While Comcast and Time Warner plan their marriage, other networks cry foul

comcast time warner merger cogent center
Comcast's corporate headquarters in Philadelphia

If you don’t believe the proposed Comcast/Time Warner merger will make Comcast an even bigger threat to net neutrality, you probably haven’t heard the whole story. As Comcast attempted to lay out the benefits of the $45.2 billion merger yesterday before Congress – a deal which would corral up to 40 percent of all U.S. Internet subscribers under one umbrella – the CEO of another powerful Internet player, Cogent’s Dave Schaeffer, put in a tenacious argument as to why the merger could be extremely dangerous.

His argument: Comcast is already a bully, and letting it merge with Time Warner will just give it more weight to throw around.

It all goes back to the politics of pipes – the unseen ones that route content from thousands of miles away all the way down the cable in your yard, into your living room and onto your screen. Comcast may own the pipes in your neighborhood, but it doesn’t own the ones all over the country – those belong to backbone providers like Cogent. While you might expect Comcast to have to pay to use those backbones, it has actually been trying to reverse the tables and extract cash from two of them: Cogent and Level 3. Level 3 reportedly already caved to Comcast, but Cogent refuses to co-operate.

“Comcast does not operate a global network. In fact, it should be buying connectivity to the global Internet”

Shaeffer explained before a House Judiciary committee just why his company refuses to pay fealty to Comcast, and why a merger with Time Warner Cable is the last thing the Internet – and consumers who use it – need. “Comcast does not operate a global network. In fact, it should be buying connectivity to the global Internet but has used its market scale and scope to extract an unusual concession,” Schaeffer explained, according to ArsTechnica. “Because it represented so many customers, Internet backbone operators like Cogent and others agreed to peer with them. That wasn’t good enough for Comcast. As Comcast’s market power continued to increase and consumers had less choice, they actually started demanding payments for connectivity. A larger Comcast will be able to demand even greater payments.”

Schaefer’s assertion that Comcast “does not operate a global network” has to do with the fact that the company is not what is considered a Tier 1 Network, such as Cogent, which has peering agreements with other Tier 1’s to help create the fundamental infrastructure of the Internet.

Basically, a Tier 1 network is a backbone service that can reach every other network on the Web without the need to pay for transit. Comcast doesn’t have that kind of reach, but even if it did, Tier 1 providers generally don’t pay to exchange information with each other. The free exchange of transit is what helps make the World Wide Web, well, world wide. And that general agreement between those with the biggest reach helps keep things even for all parties online so that services can connect to anyone, anywhere.

Dave Schaeffer
Cogent Founder and CEO

But Comcast is so big, and holds so many subscribers, it is able to extract payment from virtually any service that wants access to its cache of customers. That includes Level 3 and Netflix. Netflix recently agreed to make a deal with Comcast — and Verizon as well — when its streaming service slowed down to a near halt for its customers who subscribe to those ISPs. A similar deal is reportedly in the works with AT&T. Netflix reluctantly made those deals for direct connection to Comcast and Verizon in an effort to alleviate the streaming speed issues. But the plot gets even more insidious. 

Cogent and Level 3 have recently accused several ISPs of deliberately slowing video traffic for the past year, in a direct effort to extract cash from services like Netflix and Tier 1 networks alike. The companies assert that large ISPs like Comcast and AT&T have simply refused to upgrade their own infrastructure at the same rate as Tier 1 services, in effect, blackmailing services to pay up, and worse, using their own Internet subscribers as hostages. The ISPs wait for fees to roll in, while their own subscribers deal with slower streaming speeds from their favorite sites.

Netflix’s own speed Index reports tell the tale, showing Comcast subscribers whose streaming speeds went down in recent months, then popped back up after money changed hands and Netflix began circumventing Level 3 and Cogent to connect to Comcast directly.

Not surprisingly, Comcast takes issue with Schaeffer’s account. A joint written statement by Comcast’s David Cohen and Time Warner’s Robert Marcus took issue with Schaeffer’s assessment of the merger’s dangers, painting Netflix’s high-volume service as a special case.

“Importantly, no content provider is ever compelled to interconnect directly with Comcast’s or TWC’s ISP networks,” the statement said. “The overwhelming majority of content from across the globe comes into Comcast’s ISP network over its settlement-free connections with its peers, without the content provider having any direct relationship with Comcast. Those connections are always an option for every content provider, and they are always open — in fact, they are the lifeblood of Comcast’s Internet business because they are also how Comcast gets its customers’ content to and from the rest of the world.”

Just how much more powerful would Comcast become by acquiring Time Warner, and cornering the ISP market even further?

