Skip to main content

Future Motion withdraws patent infringement action against Changzhou

At this year’s Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas, a small group of tech journalists and spectators were treated to a bit of drama on the showroom floor, witnessing the raid of a Chinese hoverboard booth by U.S. Marshals. In what seemed like the blink of an eye, a group of Marshals stormed the Sands Expo Center to enforce a court order secured by the California startup Future Motion, which claimed Changzhou First International Trade Co. violated two of its hoverboard patents.

Now, however, in a surprising turn of events, Future Motion has decided to withdraw its lawsuit, citing a desire to be “innovating instead of litigating.” Thing is, Changzhou isn’t going away quietly.

Recommended Videos

At first glance, Changzhou’s hoverboard (dubbed the Trotter) looks wildly similar to Future Motion’s popular OneWheel (pictured above). Each boasts one giant wheel in the center of a board with a spot for a foot on either side of the wheel. To many navigating the busy hallways of CES 2016, Changzhou’s Trotter was actually mistaken for the OneWheel — a design which Future Motion had already patented prior to the show. The other patent, one which concerns how the OneWheel differs from other hoverboards, was also allegedly violated (according to Future Motion), prompting a swift visit to a judge capable of issuing a temporary restraining order.

Changzhou's Trotter hoverboard. Look familiar?
Changzhou’s Trotter hoverboard. Look familiar? Image used with permission by copyright holder

At the time of Future Motion’s filing, the company decided to initiate an “ex parte” proceeding (meaning the presence of both parties was not required) in federal court. It took the judge just seven minutes before a TRO was issued, prompting the U.S. Marshals to immediately storm the CES showroom floor and shut down Changzhou’s operation. As one would reasonably expect, this extremely peeved Changzhou, which felt cheated out of an opportunity to present at CES, so the company immediately called mega law firm Merchant & Gould and lawyered up. Future Motion may have fired the initial salvo, but Changzhou was ready for the fight; a fight that, in the end, wouldn’t happen (for the most part).

“After considering the economics of the litigation, Future Motion has voluntarily dismissed its patent infringement lawsuit against Changzhou First International Trade Co.,” OneWheel tells Ars Technica. “In view of apparently minimal U.S. sales of the accused CZ-First product, Future Motion determined that the likely costs of continuing litigation would outweigh the potential benefits.”

So while Future Motion ditched the lawsuit, Changzhou fired back and filed a motion of its own which seeks to obtain the attorney fees expended during the controversy. Changzhou argues that it did not violate any patents filed by Future Motion and maintains that Future Motion initially filed the lawsuit to gain notoriety and raise money. Above those claims, however, Changzhou felt more damaged by the fact it wasn’t allowed to continue participating in CES, an event it felt was perfect for advancing awareness of its own product and its sales.

Future Motion's OneWheel
Future Motion’s OneWheel OneWheel

“[CES] was a major opportunity for Changzhou to promote sales of its Trotter product,” the lawsuit contends. “Instead, FM [Future Motion] orchestrated an effort to obtain a baseless TRO and to effect seizure of Changzhou’s products from CES. These acts caused Changzhou to lose sales and suffer public embarrassment at a critical juncture in marketing its new Trotter product.”

The lawyer continues by stating that Future Motion shouldn’t be allowed to “slink away unnoticed with no repercussions,” and asked for $100k in damages (along with attorney’s fees) to atone for the alleged lost sales and damage to its reputation. The company also wants Future Motion to issue an official press release in which it admits to dropping the case against Changzhou. Future Motion has yet to make any move regarding the recent motion but has until Monday, February 22 to do so.

Rick Stella
Former Associate Editor, Outdoor
Rick became enamored with technology the moment his parents got him an original NES for Christmas in 1991. And as they say…
Sebastian Stan lays out Bucky’s future after Thunderbolts
Sebastian Stan in Thunderbolts.

There are some spoilers ahead for the ending of Marvel's Thunderbolts. Stop reading now if you don't want to be spoiled.

Earlier this year, Captain America: Brave New World briefly introduced a new direction for James "Bucky" Barnes, a character Sebastian Stan has been playing since 2011 in Captain America: The First Avenger. In Brave New World, the former Winter Soldier apparently retired from being a reformed hero and went into politics by running for Congress. Thunderbolts reveals that Bucky won his election to the House of Representatives. But his stay in Congress was short.

Read more
Jeep Compass EV breaks cover—but will it come to the U.S.?
jeep compass ev us newjeepcompassfirsteditionhawaii  4

Jeep just pulled the wraps off the all-new Compass EV, and while it’s an exciting leap into the electric future, there's a catch—it might not make it to the U.S. anytime soon.
This is a brand new electric version of the Jeep Compass, and being built on Stellantis' STLA platform—the same architecture underpinning models like the Peugeot E-3008 and E-5008—it looks much slicker and packs a lot more inside than previous versions of the Compass.
Let’s start with what’s cool: the new Compass EV is packing up to 404 miles of range on a single charge, a 74 kWh battery, and fast-charging that gets you from 20% to 80% in about 30 minutes. Not bad for a compact SUV with Jeep's badge on the nose.
There are two versions: a front-wheel-drive model with 213 horsepower and a beefier all-wheel-drive version with 375 horsepower. That AWD setup isn’t just for looks—it can handle 20% inclines even without front traction, and comes with extra ground clearance and better off-road angles. In short, it’s still a Jeep.
The design's been refreshed too, and inside you’ll find the kind of tech and comfort you’d expect in a modern EV—sleek, smart, and ready for both city streets and dirt trails.
But here’s the thing: even though production starts soon in Italy, Jeep hasn’t said whether the Compass EV is coming to America. And the signs aren’t promising.
Plans to build it in Canada were recently put on hold, with production now delayed until at least early 2026. Some of that might have to do with possible U.S. tariffs on Canadian and Mexican vehicles—adding a layer of uncertainty to the whole rollout.
According to Kelley Blue Book, a Stellantis spokesperson confirmed that the company has “temporarily paused work on the next-generation Jeep Compass, including activities at” the Canadian plant that was originally meant to build the model. They added that Stellantis is “reassessing its product strategy in North America” to better match customer needs and demand for different powertrain options.
So while Europe and other markets are gearing up to get the Compass EV soon, American drivers might be left waiting—or miss out entirely.
That’s a shame, because on paper, this electric Jeep hits a lot of sweet spots. Let’s just hope it finds a way over here.

Read more
Charlie Cox singles out his least favorite Daredevil: Born Again episode
Charlie Cox in Daredevil: Born Again.

Daredevil: Born Again season 1 was largely reconceived after the 2023 actor and writer strikes. Dario Scardapane -- a veteran of The Punisher series on Netflix -- was brought in to be the new showrunner and he made a lot of changes to the series that were well-received. However, there's one episode that Scardapane didn't really change at all, and it happens to be the least favorite episode of Daredevil: Born Again's leading man, Charlie Cox.

During an appearance on The Playlist, Cox noted that he wasn't very fond of the season's fifth episode, "With Interest," which was a largely standalone episode that featured his character, Matt Murdock, in a bank during a hostage crisis.

Read more