Skip to main content

Judge dismisses lawsuit over Superman distribution rights

A judge has thrown out a lawsuit challenging Warner Bros.’ right to distribute James Gunn’s Superman in 10 countries, including the U.K. and Ireland. The lawsuit was first filed in January by Mark Peary, the nephew of late Superman co-creator Joe Schuster, and argued that Schuster’s estate had the right to cancel the Superman copyright in certain territories.

In a ruling first released on April 24, U.S. District Judge Jesse Furman held that the court has no authority to address the estate’s rights under foreign laws. “The Court concludes that it lacks subject-matter jurisdiction over this case; the case therefore must be and is dismissed,” he wrote.

Recommended Videos

Following the dismissal, Peary filed a nearly identical lawsuit in state court in New York on April 25. The lawsuit is seeking an injunction that could disrupt the release of Superman, which is set to hit theaters on July 11.

The copyright to Superman has been contested for decades, ever since Schuster and Jerome Siegel created the character and sold the copyright to him for $130 in 1938. In 2013, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeal rejected the Shuster estate’s claim that they still hold the copyright, finding that Shuster’s sister had signed away all rights after Shuster’s death in 1992.

Peary’s lawsuit argues that that ruling settled the copyright claim forever with regard to the United States, but left the question of foreign copyrights undecided. As the movie’s release gets closer, though, the likelihood that this lawsuit will be able to halt its release continues to decrease.

Joe Allen
Joe Allen is a freelance writer at Digital Trends, where he covers Movies and TV. He frequently writes streaming…
DC Studios James Gunn and Peter Safran share updates on Sgt. Rock, The Batman 2, Clayface, and more
Batman stands across from Catwoman and looks at her.

It's time for another State of the Union from DC Studios.
DC Studios co-CEOs James Gunn and Peter Safran provided updates on the company's upcoming projects with a group of journalists on February 21. The address comes two years after Gunn and Safran relaunched the DC Universe and announced plans for Chapter One: Gods and Monsters.

Starting in the film division, Safran stated DC's intention to release two live-action movies and one animated film per year. Last week, Daniel Craig departed Sgt. Rock, the upcoming superhero movie from director Luca Guadagnino and screenwriter Justin Kuritzkes. Per Variety, Safran said DC "never met with Daniel," while Gunn noted that the duo "never announced the project."
Safran said Matt Reeves has not completed the full script for The Batman Part II, which moved release dates from October 2026 to October 2027. Speaking of the Batman Epic Crime Saga, the DC executives are unsure if The Penguin will return for season 2. Batman: The Brave and the Bold remains in active development, though Robert Pattinson will likely play that version of the Caped Crusader.
Safran confirmed that Clayface will be directed by James Watkins from a screenplay by Mike Flanagan. Casting has begun. Alan Tudyk, who voices the character in Harley Quinn and Creature Commandos, will not star in the live-action horror. Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow is halfway through production, while Ana Nogueira continues to work on a Teen Titans script. Swamp Thing is still in development with James Mangold, and The Authority remains far off.
Superman | Official Teaser Trailer
DC's television slate is highlighted by Peacemaker season 2 premiering in August. The Viola Davis-led series Waller is still in development after a "bumpy road" during production. Shows that are happening include Lanterns, which arrives in 2026, and a Blue Beetle animated series, which follows the events of the live-action movie. Paradise Lost and Booster Gold remain in development, though the latter moved on from its initial showrunner.
Finally, animation remains a priority for Gunn and Safran. Dynamic Duo, a movie about Dick Grayson and Jason Todd, remains in pre-production. Three “younger-skewing” animated series have been greenlit, including My Adventures with Green Lantern, DC Super Powers, and Starfire.
DC Studios' focus will soon shift to promoting and marketing Superman, opening in theaters on July 11, 2025.

Read more
Shaq meets the new Man of Steel in latest Superman ad
James Gunn, Shaquille O'Neal, and David Corenswet in a Superman ad.

Shaquille O'Neal has never made a secret about his fandom for Superman. That was one of his nicknames during his playing career, and he even has a Superman "S" logo tattoo on his arm. Out of all of the hosts on Inside the NBA, that's why Shaq was the perfect choice to appear in the latest TV ad for Superman, which debuted on TNT over the weekend.

In the commerical, Shaq unknowingly meets the new Superman, David Corenswet, before the pair are formally introduced by director James Gunn. But rather than wish the latest Man of Steel good luck in his upcoming debut as Superman, Shaq is a little salty that he wasn't chosen to play the role himself. He's even less pleased to learn that his Inside the NBA co-host, Charles Barkley, was offered a cameo by Gunn.

Read more
Henry Cavill’s James Bond audition leaks online. Should Superman have played 007?
Henry Cavill as Napoleon SOlo aiming a gun at someone off-camera in The Man From U.N.C.L.E.

Henry Cavill nearly wore a tuxedo instead of a cape.
In 2005, Cavill auditioned for the role of James Bond in Casino Royale. According to director Martin Campbell, Cavill and Daniel Craig were the finalists to replace Pierce Brosnan as 007. For years, fans have wondered what Cavill's interpretation of Bond would have been like. Thanks to a leaked video, these fans now get their wish.
Cavill's Bond audition has leaked online. Posted to Ron South's YouTube channel, Cavill is seen reading lines from a scene in 1995's GoldenEye. Cavill is only 22 in the video, while sporting long black hair. According to the video's description, the video came from a "VHS tape found in a recycling bin at a movie studio."

As the story goes, Craig won the role and played the iconic spy in five movies. Producers opted to go with an older version of Bond — Craig was 37 in 2005 — instead of an early-20s spy. Despite losing the role, Cavill won over Campbell, who praised Cavill's "tremendous" audition.

Read more