While it may be true that no content provider is “compelled to interconnect directly” with Comcast, as the recent numbers of Netflix’s sluggish streams show, those content providers who want to hold on to their customers just might be. If people can’t stream Netflix, people won’t use it. And if Comcast along with other ISPs like Verizon truly did extract payment from Netflix by intentionally slowing streams to all of Level 3 and Cogent’s clients, it begs the question: Just how much more brazen would Comcast become by acquiring Time Warner, and cornering the ISP market even further?

Cogent certainly has its own reasons to stop Comcast in its tracks, namely the cash it could lose as streaming video companies like Netflix make direct deals with ISPs and no longer pay it for transit. But if the rumors are true, and ISPs are already throttling video to extract money from a host of services, letting Comcast balloon even further seems like a pretty bad move.

With net neutrality surfacing as a hot-button issue lately, advocates are looking to the FCC’s recent proposals as a sort of Internet doomsday. But if the throttling rumors are true, the monster may already be inside the door. Cogent’s David Schaeffer just doesn’t want that monster to get any bigger.

Home Theater

Netflix vs. Hulu vs. Amazon Prime: Battle of the streaming giants

Trying to figure out which subscription streaming service to use while sticking to a frugal entertainment budget? Check out our updated comparison of the big three: Netflix, Amazon Instant Video, and Hulu.

Here's our head-to-head comparison of Pandora and Spotify

Which music streaming platform is best for you? We pit Spotify versus Pandora, two mighty streaming services with on-demand music and massive catalogs, comparing every facet of the two services to help you decide which is best.

Spotify is the best streaming service, but its competitors aren’t far behind

It can be hard to decide which music streaming service is for you, so we've picked out the individual strengths of the most popular services, aiming to make your decision a little easier.
Movies & TV

Lose the torrents. Here's how to watch 'Game of Thrones' online (legally)

Game of Thrones is one of the most popular shows on TV, but unless you're a cable subscriber, finding a way to watch isn't always easy. Check out our guide on how to watch online, whether you prefer using HBO, Hulu, or Amazon.
Home Theater

Set your ears free with the best completely wireless earbuds

If you can't stand the tangle of cords, or you're just excited about completely wireless earbuds, you're going to need some help separating the wheat from the chaff. Our list serves up the best true wireless earbuds around.
Home Theater

From the Roku Ultra to the Fire TV Cube, these are the best streaming devices

There are more options for media streamers than ever, so it’s more difficult to pick the best option. But that’s why we're here. Our curated list of the best streaming devices will get you online in no time.
Home Theater

Streaming services blast past networks for the most scripted TV shows in 2018

For the first time in history, streaming services like Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon, produced more original scripted series than broadcast or cable channels, setting a new record for the number of TV shows on the air.
Home Theater

Block the outside world, tune into your own with the best in-ear headphones

Over-the-ear headphones offer top-flight sound, but they're not so easy to take along with you. If you're looking to upgrade your portable sound, check out our favorite in-ear headphones -- there's a model for every user and every budget.
Home Theater

These awesome A/V receivers will swarm you with surround sound at any budget

There is no one-size-fits-all approach to shopping for a receiver, so we assembled our favorites for 2018, at multiple price points and all loaded with features, from Dolby Atmos to 4K HDR, and much more.
Movies & TV

Celebrate the 25th anniversary of ‘The X-Files’ with the show’s 10 best episodes

The X-Files premiered 25 years ago, so here are the 10 best episodes of the award-winning sci-fi series. From alien-abduction drama to hilarious satires, these are the best episodes from all 11 seasons of the hit series.
Movies & TV

Can't get enough lightsaber action? Here's how to get your Star Wars fix online

Few of us want to deal with DVDs or Blu-ray discs anymore. Unfortunately, the Star Wars movies are few and far between when it comes to streaming. If you want to watch Star Wars online, check out our guide on where to find the films online.
Home Theater

How to master your equalizer settings for the perfect sound

You may know what an EQ is, but do you know how to adjust equalizer settings for the best possible sound? We go through the basics of the modern EQ and lay out some guidelines for how to achieve tip-top sound from your system.
Home Theater

Confused about LED vs. LCD TVs? Here's everything you need to know

Our LED vs. LCD TV buying guide explains why these two common types of displays are fundamentally connected, how they differ, what to look for in buying an LED TV, and what's on the horizon for TVs.
Home Theater

What is Terrarium TV? Here’s everything you need to know

Terrarium TV offered a way to watch movies & TV for free, but now after a troubled existence, the app's developer has shut it down, and offered an ominous message to users on his way out.