Samsung’s Galaxy still isn’t big enough to conquer Times Square


When word began circulating around the office yesterday that Samsung would be “taking over Times Square” as part of the Galaxy S4 launch, my initial reaction was, “Radio City Music Hall. The event is at Radio City Music Hall you nitwits. They’re, like, nine blocks apart.” These guys are going to handle our event coverage?

But no, they insisted. Samsung will also be “taking over Times Square.” This, I thought, was preposterous. First of all, they’re throwing a massive we-know-what-to-do-with-all-that-damages-money-the-judge-made-Apple-give-us-back event in one of the most famous theaters in the world; why would they need to “take over” one of the world’s most famous public spaces at the exact same time?

More importantly, taking over Times Square would be completely redundant. More than 300,000 people pass through there every day, which means it’s effectively in a constant state of takeover. Taking over Times Square would require an elite military unit several thousand strong, or one of those “pinch” devices that they used in Oceans 11 to shut down the power on the Las Vegas strip for a few minutes, or an army of Chinese hackers to turn back the technicolor capitalist glow radiated from a hundred acres of electronic billboards and make them all simultaneously display a single …

This warranted further investigation.

So, while DT’s crack team of mobile reporters dispatched to Radio City Music Hall to rub elbows with New York City’s technological elite while eating canapés and sipping champagne in anticipation of the official product launch beginning engage in the foot-shuffling bloodsport of the media line, I armed myself with a digital camera and a notebook and headed to the Crossroads Of The World.

A well-placed source at Samsung US ensured us that we’d want to be there by 6:30 PM – a full half hour before the Radio City Music Hall event was slated to start – if we wanted to see the fireworks. I emerge from the subway at 42 Street and 7th Avenue with 20 minutes to spare and immediately begin scanning the everyday mob scene that greets anyone unfortunate enough to find themselves in Times Square at any moment following, say, 1998. There is no immediate sign of the impending invasion, but then what takeover worth its salt would telegraph itself anyway (I mean, any more than by having representatives from the taking over company confirm the takeover)?

I turn up 7th and catch my first glimpse: an all-black Billboard innocuously set one story off the ground that coyly announced … live streaming of the Galaxy S4 Unpacked event starting at 7 p.m. Two blocks north of me. Looking up 7th, I spot the back of the screen where the live stream will display. It’s about a fifth the size of the average Times Square billboard. This is off to an inauspicious start; then again, had I paid more attention to this:

I would have known to expect little. After all, if that was Samsung’s definition of a “flash mob,” things were bound to be underwhelming. I trudge toward the viewing area, tucked into a corner of Duffy Square, better known before tonight (and also immediately after and forever more) as the home to that big red staircase on top of the place that sells tickets to Broadway shows. Aside from the screen, there are 10 or 15 rows of seats set up, and a small crowd of curious spectators waiting to be let into the square, which has been sectioned off with police cordons. They are let in at 6:30 on the dot, an “invasion” one hundred strong, trickling into a space where they’re matched, nearly one-for-one, by inordinately cheerful Samsung reps wearing jackets in the company’s distinctive Smurf blue.

For the next half hour, the crowd increases by another few hundred people, while the world’s lamest hype man attempts to start a wave, followed by a call and response game that consists of four people on one side of the square shouting “What’s in!” while two people on the other side shout “The box!” Meanwhile, the ad campaign featuring the insufferable brat Jeremy plays on an endless loop. Were it not for the billboard showing scantily clad women frolicking in beds directly above Jeremy, I wouldn’t have lasted more than five minutes. Did I mention it’s about 28 degrees?

The cold doesn’t keep people from continuing to stream in, although it’s unclear how many of them are to check out the S4 launch event, and how many of them were simply corralled into area by the endless maze of cordons that – depending on your taste for conspiracy theories – either govern efficient pedestrian flow through Times Square or exist to ensure no one ever leaves. Speaking of conspiracy theories, some press guys behind me suspect there’s a hidden meaning in the fact that a scene in the commercial shows Jeremy untwisting an Oreo and then twisting it back together before opening the mythical box at the center of the entire S4 marketing campaign.


“Watch! Watch!” one of them insists to the others. “He opens it … and then he closes it! No one does that! What does it mean?!”

It’s a fair question; I last another 15 minutes, until the screen (and, to be fair, the big billboard that just a moment ago showed a woman in a bikini rolling in the surf – two billboards out of a gazillion, not bad!) switches over to a live feed from Radio City Music Hall. The lights are down, last-minute tech staff scramble across the stage making preparations. It occurs to me that the chances of anything beyond a live stream and a few more games of “What’s in!” “The box!” happening are effectively nil at this point. I could watch this thing in the freezing cold or I could walk nine blocks to the event. I wish the guy next to me well, he looks at me quizzically before saying something in Russian, and I bail.

