Skip to main content

My Best Friend’s Exorcism review: Fighting mean girls (and meaner demons)

The teenage years can be scary, even without the threat of demonic possession. Throw a sinister supernatural element into the mix, and the experience becomes, well … only slightly more terrifying, actually.

That’s one takeaway from director Damon Thomas’ My Best Friend’s Exorcism, which delivers a scary-fun paranormal thriller filtered through a coming-of-age drama about two teenage girls in the 1980s whose lifelong friendship is threatened when one of them becomes the unwilling host of an infernal entity. That this supernatural encounter occurs while the girls are navigating young adulthood turns the typical social hellscape of high school into something more sinister, and tests their friendship in unexpected and terrifying ways.

A group of girls gathers around a Ouija board in My Best Friend's Exorcism.

Penned by screenwriter Jenna Lamia (Good Girls) and based on the novel of the same name by Grady Hendrix, My Best Friend’s Exorcism casts Elsie Fisher (Eighth Grade) and Amiah Miller (War for the Planet of the Apes) as Abby and Gretchen, respectively, best friends whose bond was already being tested by their final year of high school before a demon named Andras decided to invade Gretchen’s body. Abby’s attempts to save her friend are complicated by the surprisingly similar ways the average teenager and malevolent demons tend to act, leaving her struggling to convince anyone of Gretchen’s supernatural plight.

My Best Friend’s Exorcism works well on a few different levels. On one hand, it offers a clever, straight-up juxtaposition between the frightening ordeal of one’s teenage years and the only-a-little-more-terrifying experience of battling a demon from hell for your best friend’s soul. Below the surface, though, it explores the way our confusing thoughts and emotions and unconscious drives can make every moment of our teenage years feel like a fight for survival, and the way a close friend can be our lifeline when things seem impossibly dire.

It’s also a funny story about mean girls and even meaner imps from hell, too.

Elsie Fisher and Amiah Miller sit on a bed in a scene from My Best Friend's Exorcism.

My Best Friend’s Exorcism can be funny, frightening, depressing, or uplifting from moment to moment, depending on which aspects of Abby and Gretchen’s experiences you connect with, but the film never dives too deeply into that pool of emotions.

While it delivers some decent scares and clever humor, My Best Friend’s Exorcism seems content to occupy the happy medium between the various genres it pulls from. Thomas makes good use of the talented young cast and Lamia’s script keeps things entertaining and compelling, without offering many surprises.

Fisher and Miller have a great chemistry as friends whose lives feel inextricably intertwined, and Miller does a great job of selling her demonic possession — particularly when it’s so easily disguised as garden-variety teenage apathy. Fisher has a knack for channeling the awkwardness of adolescence, too, and finds just the right balance between shy wallflower and scream queen as Abby’s world suddenly becomes even more surreal and scary than she ever anticipated.

In a relatively brief supporting role, GLOW actor Christopher Lowell is also fun to watch as a bumbling, overconfident, Jesus-loving meathead who Abby turns to for help, and he makes for an entertaining counterpoint to Abby’s raging insecurity.

Elsie Fisher walks through a creepy house in a scene from My Best Friend's Exorcism.

Never too scary or too dark, and never too silly or biting with its humor, My Best Friend’s Exorcism is a film that neither overreaches nor oversells its premise. Its story of two teenage friends battling a demon can be as simple as that, or it can be a narrative filled with underlying metaphors and themes that make an otherwise straightforward premise something deeper. Whatever way you choose to approach it, it’s a smart, satisfying scary story.

Directed by Damon Thomas, My Best Friend’s Exorcism will be available to stream September 30 on Prime Video.

My Best Friend's Exorcism (2022)
My Best Friend's Exorcism
96m
Genre Horror, Comedy
Stars Elsie Fisher, Amiah Miller, Cathy Ang
Directed by Damon Thomas

Editors' Recommendations

Movie images and data from:
The best sci-fi movies on Amazon Prime Video
Ryan Kiera Armstrong lights a lighter in a scene from Firestarter.

What do extraterrestrial invasions, sentient cyborgs, and time-traveling all have in common? They're all variations of the sci-fi genre, and far beyond the shelves of dusty used bookstores, you can find science fiction across all mediums these days. In fact, if you’re a fan of sci-fi movies, one of the best places to watch them is Amazon Prime Video. 

As fans of both the streaming service and the genre, we've gone ahead and rounded up all the best sci-fi movies you can watch on Prime Video.

Read more
Slash/Back review: The kids are all right (especially when fighting aliens)
Three girls, each armed with different weapons, go looking for alien invaders in a scene from Slash/Back.

Audiences love stories that pit plucky kids against horrible monsters -- whether it's aliens, zombies, ghosts, or various other supernatural threats. There's so much love for these stories, in fact, that it takes a special kind of film to stand out in the crowded "kids vs. monsters" genre these days.

Director Nyla Innuksuk's Slash/Back is one such film, and it delivers a uniquely clever, creepy-fun adventure, led by a talented cast of young actors.

Read more
Smile review: A cruelly scary studio horror movie
Caitlin Stasey smiles, unnervingly.

The alarm has been tripped. The backdoor is wide open. And who or whatever’s impersonating the security-system operator on the other end of the phone line has just croaked three words that no horror movie character would ever want to hear: “Look behind you.” The command puts Rose (Sosie Bacon), the increasingly petrified heroine of Smile, between a rock and a hard place. She has to look, even if every fiber of her being would rather not. And so does the audience. We’re locked into her campfire crucible, forced to follow the hesitant backward tilt of her gaze, and the anticipatory creep of a camera that’s slow to reveal what that disembodied voice has invited her (and us) to discover.

Smile is full of moments like this. It’s a nasty, diabolically calibrated multiplex scream machine — the kind of movie that sends ripples of nervous laughter through packed theaters, the kind that marionettes the whole crowd into a synchronized dance routine of frazzled nerves and spilled popcorn. Turn up your nose, if you must, at the lowly cheap sting of a jump scare. Smile gives that maligned device a workout for the ages. It rattles with aplomb.

Read more