Skip to main content

Patent owned by bloatware company and used to make millions invalidated

microsoft maintains right protect overseas data law enforcement lawsuit judge copyright patent infringement
Image used with permission by copyright holder
For those unfamiliar with the Uniloc USA, Inc. v. Microsoft Corp. patent lawsuit, it goes like this. A company called Uniloc, a developer of “try and buy” software (essentially bloatware) that is found in magazines and built in to new PCs, presumably found that its business model wasn’t quite as effective as it had hoped.

So the company decided to sue over 75 companies for infringement of a vague patent (the ‘216 patent) that it filed in 1996. The patent consisted of a trial-based software registration system demanding an activation code issued by the company in order for the user to fully access it. As a result, the software user would somehow manage to avoid piracy.

Unfortunately, many companies were using this system at the time. Sure, Uniloc had it patented, but it wasn’t a particularly unique proposition to begin with. Microsoft was one of the multitude of companies Uniloc sued, and Microsoft nearly lost $388 million in 2009 in the action Uniloc brought against it. The verdict, however, was overturned five months later and then revisited in 2010 when both parties decided to settle for an unknown amount.

A large number of efforts have been made, dating back to 2002, to try and invalidate Uniloc’s patent, but for whatever reason, every single one of them was rejected, until a group of notable companies formed an alliance against Uniloc founder Ric Richardson. The companies, consisting of Sega, Ubisoft, Kofax, Cambium Learning Group, and Perfect World Entertainment, decided to attack Richardson’s method of patent filing rather than the legalities of the patent itself.

After Richardson initially filed the patent in Australia, it took a year for him to repeat the process in the United States, which in turn gave the ‘216 patent an extra year’s worth of priority. That extra year, however, was exactly when the same software registration system began to emerge from other companies. What’s more, Uniloc’s U.S. patent was allegedly even more vague than what was filed in Australia.

The U.S. Patent Office did finally decide to invalidate the patent based on this information alone. Uniloc, however, still has the opportunity to appeal the decision if it so chooses.

An email from Uniloc president and IP counsel Sean Burdick offered their responsive view on the matter in an email:

The PTAB decision is inconsistent with two prior rulings by the Federal Circuit, and with the opinions of seven patent examiners who previously upheld the validity of the ‘216 patent in multiple reexaminations. Ultimately the PTAB gave undue credibility to a lone expert opinion that was authored by petitioners’ counsel. Congratulations to Erise IP for pulling wool over the eyes of the Patent Office.

Uniloc’s opponents would contend that the firm was exploiting patent laws for financial gain, and that, at least pending appeal, it can no longer do so.

Editors' Recommendations

Gabe Carey
Former Digital Trends Contributor
A freelancer for Digital Trends, Gabe Carey has been covering the intersection of video games and technology since he was 16…
Microsoft wants to use A.I. to make health care better for everyone
fitbit resting heart rate study medicine health glasses hospital clinic organ prescription doctor medical medic healthcare ap

Microsoft is bringing artificial intelligence into the health care world with the launch of a new program that aims to improve the well-being of people and communities around the globe. 

The five-year program, called A.I. for Health, will focus on advancing medical research, reducing health inequality and improving health care access, as well as compiling global health insights. The new program is part of a bigger Microsoft initiative called Microsoft A.I. for Good. 

Read more
Microsoft’s latest patent reveals a Skype-enabled smart speaker
harmon kardon invoke review top

A recently discovered Microsoft patent suggests the tech giant might enter the smart speaker field with a device of its own. The patent covers a smart speaker with a built-in projection system that could be used for Skype calls. Last month, Microsoft filed for another patent for a “Skype dock” for Apple devices. This new patent is, in a way, an evolution of the previous patent. While it centers around a different product, many of the same ideas are still present.

According to the patent, the device could allow users to make a Skype call without a PC, Mac, or mobile device. The smart speaker consists of several different parts and looks similar to an Amazon Echo or an Apple HomePod. The cylindrical shape allows the camera and the projector to move independently of one another. In theory, this means that the device could track a person as they move throughout the room so that eye contact can always be held no matter the position.

Read more
Microsoft patent reveals liquid-filled hinge to make better foldable devices
Surface Pro 6 Review

A patent filed by Microsoft reveals that the company has been working on a special kind of hinge filled with liquid that looks to solve some of the unique problems of foldable devices.

The new Microsoft patent, which was first spotted by Windows United, details a device with a foldable OLED display that comes with a hinge filled with liquid or gas.

Read more