Skip to main content

The $4 smartphone in India is probably too good to be true

Sure, you can get this smartphone in India for a fraction of the price of an iPhone, but are you also getting a fraction (or even less) of the quality? After being stunned by the mere existence of a $4 smartphone in southeast Asia, market experts and analysts are now crying foul play on this deal that really does seem to drive home the point: when things seem too good to be true, they probably are.

On Wednesday this week, Ringing Bells debuted its Freedom 251 smartphone, with relatively admirable features including a 4-inch display, 1.3-GHz quad-core processor, and 8 GB of storage. Made in India and cheaper than a meal at McDonald’s, the phone was sold for just 251 rupees, or $3.65. The idea, the company said, was to grant a greater proportion of the Indian population access to smartphone technology, helping to bring one of the world’s most populous nations online. But now, everyone has their guard up.

Recommended Videos

“This seems to be a joke or a scam. It is something we are very upset about,” said Pankaj Mohindroo, national president of the Indian Cellular Association. “This is being investigated by various government authorities.” Mohindroo noted that the retail price of the phone doesn’t even cover the cost of its parts — in a letter to India’s Minister for Communications and I.T., the Association president pointed out that a phone using the least expensive parts available would still have to cost at least $40, and after taxes and duties were factored into consideration, would have to go for a bare minimum of $52.

Those outside the country expressed similar concerns — according to Richard Windsor, an analyst at Edison Investment Research, Ringing Bells puts itself $26 in the hole with each smartphone it sells at the sub-$4 price. “This launch has generated a lot of waves, and we suspect that either after the first batch has been sold, the price goes up to $53 per device or that the company quietly disappears,” he told CNN. “There is no way that these economics add up in the long term.”

But beyond the economics of the smartphone, others are pointing out that the device itself is complete trash. According to Android Authority, “the Freedom 251 is actually the Adcom Ikon 4, an entry-level Chinese smartphone. Not only is this a scam, but it’s one where the scam artist isn’t even trying! What’s more, the device looks nothing like the smartphone advertised on Ringing Bells’ website.”

While cheap smartphones in India are nothing new, the almost absurd price point of the Freedom 251 created quite a frenzy in the country — the company’s site actually crashed after being overloaded by some 600,000 hits per second. But whether all that hype will actually come to fruition has yet to be determined — deliveries for the phone are expected by June.

Lulu Chang
Fascinated by the effects of technology on human interaction, Lulu believes that if her parents can use your new app…
Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 7: the upgrade we’ve been waiting for?
Thre Flip 7 models next to each other

I never really thought that I'd want to go down the route of owning a flip phone, ever since I swore off my Nokia in the early 2000s (you know, the one with the weird felt covering and tiny notification window).

Fast forward two decades, and I'm considering rejoining the race, thanks to the Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 7. Coming in at $1,100, it's not cheap, but it's definitely something different compared to the world of black rectangles, and it it feels like Samsung’s Flip family has finally come of age.

Read more
I used the Galaxy Z Fold 7, here’s why I’m completely smitten
The back of the Galaxy Z Fold 7

We’ve waited several years for Samsung to join the party, but it’s finally here: Samsung has followed rivals like Oppo, OnePlus, and Honor in building a thinner, lighter, and sleeker Galaxy Z Fold 7. It’s an impressive feat of engineering and a major upgrade over previous years.

It’s easy to consider the Fold 7 nothing more than an update to the Galaxy Z Fold 6, but in many ways, it feels like a huge step forward, not just for Samsung but for all folding phones. I spent a few hours with the Galaxy Z Fold 7 in an exclusive preview, and here’s why I absolutely love what Samsung has done this year.

Read more
I tried the Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 series – they’re sleek, but with a lot to prove
Watch 8 on a wrist

Trying out the Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 and Watch 8 Classic is a tough gig - not in terms of it being a hardship to try out two high-end models, but that it's impossible to assess them with only 30 minutes’ use.

I can easily talk about the improved design and the fit of the straps etc, but the real changes are within the health ecosystem, and they'll need sustained testing to really understand if they're any good.

Read more