Smartphones should not have a ‘kill switch’ if they’re stolen

phone thief

Cathy L. Lanier, the chief of police in Columbia believes “carriers are not innocent” when it comes to phone theft. They aren’t inclined to make phones less attractive to thieves, because, as she puts it, they’re “making a profit off this.” She’s referring to the fact the victim will usually have to buy a new phone, or must cough up cash to buy their way out of a contract.

Lanier’s comments are part of a New York Times piece on this very issue, suggesting the mobile industry is, “Looking the other way,” as phone thefts continue to rise. To highlight the problem, it’s said thefts involving a phone now account for half of all robberies in San Francisco, while last year the figure was 36 percent. While we may giggle at the stupidity of some thieves, the New York Times paints a far more serious picture, with one police lieutenant calling the gangs behind the major operations, “Well organized, very tech savvy, well trained and well funded.”

The industry’s primary weapon in the fight is the national, unified database which stores the IMEI numbers (every phone has a unique IMEI) attached to stolen phones, which, in theory, prevents them from being re-used. Databases like this are maintained all over the world, and in time, the U.S. database will be merged with international versions to help stop stolen phones being sent out of the country and re-connected elsewhere.

However, according to the New York Times, IMEI numbers are being altered so they no longer show-up on carrier’s blacklists, enabling them to be sold on and connected without a problem. The District Attorney for San Francisco, George Gascon, holds manufacturers responsible for not doing enough to secure mobile phones, saying, “Unlike other types of crimes, this is a crime that could be easily fixed with a technological solution.” The carriers, represented in the article by T-Mobile, aren’t helping themselves either. A T-Mobile representative could only say, “we do care very deeply about this,” but was quiet about any potential solutions.

Find My iPhone iPadKill switches probably aren’t the answer

So is this, as the district attorney says, an easily fixable problem? There are several safeguards we as smartphone users can already take to make the loss of a phone less problematic, with several companies offering tracking solutions, and Apple’s Find My iPhone device tracking system coming as standard. But the DA wants manufacturers to include a, “kill switch,” which sounds like a cross between an EMP device and the system used to convey messages to Ethan Hunt.

This isn’t the first time the San Francisco district attorney has brought up the idea of a kill switch, but he has been frustrated by the industry’s lack of interest in developing one, which he claimed is due to profits. A VP of mobile security firm Mobile Iron told Information Week earlier this year that kill switches were, “Technically feasible,” but offered few advantages outside of the business world. For regular users, he saw the available remote wipe features pre-installed on phones, or systems like Norton Mobile Security, as being sufficient.

Kill switches are already used by manufacturers, and although Apple has never used the one installed on the iPhone, Google has flexed its muscles twice in the past, each time to remove malicious applications after they had been installed on active Android phones. The trouble with the idea of a central kill switch is not that it could inevitably be bypassed (Apple’s has been deactivated in the past through jailbreaking the phone), but who would be in control. Giving carriers the legal right to zap a phone from existence may sound good after it has been stolen, but less so if excuses could be found for using it against late payers, modified phones, or those installing unapproved software.

Police forces around the world have successfully recovered stolen phones using Find My iPhone and similar systems – the Metropolitan Police in the UK even recommends turning it on, and has a guide on how to do so on its website – but don’t always have the resources to follow up each case, which can be frustrating for victims of crime.

There’s no doubt Cathy Lanier and District Attorney Gascon are correct in one sense, that the problem of smartphone crime needs addressing, but we’re not convinced kill switches are the answer. However, if a truly international database of stolen IMEI numbers could be implemented quickly, and all networks around the world were compelled to update it, this along with systems such as fingerprint scanners fitted to phones and the existing remote wipe features, could at the very least stem the tide.

Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Halfbikes, VR for all your senses, and more

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it's fun to gawk!

Smash your carrier shackles with the best unlocked phones

If you want the freedom to switch carriers at will or you prefer to get your phone directly from the company that makes it, you'll want to buy an unlocked smartphone. These are the best unlocked phones you can buy in the U.S.
Home Theater

What’s new on Amazon Prime Video and what’s leaving in May 2019

Amazon Prime Video adds new titles each month that are available for free to all Prime members. Check out our list to find all the content hitting Amazon Prime Video in April and May, from new original series to classic films.
Movies & TV

Alan Tudyk's K-2SO confirmed for Disney Plus' Star Wars: Rogue One series

Diego Luna will reprise his role from 2016's Rogue One: A Star Wars Story for an upcoming television series on Disney's streaming video platform. The series will explore rebel spy Cassian Andor's early adventures, with Alan Tudyk returning…

The Department of Justice may prevent the T-Mobile-Sprint merger

T-Mobile and Sprint are getting closer to merging. After a few failed attempts, the two companies announced their merger at the start of 2018. The new T-Mobile could be better positioned to take on the likes of Verizon and AT&T.

Spruce up your Lenovo smartphone with the best Moto Mods for the Moto Z-series

Moto Mods, the snap-on accessories compatible with Lenovo's Moto Z-series smartphones add a lot of value without adding a lot of bulk. Looking to try one out? Here are a few of our favorite Moto Mods.

The Pixel 3a and 3a XL will be coming to the U.S. with T-Mobile

The Google Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL are considered to be two of the best Android smartphones, but it looks like Google could be prepping a midrange line. Say hello to the Pixel 3a and Pixel 3a XL.

The Pixel 3 range will soon be coming to T-Mobile's network

Google's latest flagships, the Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL, are now official and we have all the details from the October 9 event in New York City and Paris. Here's everything we know about the Google Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL.

Keep your new iPad (2018) sparkling with the best screen protectors

Your iPad sports a stunning 9.7-inch screen and you'll want it to stay that way. The best iPad (2018) screen protectors guard against cracks, scratches, and even smudging from your fingers. Check out our top picks here.

Intel gives up on 5G modems for smartphones, will focus on other devices

After a delay that saw Intel's manufacture of 5G modems pushed back to 2020, Intel has given up on the 5G modem business, and will focus its efforts elsewhere. But is something else to blame?

The black satin Razer Phone 2 is now available for $500

The Razer Phone 2 is finally here, and it's got upgraded specs, that super-smooth 120Hz display, and an updated design. Here's absolutely everything you need to know about the Razer Phone 2.

The best LG G7 ThinQ cases will keep your phone looking new

The LG G7 ThinQ comes with a powerful processor, versatile cameras, and amazing sound. But a powerful phone still needs protection and you might want to change the style. Here are the best LG G7 ThinQ cases.

Multiple phone leaks show May 21 is going to be a big day for Honor

Honor will launch at least one new smartphone on May 21, at an event taking place in London. Leaks have indicated the Honor 20 will take center stage, with a Lite version, and perhaps even another model also showing up on the day.

Breaking news: Samsung responds to reported Galaxy Fold display issues

The Samsung Galaxy Fold has arrived, and it goes on sale soon. Folding out from a 4.6-inch display to a tablet-sized 7.3-inch display, this unique device has six cameras, two batteries, and special software to help you use multiple apps.