Skip to main content

Apple requests iTunes monopoly lawsuit be dropped


Apple has requested that a federal judge dismiss an anticompetition lawsuit against the Cupertino, California-based company, which seeks to prove that Apple limited consumers’ choice with the use of proprietary software placed on its downloads, reports Bloomberg.

The lawsuit, started in 2005, claims that Apple stifled competition with an update made to its FairPlay DRM, a proprietary software, in July 2004, which prevented music downloaded through other services from working on its iPod devices. The update was launched just days after RealNetworks Inc boasted that songs from its Harmony online store could be played on iPods.

Related Videos

Apple’s legal counsel, Robert Mittelstaedt, argues that the restrictions on which music worked with iPods are not anticompetitive, but were imposed as a quality-control measure.

“Apple’s view is that iPods work better when consumers use the iTunes jukebox rather than third party software that can cause corruption or other problems,” Mittelstaedt said during a court hearing.

To backup its claims, Apple cited 58 consumer complaints as the reason for its decision to update iPods to not work with other companies’ downloads. US District Judge James Ware, to whom Apple made its dismissal request, asked whether Apple had conducted any scientific tests to confirm the dangers of allowing downloads from other sources. Apple said it had not.

Last month, a separate judge, Magistrate Judge Howard R. Lloyd, ordered that Apple CEO Steve Jobs submit to questioning in the case. Apple eventually agreed, with the stipulations that  Jobs not be asked about any matters outside of the 2004 iPod update, and not exceed more than two hours. Jobs came in for questioning on April 12.

As of March 2009, music sold on iTunes no longer comes loaded with restrictive proprietary software.

Judge Ware said he would decide whether or not to dismiss the case by May.

Editors' Recommendations

Bye bye Wi-Fi: iOS code hints Apple may switch to super fast Li-Fi on future iPhones
apple li fi ios code news iphone 6s 7840 1500x1000

Operating system code can sometimes give us clues as to where a company is headed in terms of development. And that could be happening with iOS, as one Twitter user has spotted something interesting called "LiFiCapability," which first appeared in iOS 9.1 code. It was further confirmed by Apple Insider, which claims that Apple might incorporate Li-Fi technology in future iPhones and iPads.

So what is Li-Fi and what are its advantages?
Li-Fi, which was invented by Harold Hass in 2011, is very similar to Wi-Fi in that it's used to transmit data, but it uses light-emitting diodes (LEDs) instead of radio frequency waves. It works by using visible light communications (VLC) to switch the current to the LEDs off and on at a very fast rate. Think of your lights flickering, but so quickly that you can't actually see it. It is this flickering that enables the transmission of data. What's even more interesting is that although the LEDs have to be on in order to transmit data, they could be dimmed to well below human visibility and still be effective.

Read more
GoPro’s drone is named Karma, and you should register to win one
gopro drone name karma giveaway free dt daily 00 27 19 still005

It’s Thursday December 10, 2015, and in case you aren't counting, that’s 14 shopping days left till Christmas. So, if you still have holiday shopping to do, you may now officially freak out. I know I am. Anyway, here are some of the tech stories we’re following today:

We now have a name for GoPro’s forthcoming drone. It’s called Karma, and if you’ve got some Karma points sitting in the credit column, you should plan to register to win one of 100 being given away. GoPro has been super tight-lipped about its drone, but we know it shoots gorgeous 4K video, which you see in the video above, and because it’s GoPro, there’s probably all kinds of other bad-assery in store to be excited about.

Read more
Good news, Apple fans! Kenwood announces two new CarPlay receivers
Kenwood Apple CarPlay receiver

Aftermarket Apple CarPlay options are growing more plentiful by the month, and car electronics giant Kenwood has just added two more choices to the pile.

Toward the end of September, the brand will begin shipping its smartphone-compatible DDX6702S and DDX6902S multimedia receivers to stores, both of which come equipped with the CarPlay system. The units cost $800 and $850, respectively.

Read more