Skip to main content

The Roku-YouTube-YouTube TV impasse isn’t over yet

It’s been several months since Roku and YouTube TV reached a cease-fire in their dispute over … well, over a few things. But it now looks like the war is heating back up.

To recap, Roku in April 2021 first announced that negotiations that would extend YouTube TV’s availability on the Roku platform had broken down. In doing so, it said that “Roku cannot accept Google’s unfair terms as we believe they could harm our users.” Exactly what those disputed terms are has been a little ambiguous. Roku has said it has to do with search results. Google calls any allegations baseless.

And today, in a rather long blog post for this sort of thing, Roku has renewed its complaints while shining a little more light on the conflict. That light, no doubt, is tinted in Roku’s distinct purple color, but there’s a good bit to glean here.

More on the Roku-YouTube dispute

YouTube TV on Roku.
Phil Nickinson/Digital Trends

First is that it’s pretty obvious that no deal has been reached that would allow YouTube TV back onto the Roku platform like any other streaming service. Currently, those who already had YouTube TV installed could keep using it. Google rigged up a workaround by which the YouTube TV experience can be launched from within the YouTube channel itself, but that’s not really ideal for anyone. And that was a bold move, all but daring Roku to shut down the world’s default streaming video service on its platform. (YouTube TV is only available in the U.S,, and in October 2020 announced that it had more than 3 million subscribers.)

Roku tips its hand a little with the following:

Content available on our platform includes TV streaming services that are owned and operated by some of the most powerful tech companies in the world who also sell their own competing streaming devices.

Read between those lines, and you get a sense that Roku is worried not just about the $50 Chromecast with Google TV — which directly competes with the likes of the Roku Streaming Stick 4K, as well as with other low-cost televisions that use the Roku operating system.

Roku flat-out says that “our concerns with Google are not about money.” Perhaps all this really is about principle, but it’s hard to believe that someone actually wrote that line with a straight face. Roku goes on to say that “We have not asked for a single change in the financial terms of our existing agreement. In fact, Roku does not earn a single dollar from YouTube’s ad-supported video sharing service today, whereas Google makes hundreds of millions of dollars from the YouTube app on Roku.”

That’s conflating a few things that are related but not the same. YouTube is not YouTube TV, even though those lines certainly are more blurry than any of the other live TV streaming services, like Hulu or Sling TV. What Roku doesn’t say is whether the concern is over any sort of fees it might be demanding over the advertising shown on YouTube TV. Perhaps YouTube TV doesn’t want to pay as high a rate as it’s currently paying, thus the impasse.

Roku does lay out things fairly succinctly, though not necessarily with any great fidelity:

​There are two primary concerns we are working to address: First, Google continues to interfere with Roku’s independent search results, requiring that we preference YouTube over other content providers. This is a concern shared by many companies who believe that customers deserve neutral and relevant results to their search queries. Second, Google discriminates against Roku by demanding search, voice, and data features that they do not insist on from other streaming platforms. ​

What that has to do with YouTube TV isn’t exactly clear. Nor does it mean that Roku and YouTube and YouTube TV and Google (and Alphabet, we suppose, which is the parent company for the latter three) can’t reach some sort of deal by what Deadline has said is a December 9 deadline, at which point new Roku users would be unable to download YouTube apps. (There’s precedent for that, by the way — Amazon Fire TV went a long time without a proper YouTube app.)

Editors' Recommendations

Phil Nickinson
Section Editor, Audio/Video
Phil spent the 2000s making newspapers with the Pensacola (Fla.) News Journal, the 2010s with Android Central and then the…
YouTube TV is still growing on the back of NFL Sunday Ticket
YouTube TV showing NFL games and bowling in multiview.

Not being able to pick your own games means YouTube TV's multiview could get you two NFL games (one twice) ... and bowling. Phil Nickinson / Digital Trends

One of our favorite (and more annoying) games to play is “Which streaming service is the biggest?” And for the most part, we tend to have pretty strong answers. YouTube TV is the biggest, probably. It’s followed by Hulu With Live TV, then Sling TV, and then FuboTV. And DirecTV Stream is way at the back of the pack. Again, probably.

Read more
YouTube rolling out some three-dozen new features this fall
The Digital Trends YouTube channel as seen on an iPhone and on a TV in the background.

The tweaks keep coming to the world's largest video provide. Today YouTube is taking the wraps off some three-dozen (more or less) new features. It's a cross-platform announcement, with the goods hitting phones and tablets, as well as televisions and wherever else you do your YouTube viewing.

Here's what you have to look forward to:

Read more
Multiview almost fixes one of the biggest problems with YouTube TV
Three college football games (and one ad) seen on a large TV on YouTube TV.

Flipping through the myriad college football games on a recent weekend, I was struck by a revelation: Multiview on YouTube TV — even in its imperfect, inflexible form — nearly fixes one of my biggest gripes about the leading live streaming platform.

The "problem" really isn't a problem insofar as anything is actually broken. It's just the way YouTube TV works, and it's almost certainly something done by design. If you're a habitual channel-flipper, you already know full well how streaming services like YouTube TV, Hulu With Live TV, and other options aren't exactly known for making it quick to fly through the channels, one after another.

Read more