Future Motion withdraws patent infringement action against Changzhou

future motion drops hoverboard lawsuit onewheel1
At this year’s Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas, a small group of tech journalists and spectators were treated to a bit of drama on the showroom floor, witnessing the raid of a Chinese hoverboard booth by U.S. Marshals. In what seemed like the blink of an eye, a group of Marshals stormed the Sands Expo Center to enforce a court order secured by the California startup Future Motion, which claimed Changzhou First International Trade Co. violated two of its hoverboard patents.

Now, however, in a surprising turn of events, Future Motion has decided to withdraw its lawsuit, citing a desire to be “innovating instead of litigating.” Thing is, Changzhou isn’t going away quietly.

At first glance, Changzhou’s hoverboard (dubbed the Trotter) looks wildly similar to Future Motion’s popular OneWheel (pictured above). Each boasts one giant wheel in the center of a board with a spot for a foot on either side of the wheel. To many navigating the busy hallways of CES 2016, Changzhou’s Trotter was actually mistaken for the OneWheel — a design which Future Motion had already patented prior to the show. The other patent, one which concerns how the OneWheel differs from other hoverboards, was also allegedly violated (according to Future Motion), prompting a swift visit to a judge capable of issuing a temporary restraining order.

Changzhou's Trotter hoverboard. Look familiar?
Changzhou’s Trotter hoverboard. Look familiar?

At the time of Future Motion’s filing, the company decided to initiate an “ex parte” proceeding (meaning the presence of both parties was not required) in federal court. It took the judge just seven minutes before a TRO was issued, prompting the U.S. Marshals to immediately storm the CES showroom floor and shut down Changzhou’s operation. As one would reasonably expect, this extremely peeved Changzhou, which felt cheated out of an opportunity to present at CES, so the company immediately called mega law firm Merchant & Gould and lawyered up. Future Motion may have fired the initial salvo, but Changzhou was ready for the fight; a fight that, in the end, wouldn’t happen (for the most part).

“After considering the economics of the litigation, Future Motion has voluntarily dismissed its patent infringement lawsuit against Changzhou First International Trade Co.,” OneWheel tells Ars Technica. “In view of apparently minimal U.S. sales of the accused CZ-First product, Future Motion determined that the likely costs of continuing litigation would outweigh the potential benefits.”

So while Future Motion ditched the lawsuit, Changzhou fired back and filed a motion of its own which seeks to obtain the attorney fees expended during the controversy. Changzhou argues that it did not violate any patents filed by Future Motion and maintains that Future Motion initially filed the lawsuit to gain notoriety and raise money. Above those claims, however, Changzhou felt more damaged by the fact it wasn’t allowed to continue participating in CES, an event it felt was perfect for advancing awareness of its own product and its sales.

Future Motion's OneWheel
Future Motion’s OneWheel OneWheel

“[CES] was a major opportunity for Changzhou to promote sales of its Trotter product,” the lawsuit contends. “Instead, FM [Future Motion] orchestrated an effort to obtain a baseless TRO and to effect seizure of Changzhou’s products from CES. These acts caused Changzhou to lose sales and suffer public embarrassment at a critical juncture in marketing its new Trotter product.”

The lawyer continues by stating that Future Motion shouldn’t be allowed to “slink away unnoticed with no repercussions,” and asked for $100k in damages (along with attorney’s fees) to atone for the alleged lost sales and damage to its reputation. The company also wants Future Motion to issue an official press release in which it admits to dropping the case against Changzhou. Future Motion has yet to make any move regarding the recent motion but has until Monday, February 22 to do so.

Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Robo sidekicks, AC for your bed, and more

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the Web this week. You can't buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!

Apple preps production of updated MacBook Air for a 2018 launch

To reach its rumored launch timeline of later this year for its low-cost notebook, Apple is expected to begin production of its updated MacBook Air soon. The sub-$1,000 laptop could launch as early as September or October.

Samsung confirms the debut of its foldable smartphone isn't far away

Samsung has been showcasing bendable display tech for a few years now and a folding smartphone might finally become a reality. The Galaxy X, or perhaps the Galaxy F, may be the company's first example. Here's everything we know about it.
Product Review

Traeger’s Timberline smoker starts to get smart, but isn't ready to graduate

Renowned for its line of wood pellet grills, Traeger has taken its game to the next level with the Timberline 850 Wi-Fi-controlled grill. Just how smart is this smoker? Read our review.

The best Xbox One games (August 2018)

More than four years into its lifespan, Microsoft's latest console is finally coming into its own. From 'Cuphead' to 'Halo 5,' the best Xbox One games offer something for everyone.
Emerging Tech

NASA’s Parker Solar Probe sets out to try and ‘touch’ the sun

A NASA probe launched on a journey to take measurement of the atmosphere of the Sun, hopefully uncovering crucial details about the origins of the solar winds generated there.
Emerging Tech

‘Rogue medicine in a bathtub’: 4 experts on the vice and virtue of pharma hacking

A biohacker, pharmahacker, and two bioethicists walk into a bar. We ordered them a metaphorical round and had a chat about the risks and rewards of DIY medicine — from unsanctioned gene therapy to medication made on the kitchen counter.
Emerging Tech

The Perseid meteor shower peaks this weekend! Here’s how to watch

Thanks to a new moon, 2018's Perseid Meteor Shower will be much easier to view, with even the dimmest meteors observable by the naked eye. Here's how to see the show this weekend, and where the views will be the best.
Emerging Tech

Don’t get burned! How to back crowdfunding projects the smart way

In the world of crowdfunding, there’s no such thing as a sure thing. There's a million reasons why a project might fail. But with this handy guide, you'll be able to spot the signs of a sketchy project and decrease your chances of getting…
Emerging Tech

Stanford A.I. can realistically score computer animations just by watching them

Researchers at Stanford University have developed a computer system that’s able to synthesize realistic sounds for 3D animation, based entirely on its knowledge about the physical world.
Emerging Tech

No keyboard? No problem. Masterkey will project you a virtual one to type on

Miss having a physical keyboard when you're out and about? Wish you could have a mobile display bigger than your smartphone can offer? Masterkey 4.0 is a wireless projector that promises to help.

You don’t need to go autonomous to make trucking safer

Long haul truckers are very good at their jobs, but they face long hours and unpredictable conditions. Autonomous tech may be coming, but here’s how lidar technology companies are working to enhance trucking safety today.
Emerging Tech

Be a master of your own ever-changing ‘galaxy’ with this kinetic wall art

Art Machine is a stunning work of kinetic art that looks like a continuously swirling galaxy or turbulent weather formation viewed through a ship's porthole. Check it out in all its glory.
Emerging Tech

Omega Centauri hosts 10 million stars and probably not an ounce of life

Omega Centauri is about 16,000 light years away, making it visible to the naked eye. And it contains some 10 million stars, making it the largest globular cluster in the Milky Way. But it probably doesn't have an ounce of life.