Activision Sues to Dodge Gibson Patent

By Geoff Duncan March 13, 2008

Guitar Hero franchise-holder Activision has filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court in Los Angeles seeking to establish that its popular game doesn’t infringe on a 1999 patent held by Gibson Musical Instruments, the maker of classic electric guitar models like the Les Paul.

Gibson’s patent describes a system where a user would wear a 3D virtual reality headset and play along to a pre-recorded concert on a musical instrument. The system would "simulate participation in a concert" by letting a user play along with the recording and see events from on on-stage point of view. Gibson has apparently applying pressure on Activision, claiming the company needs to execute a license to Gibson’s patent if it wants to keep selling entries in its Guitar Hero franchise.

Activision says it doesn’t need a license to Gibson’s patent, and has filed a lawsuit to get a ruling to that effect. "We disagree with the applicability of their patent and would like a legal determination on this," George Rose, Activision’s general counsel, said in a statement Wednesday.

Guitar Hero doesn’t involve a 3D headset or an actual musical instrument: Guitar Hero "guitars" are really just plastic guitar shaped controllers that offer a different interface to a game console’s standard commands. Activision has licensed several guitar designs from Gibson for use as game controllers and in-game elements, including the iconic Les Paul solidbody guitar design.

It’s not clear why Gibson has waited so long to bring up this patent with Activision. Guitar Hero hit the market more than three years ago, and Gibson has been working as Activision’s parter on the franchise. Gibson’s actions could conceivable constitute granting Activision an implied license to the patent even if it were found to be applicable to the Guitar Hero game.

Editors' Recommendations

New York City sues Activision Blizzard over Microsoft deal

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…

Gaming

Best Lego deals: Save on Star Wars, Marvel, Technic and more

legos new space shuttle set includes hubble telescope model lego discovery

If you're trying to get away from your screen, such as by reading a book or playing board games, one great alternative is to build Lego. One of the most popular brands on the planet with millions upon millions of new bricks made every year, there is seemingly a Lego set for pretty much anything. Whether you love the Marvel universe and want to build the Infinity Gauntlet or are really into cars and want to build a Lamborghini, there's very likely a set out there for you. To that end, we've gone out and collected some of our favorite Lego deals across various categories, although if you don't find what you're looking for, you could check out some of these great board game deals as well.

Today's Best Lego Marvel Deals

Gaming

VR headset deals: Meta Quest 2 and VIVE XR

htc vive vs pro headphones

VR tech is pretty interesting, and while it's not as big as other forms of gaming, it's grown quite significantly since the original Oculus Go was released. In fact, there are some highly acclaimed modern VR games like Half-Life: Alyx that are a lot of fun, and with something like the Meta Quest, you don't even need a high-end gaming PC to run it. Luckily, even if you've spent money on one of many gaming PC deals out there, you can still buy a high-end VR headset that can use all that power. To that end, we've collected deals on some of the best VR headsets on the market, although if you're not quite ready to take that plunge, check out some of these other great video game deals.
Meta Quest 2 -- $199, was $200

Even though the Meta Quest 3 came out quite recently, the Meta Quest 2 is still a pretty powerful contender, especially since it has a wider library and app support than the Quest 3 currently has. Even more so, the Quest 2 is a lot cheaper than the Quest 3, and with the latest permanent discount down to just $200, that's a whole $300 or so difference from the Quest 3. Of course, the Quest 3 does have more advanced AR and slightly better performance with software and Wi-Fi, but that may not be worth the extra cost for some. Either way, be sure to check out the breakdown between Quest 2 and Quest 3 to get a better sense of what you should pick up.

Gaming

Hellblade 2 struggles to balance a serious message and video game tropes

Senua stares at a burning tree in Hellblade 2.

For the first two hours of Senua's Saga: Hellblade 2, I was fully transported into Senua's headspace. Every aspect of the sequel's design was working in concert to pull me into her mind and never let me go. And then I found my first collectible.

I missed out on the first Hellblade, but was familiar enough to know what the general consensus was regarding its strengths and weaknesses. I knew it was a narrative-driven game about a very serious mental health condition. What I never heard about, and thus didn't know to expect until I came across it, was something as "gamey" as collectibles. In most games, collectibles can be a way to reward exploration, add lore to the world, or simply be an added objective for those who want to do and see it all. In the case of Hellblade 2, however, it's one small piece of a larger issue: The series' video game instincts betraying the serious tone and subject matter that the rest of the subversive experience is so committed to.
Wall hugging
At first, Hellblade 2 gripped me like few games have. You already know just how impressive this game is from a visual standpoint from trailers and screenshots, but it's the 3D audio that pushes it into a league of its own. That first scene of Senua nearly drowning in the ocean while competing voices attempt to encourage and demoralize her instantly established an empathetic link between us. The tight perspective of the camera, the framing of Senua and her detailed facial animations, and the lack of a head-up display (HUD) all made sure that link remained unbroken.