Skip to main content

Dissatisfied iPad owners take Apple to court over AppleCare+

Apple finds itself back in court, but instead of getting in trouble over possible patent infringement, the Cupertino company finds itself potentially in hot water over its AppleCare and AppleCare+ plans, reports AppleInsider.

The lawsuit, filed in the Northern California District Court by Vicky Maldonado and Joanne McRight, stems from Maldonado’s experience with her third-generation iPad, According to the plaintiff, her iPad’s screen cracked after she owned the tablet for six months. Because Maldonado accidentally damaged her iPad, she was told she needed to pay $250 for a replacement. Furthermore, she was told that replacing a device under AppleCare+ will cost her $100.

Recommended Videos

As a result, Maldonado purchased a fourth-generation iPad and AppleCare+ in September 2013. AppleCare+, an offshoot of the regular AppleCare, covers customers for two years and allows them to make two claims due to damage they might incur. The price of AppleCare+, which must be purchased within 60 days of a device’s initial purchase, range from $50 when buying an iPad to $100 for buying an iPhone 6S.

Maldonado alleges she received a refurbished device in May 2015, but was not told she would receive a refurbished device as a replacement. According to the lawsuit, this goes against the terms of AppleCare+, which state that customers will receive “a device that was new or equivalent to new in performance …”

The issue the lawsuit raises concerns how “new” and “refurbished” are defined. The complaint alleged that replacements are not “equivalent to new” because “refurbished devices can never be the equivalent to new in performance …”

“‘New’ means a Device that has never been utilized or previously sold and consists of all new parts,” reads the lawsuit. “The word ‘refurbished’ appears only once in the AppleCare+ terms and conditions even though the printed booklet is 33 pages long. The word is not even used to reference a device, but a part.”

Because of the nature of the lawsuit, since the action was brought on behalf of customers who bought an AppleCare or AppleCare+ plan for their iPhone, iPad, or iPod Touch after July 11, 2011, an Apple loss means all of those customers, including Maldonado and McRight, will receive some sort of compensation. Both defendants also seek an injunction prohibiting Apple from sending out refurbished devices as replacements, along with changes to the AppleCare+ terms and conditions, and the ability for customers to receive the full purchase price of a damaged device.

Williams Pelegrin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Williams is an avid New York Yankees fan, speaks Spanish, resides in Colorado, and has an affinity for Frosted Flakes. Send…
What’s the best iPad screen size: should you go 11-inch or 13-inch?
13-inch iPad Air (2025) with iPad Air 4 and iPad Mini 7 in the background.

The Apple iPad lineup is bigger than ever. Previously, when choosing an iPad Air, you just needed to consider storage capacity and cellular capabilities. Now, like the iPad Pro, you also get to choose between two screen sizes. I’ve received emails from readers confused about whether the 13-inch model is a better pick for watching movies. The short answer? No. A bigger iPad doesn’t necessarily mean a better screen for video consumption.

I recently switched to the 13-inch iPad Air (2025) from my 11-inch iPad Air (2020), and it made me realize that both tablets are made for different use cases. If you're confused about which screen size is right for your next iPad Air or iPad Pro, here’s a breakdown based on my experience.
Look at the aspect ratio, not the display size
13-inch iPad Air (2025) display Prakhar Khanna / Digital Trends

Read more
iPad is the best secondary screen I’ve used with a MacBook
You can extend your MacBook's screen by using an iPad as a secondary monitor.

I spend an unhealthy amount of time lurking in communities where people share aesthetic desktop setups. One of my friends recently set the group chat on fire with a triple monitor setup that had two vertical screens and an ultrawide curved panel at the center. An impulse swipe later, I achieved a similar makeover for my desk at home.

Here’s the problem, though. My $600 workstation overhaul did bring me visual joy, but not much utility. For reporting assignments, I spend the majority of the year away from home, working from deserted cafes or unnaturally uncomfortable bunk beds. I do miss the convenience of large secondary screens. Interestingly, that yearning is addressed by a rather unconventional device —the humble iPad. 

Read more
Apple iPhone owners urged to download new update now as a security must
An iPhone showing the Apple Password app.

The new iPhone software update, iOS 18.4, could be more critical than is being talked about when it comes to security.

While there are lots of new features added in the latest release, out yesterday, what's less talked about is the 62 security updates and fixes that roll out with this version. Some are quite serious.

Read more