Skip to main content

Small phones have had a chance, but we always go large

Last week, Pebble founder Eric Migicovsky joined a chorus of mostly online voices in advocacy for a small premium smartphone. In an interview with The Verge and on the aptly named “smallandroidphone” website, he lamented the dearth of choices in the smartphone world when it came to size. According to him, small phones fit nicely in a pocket, are very light, easy to use one-handed, and handy in sports.

These are all really good arguments for the ever-recurring small phone debate we have year after year, but the numbers have been in for a long time: No one really wants small phones that badly.

Discontinued for a reason

“Since Sony discontinued the Xperia Compact line, no other Android phone maker has had the courage to make a small premium Android phone. It’s up to us to change that,” the page reads. It’s a strange request. What manufacturer would discontinue a product if it was selling well? Sony may be terrible at many things, but it’s not that dumb.

Sony Xperia XZ2 Compact
The Xperia Compact line is another example of a small phone series that failed to set the market aflame. Julian Chokkattu/Digital Trends

If small phones were a successful enough niche, like big phones with massive cameras, or thick phones with massive batteries, or even those ugly ones built for gamers, many companies would build them. Oppo, Xiaomi, or even Samsung would find the time to knock one out if it could wring out a single extra dollar. Instead, if you look around, you’ll notice that over the years smartphone sizes have done nothing but creep up, with nothing but minute fluctuations.

The so-called perfect small Android phone has already come and gone many times. Google’s Pixel range shipped with sub-six-inch displays prior to the Pixel 6, with the Pixel 5 providing one of the best, small premium Android experiences there has been. Asus has its similarly compact Zenfone 8 out, and if we extend this to Apple’s range, there’s the iPhone 12, iPhone 13 Mini, and iPhone SE (2022). Aside from size, all these phones have one thing in common. They underperformed sales-wise.

No one buys them

This cuts to the heart of the reason companies don’t make small phones. It isn’t that they’re pushing for big phones just for the fun of it, it’s that they are proven to sell far better than their smaller counterparts over and over again. This rule holds even when the smaller phones are several times cheaper than the large ones. Google’s Pixel 6 and 6 Pro have, by the company’s own admission, sold more than the Pixel 4 and Pixel 5 combined. Both of these bigger phones are just shy of the iPhone 13 Pro Max size-wise.

iPhonr 12 range 2
Apple’s more expensive Pro Max phones outsell the cheaper models year over year. Andrew Martonik/Digital Trends

Speaking of iPhones, the iPhone 12 and 13 Mini make up 3% of Apple’s combined iPhone sales. An April note from research firm Wave7 puts the expensive iPhone 13 Pro Max and its similarly supersized Samsung counterpart, the Galaxy S22 Ultra, at the top of the sales chart in the U.S., according to comments from carriers, with the size of the devices as one of the top reasons people are buying them.

Small size, big compromises

It makes a lot of sense if you think about it. The biggest selling point of small phones, by its proponents, is that you barely notice it’s there. That’s hard to market in a way that’s exciting. It’s easy to point out the large display as a benefit for someone who reads a lot of books or comics, someone who takes pictures, or someone who loves watching moves. The best you can do for a small one is: “Eh, you won’t feel it in your pocket” and “you can hold it in one hand.” Pardon me if I’m not rushing to the store holding a stack of bills.

The other big issue with small phones? Physics. Even if some people want phones that are small-sized, can they live with the problems that come with them? If I want the phone with the best battery because I’m a road warrior, that wipes out all small phones because it requires physical space to hold that big battery. If I want the best camera, I’m going to need a big phone because all those sensors have to go somewhere. Texting someone? It’s irritating on a small screen. Do you want the fastest modem and the best display? Sure you do, but these things take up space.

Migicovsky says these trade-offs are less of an issue than size but it doesn’t seem to play that way. At the end of the day, when presented with phones that are all but identical aside from size and price, it seems the bigger and more expensive phones win out. That says more than any online petition ever could.

Editors' Recommendations

Michael Allison
A UK-based tech journalist for Digital Trends, helping keep track and make sense of the fast-paced world of tech with a…
I tried the iPhone’s new Journal app. Here’s what’s good (and bad)
Apple Journal app on iPhone 15 Pro.

Apple's Journal app in iOS 17 is like a basic notetaking app supercharged with AI. It offers prompts and suggestions based on what you do throughout the day to help you journal your daily entries.

While the app is a basic white screen with a “+” icon, it's what happens after you tap on that icon that sets it apart from Notes or other journaling apps. I've been using the app for a little while now, and while it's not perfect, it is off to a really interesting start.
Using iOS 17's Journal app

Read more
I reviewed 20 phones in 2023. These are my 5 favorites
A person taking a photo with the Apple iPhone 15 Plus.

This has been a fantastic year for smartphones due to the sheer variety of great devices at all prices. In other words, if you wanted a brilliant new phone this year, it didn’t have to be a $1,000-plus flagship.

I’ve used and reviewed a great many phones over the past 12 months, but the following five have left the biggest impression to become what I consider the very best you can get.
iPhone 15 Plus
Apple iPhone 15 Plus Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

Read more
Why RCS for the iPhone is Apple’s biggest announcement of 2023
A person holding the Apple iPhone 15 Plus.

Hell has frozen over. On November 16, 2023, Apple made the very unexpected announcement that it was bringing support for RCS on the iPhone in 2024.

In 2022, Tim Cook himself said that he’d rather sell you an iPhone instead of ever bringing RCS support to the iPhone because he thought customer demand for RCS wasn’t there. Google has made numerous attempts to shame Apple over its pushback of RCS over the years.

Read more