Skip to main content

What the hell happened to The Mandalorian?

The Mandalorian has always wanted to have its cake and eat it, too. Across its first two seasons, the series attempted to blend sidequest-heavy, episodic storytelling with one longform, serialized story. While the show never found the perfect balance between those two modes, its first two seasons both came together well in the end. Unfortunately, The Mandalorian season 3 hasn’t been quite as effective.

Over the course of its first six episodes, The Mandalorian’s latest season has struggled to maintain any kind of singular, serialized story. Instead, it has delivered a handful of sidequests and one-note villains that so far haven’t amounted to much. Along the way, the series has loosely threaded together its latest batch of adventures with a story about Bo-Katan Kryze (Katee Sackhoff) and Din Djarin (Pedro Pascal) setting out to retake Mandalore, which has progressed at a frustratingly uneven pace.

All of these problems, along with the show’s inability to balance Bo-Katan and Din Djarin’s perspectives, have resulted in a season of television that feels disappointingly directionless. In fact, it’s starting to feel like The Mandalorian doesn’t really know how or what story it wants to tell anymore.

The Mandalorian’s identity crisis

Din looks at Grogu in The Mandalorian.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The Mandalorian used to be about Din Djarin and his force-sensitive ward, Grogu. The former character started out as a detached, cold bounty hunter who had little interest in personal connection. That all changed when he met Grogu. Across its first two seasons, The Mandalorian consequently followed Din as he grew so close to Grogu that he not only became a more sensitive friend and formidable warrior, but also a father figure who was willing to reevaluate his own beliefs in order to protect his loved ones.

Din’s journey set him up to be — like so many of the iconic heroes who have come before him — an unlikely, but capable leader. In its third season, however, The Mandalorian has more or less thrown that possibility out the window. Not only has Din reverted back to following the laws of The Way with a dogmatic fierceness, but his and Grogu’s relationship hasn’t evolved or progressed at all since the last time Star Wars fans saw them together at the end of The Book of Boba Fett season 1.

Instead of continuing to find new ways to challenge Din and Grogu’s relationship, The Mandalorian has turned its attention to Bo-Katan and Din’s shared desire to rebuild Mandalore. On paper, that makes sense as the next chapter of The Mandalorian’s story. However, in practice, the series’ Bo-Katan-centric plot has left a lot to be desired.

The problem with Bo-Katan

Din Djarin stands in front of Bo-Katan in The Mandalorian season 3 episode 6.

Over the course of The Mandalorian season 3, Bo-Katan has gone from an exiled princess living in isolation to the newly decreed future leader of Mandalore. The only problem with that arc is that Bo-Katan herself hasn’t actually changed in ways that justify such a transformation. She has more or less remained the same person she was when she first showed up on The Mandalorian. Even when it looked like the Disney+ series was going to see her become a full-time, card-carrying follower of The Way, The Mandalorian ended up abandoning that possibility.

Now, Bo-Katan has not only been given permission by The Armorer (Emily Swallow) and the other members of Din’s covert to take her helmet off in the presence of others, but she’s also been named the new wielder of the Darksaber by Din himself. Despite Din’s fierce belief in her, though, The Mandalorian hasn’t sufficiently shown or explained why Bo-Katan deserves to take his place as the future leader of Mandalore. In fact, while viewers have already witnessed Din’s capacity for change, Bo-Katan hasn’t grown much since she appeared for the first time in The Mandalorian season 2.

As a result, many moments in The Mandalorian season 3 have felt like the series just going through the motions. The show’s previously established emotional throughlines have either been sidelined or abandoned altogether — leaving The Mandalorian with only a series of plot developments that carry little actual weight.

Too much of a good thing?

Bo-Katan holds the Darksaber while standing next to Din Djarin in The Mandalorian season 3 episode 6.

One of the biggest problems with franchise storytelling, in general, is that it can lead to certain series overstaying their welcome. That usually happens whenever a show keeps going after its central dramatic argument has already been resolved, which is just another way of saying that it no longer has any reason to exist outside of its own corporate worth.

It’s starting to feel more and more like that’s what has happened to The Mandalorian. In previous years, the Disney+ series was kept afloat by Din and Grogu’s relationship, which allowed it to explore the ways that connection and love can motivate a person to grow and become a better version of themselves. For comparison’s sake, Season 1 of Andor similarly used one man’s political radicalization to tell a story about how hope and freedom can thrive in even the most oppressive of times. Unfortunately, The Mandalorian seems to believe that it ran out of ways to explore its core themes when it reunited Din and Grogu in The Book of Boba Fett.

All that remains in the show is Bo-Katan and Din Djarin’s shared mission to rebuild Mandalore. To be fair, that’s an objectively intriguing premise, but The Mandalorian season 3 has failed to establish an actual story beneath that plot. The series, in other words, has become a zero-calorie space odyssey that is in desperate need of something deeper and greater to latch onto.

New episodes of The Mandalorian premiere Wednesdays on Disney+.

Editors' Recommendations

Alex Welch
Alex Welch is a TV and movies writer based out of Los Angeles. In addition to Digital Trends, his work has been published by…
3 things we learned from the new trailer for Ahsoka
Rosario Dawson as Ahsoka in an ancient ruin in the titular series.

Star Wars fans don't have long to wait for the next chapter in the franchise. Rosario Dawson is headlining Ahsoka, a new original series featuring the heroine who made her name in the animated series Star Wars: The Clone Wars and Star Wars Rebels. During Dawson's live-action debut as Ahsoka Tano in The Mandalorian season 2, it was revealed that she is seeking out Grand Admiral Thrawn, one of the most formidable officers in the Empire. Soon, Ahsoka will come face-to-face with her nemesis and determine the fate of the galaxy.

Ahsoka | Official Trailer | Disney+

Read more
4 questions we have after Secret Invasion episode 1
A Skrull with Nick Fury's face in the opening credits of "Secret Invasion."

Marvel Studios' new spy thriller series, Secret Invasion, has just hit Disney+. Now that Nick Fury (Samuel L. Jackson) has finally returned to Earth, he and his allies must stop a group of shape-shifting Skrulls from terrorizing the globe.

Given the nature of this series, there are already many surprises after just one episode that have left audiences with questions. Who killed [REDACTED]? And why? And just what is Talos up to? DT asks the hard questions and provides some quasi-answers to the many mysteries the first episode of Secret Invasion sets up.

Read more
Star Trek vs. Star Wars: which one is better in 2023?
Diego Luna walks through a scrapyard of ships in a scene from Andor.

For as long as both entities have existed, fans of science fiction and fantasy have debated the merits of Star Trek and Star Wars. But for most of the 45 years that the two franchises have overlapped, Star Trek and Star Wars haven’t actually had much in common, apart from their cosmic setting. Star Trek is an aspirational sci-fi series set in humanity’s future, while Star Wars is a bombastic fantasy adventure that takes place in a far-off galaxy. One has primarily lived on weekly television, while the other has broken big-screen box office numbers.
However, in recent years, both Star Trek and Star Wars have become tentpoles for their parent companies’ subscription streaming services, Paramount+ and Disney+, respectively, each pumping out a steady stream of content in an ever-widening array of formats. This has led them to encroach further into each other’s territory than ever before. Star Trek vs. Star Wars is no longer an apples-to-oranges comparison — they are directly competing products, sharing some of the same ambitions and struggling against the same environmental forces.
We will likely never settle on which space franchise is the greatest of all time, but we can take a moment to ask: Which is better right now?

Star Trek and Star Wars have both leaned heavily into fan service

Read more