A half an hour ago, apparently, hundreds upon hundreds of media members lined 50th Street in a disorganized scrum, trying to reason with clipboard-wielding event staff who tried to reason with them back as no one got it. Meanwhile, guerrilla representatives from HTC and LG picked people off with snacks and hot chocolate, in exchange for down and dirty demonstrations with those manufacturers’ flagship phones. But that was then. Five minutes after the lights go up inside, I walk unimpeded into the art deco temple that is the Radio City Music Hall lobby. A few too-cool attendees sip free booze, but the yawning space is populated almost exclusively by bored-looking women in short black cocktail dresses and elbow-high black gloves who man the stairwells. I remember the Smurfs a few blocks back and feel bad for them; these ladies look much warmer.

I climb to the third balcony before finding a seat – it’s an impressive turnout considering the place has a capacity of roughly 6,000 – and drop down next to two intent-looking gents just as JK Shin, the global head of Samsung Mobile, introduces to the S4. The smattering of applause would sound more impressive in a less cavernous room, but instead sounds like it’s being swallowed by hundreds of gruff tech writers wielding journalistic integrity. But as Samsung Director of Product Marketing Ryan Bidan takes the stage and begins rifling through the phone’s specs, even the hacks start to get excited.


And why not? On paper (or a massive screen, as the case may be), the S4 is a beast. A paper cut-inducing 7.9mm thick and weighing in at just 130 grams, the phone (in the US, anyway) will boast a quad-core 1.9GHz Snapdragon S4 pro chip powered by a 2,600mAh battery. The gaggle of sensors – infrared, proximity, temperature, barometer, gyroscope, accelerometer – get some ooh’s and ahh’s, but it’s the screen, a 5-inch, 1080p gem packing 441ppi pixel density that finally tips them into nerdgasm. Cheers erupt and the two guys next to me giggle and slap high fives. But that’s it for the look under the hood.

I’m sorry, did you want to talk hardware some more? You must be mistaking this for the launch of a mobile device. The S4 isn’t a phone, you simpleton! It’s a “Life Companion!”

From here, the event’s MC, television “That Guy” Will Chase takes the wheel, initiating a series of Broadway-inspired scenes that fall somewhere between a Norman Rockwell painting and the worst sitcom network television ever produced. Each one is choreographed to illustrate a real-world situation that the S4 has been custom tailored to address. Ever wanted to be in the family photo you’re taking, but are too agoraphobic to ask a passerby to take the shot for you? “Dual Camera” operates the front and back lens simultaneously and then inserts your face into the picture you just took. Want to record sound to accompany your photos so … looking at them annoys people nearby? “Sound & Shot” will do that. Have a decent home stereo but would rather hear your music played simultaneously through eight tinny Galaxy phone speakers in your living room in unison? Group Play has you covered. Fingers covered in pizza sauce and you’re just too lazy to use a napkin? “Air Gesture” lets your use your touchscreen without actually touching it. This last one manages to roust the fanboys next to me, who excitedly exclaim to each other, “He’s not touching the screen! He’s not touching the screen!”

Their enthusiasm aside, this suite of software is clearly designed for caricatures of the average consumer. Like a lot of Samsung’s recent mobile products, it all comes prepackaged and preloaded, almost as if the company’s response to Apple’s “There’s an app for that” campaign is to interrupt you before you can buy that iPhone and swear, “You don’t need an app for it! We have it all, right here!” But baking functionality into the phone only works if the functionality isn’t half baked. I’m reminded of Samsung’s Galaxy 10.1 launch event last September, when I watched Hollywood super director Baz Luhrmann display that tablet’s functionality from afar, only to find the functionality stuttering and unreliable when I played with the device just a few minutes later.

As the presentation ends, the Smurfs make their appearance, manning tables throughout the auditorium and mezzanines where hundreds of S4’s are tethered for hands on display. The wait for a device is long, giving me ample opportunity to see the software put to the test by multiple people. One by one they speak into the translator or try to activate the Smart Pause that stops a video when your eyes look away or flip horizontally through screens without touching the glass. The success rate for everyone is about 50 percent.

Finally, it’s my turn. I spend a few minutes poking around the photo-editing functions (“Who needs Photoshop when you have Drama Shot and Story album?”) and the fitness functions (“No need for that Fuel Band anymore!”), before trying my luck with the “Life Task” functions. I subtly shift the phone toward me and away from me, hoping to get a New York Times article to “Smart Scroll.” After a few minutes, one of the Smurfs digs through the settings menu with an exasperated sigh and activates the function, at which point it works so well that I get vaguely motion sick trying to keep up as the page disappears into the top of my screen. Then I try the “Air Gesture,” initially making subtle swiping motions across the screen before getting incrementally more demonstrative. Pretty soon, I look like I’m trying to put out a small fire in the phone, but the screen goes nowhere. I can’t bear the Smurf’s withering stare a second time, so I leave it at that.


At this point, the crowd has thinned out and things are winding down. I decide to hoof it back to Times Square and confirm that there was not, in fact, an actual takeover. As I approach from behind the big red stairs, it’s clear that whatever crowd had gathered has mostly dispersed. The screen is dark. The beautiful women have returned to the billboard above, and the Smurfs are huddled together in small packs or manning a consumer version of the hands on display that I just left.

The journalist in me wants to sidle up alongside one of those consumers and see if this remarkable new phone with the breathtaking specs and the Life Companion software suite is everything they ever hoped it would be and more. Would they actually use the fitness functions? Do they, in fact, find touching their touch screens to be too onerous to deal with? Does fondling the S4 make them regret their five month-old iPhone purchase?

But the New Yorker in me just wants to get the hell out of Times Square, and the New Yorker wins. For all I know, Samsung initiated a massive military raid on the place moments after I left. If they did – and if anybody noticed – I’ll read about it tomorrow.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Product Review

This $295 smartwatch has the Armani name, but not the looks

The Armani Exchange AX Connected smartwatch does everything right. It has strong technical features, a good design, and isn’t over-priced. But is subtle brand name appeal enough to recommend it?

The best MP3 players of 2018 cram tons of music into a small package

Want to go for a run, but your phone is weighing you down? Don't sweat it. Can't fit your whole music library on your smartphone? No worries. Check out our list of the best MP3 players, and find one that works for you.
Smart Home

It does everything you can imagine, but the Instant Pot Max has one major flaw

Instant Pot Max has more cooking functions and features than the Duo and most other IP models. Is the Max worth the higher price tag? We tested it out to find out. Here's what we like and don't like about it.
Movies & TV

The best movies on Netflix in March, from Buster Scruggs to Roma

Save yourself from hours wasted scrolling through Netflix's massive library by checking out our picks for the streamer's best movies available right now, whether you're into explosive action, witty humor, or anything else.

The Pixel 3 range will soon be coming to T-Mobile's network

Google's latest flagships, the Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL, are now official and we have all the details from the October 9 event in New York City and Paris. Here's everything we know about the Google Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL.

The Pixel 3a and 3a XL will be coming to the U.S. with T-Mobile

The Google Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL are considered to be two of the best Android smartphones, but it looks like Google could be prepping a midrange line. Say hello to the Pixel 3a and Pixel 3a XL.

Intel gives up on 5G modems for smartphones, will focus on other devices

After a delay that saw Intel's manufacture of 5G modems pushed back to 2020, Intel has given up on the 5G modem business, and will focus its efforts elsewhere. But is something else to blame?

Keep your new iPad (2018) sparkling with the best screen protectors

Your iPad sports a stunning 9.7-inch screen and you'll want it to stay that way. The best iPad (2018) screen protectors guard against cracks, scratches, and even smudging from your fingers. Check out our top picks here.

The black satin Razer Phone 2 is now available for $500

The Razer Phone 2 is finally here, and it's got upgraded specs, that super-smooth 120Hz display, and an updated design. Here's absolutely everything you need to know about the Razer Phone 2.

The best LG G7 ThinQ cases will keep your phone looking new

The LG G7 ThinQ comes with a powerful processor, versatile cameras, and amazing sound. But a powerful phone still needs protection and you might want to change the style. Here are the best LG G7 ThinQ cases.

Multiple phone leaks show May 21 is going to be a big day for Honor

Honor will launch at least one new smartphone on May 21, at an event taking place in London. Leaks have indicated the Honor 20 will take center stage, with a Lite version, and perhaps even another model also showing up on the day.

Breaking news: Samsung responds to reported Galaxy Fold display issues

The Samsung Galaxy Fold has arrived, and it goes on sale soon. Folding out from a 4.6-inch display to a tablet-sized 7.3-inch display, this unique device has six cameras, two batteries, and special software to help you use multiple apps.

The Avalon V is Alcatel’s first Verizon-exclusive smartphone

Alcatel is has announced a new phone, the Avalon V -- but this budget device isn't what makes the announcement special. It's Alcatel's first phone on the Verizon network, and it's available now.

Big, beautiful, and breakable: Check out the best Galaxy S8 Plus cases

There’s no denying Samsung’s ability to turn out an attractive smartphone, but glass curves are expensive to fix and metal chips easily. We've rounded up the best Galaxy S8 Plus cases on the market.