Skip to main content

Google execs say we need a plan to stop A.I. algorithms from amplifying racism

Two Google executives said Friday that bias in artificial intelligence is hurting already marginalized communities in America, and that more needs to be done to ensure that this does not happen. X. Eyeé, outreach lead for responsible innovation at Google, and Angela Williams, policy manager at Google, spoke at (Not IRL) Pride Summit, an event organized by Lesbians Who Tech & Allies, the world’s largest technology-focused LGBTQ organization for women, non-binary and trans people around the world.

In separate talks, they addressed the ways in which machine learning technology can be used to harm the black community and other communities in America — and more widely around the world.

Bias in algorithms IS NOT JUST A DATA PROBLEM. The choice to use AI can be biased, the way the algorithm learns can be biased, and the way users are impacted/interact with/perceive a system can reinforce bias! checkout @timnitGebru’s work to learn more!

— X. Eyeé ???????? (@TechWithX) June 26, 2020

Williams discussed the use of A.I. for sweeping surveillance, its role in over-policing, and its implementation for biased sentencing. “[It’s] not that the technology is racist, but we can code in our own unconscious bias into the technology,” she said. Williams highlighted the case of Robert Julian-Borchak Williams, an African American man from Detroit who was recently wrongly arrested after a facial recognition system incorrectly matched his photo with security footage of a shoplifter. Previous studies have shown that facial recognition systems can struggle to distinguish between different black people. “This is where A.I. … surveillance can go terribly wrong in the real world,” Williams said.

X. Eyeé also discussed how A.I. can help “scale and reinforce unfair bias.” In addition to the more quasi-dystopian, attention-grabbing uses of A.I., Eyeé focused on the way in which bias could creep into more seemingly mundane, everyday uses of technology — including Google’s own tools. “At Google, we’re no stranger to these challenges,” Eyeé said. “In recent years … we’ve been in the headlines multiple times for how our algorithms have negatively impacted people.” For instance, Google has developed a tool for classifying the toxicity of comments online. While this can be very helpful, it was also problematic: Phrases like “I am a black gay woman” were initially classified as more toxic than “I am a white man.” This was due to a gap in training data sets, with more conversations about certain identities than others.

There are no overarching fixes to these problems, the two Google executives said. Wherever problems are found, Google works to iron out bias. But the scope of potential places where bias can enter systems — from the design of algorithms to their deployment to the societal context under which data is produced — means that there will always be problematic examples. The key is to be aware of this, to allow such tools to be scrutinized, and for diverse communities to be able to make their voices heard about the use of these technologies.

Editors' Recommendations

Luke Dormehl
I'm a UK-based tech writer covering Cool Tech at Digital Trends. I've also written for Fast Company, Wired, the Guardian…
Google CEO Sundar Pichai warns of dangers of A.I. and calls for more regulation
Google & Alphabet CEO Sundar Pichai

Citing concerns about the rise of deepfakes and the potential abuses of facial recognition technology, Google CEO Sundar Pichai declared in an op-ed in the Financial Times that artificial intelligence should be more tightly regulated: "We need to be clear-eyed about what could go wrong" with A.I., Pichai wrote.

The Alphabet and Google executive wrote about the positive developments that A.I. can bring, such as recent work by Google finding that A.I. can detect breast cancer more accurately than doctors, or Google's project to use A.I. to more accurately predict rainfall in local areas. But he also warned that "history is full of examples of how technology’s virtues aren’t guaranteed" and that "[t]he internet made it possible to connect with anyone and get information from anywhere, but also easier for misinformation to spread."

Read more
Google’s A.I. can now detect breast cancer more accurately than doctors can
artificial virus kills cancer cells cell

Google’s artificial intelligence technology is able to spot signs of breast cancer in women with more accuracy than doctors, according to a new study. 

The study, published on Wednesday, January 1, in the scientific journal Nature, found that by using A.I. technology, there was a reduction in false positives and false negatives when it came to diagnosing forms of breast cancer.

Read more
A.I. can remove distortions from underwater photos, streamlining ocean research
nasa coral reef climate change lush tropical shore and corals underwater

Light behaves differently in water than it does on the surface -- and that behavior creates the blur or green tint common in underwater photographs as well as the haze that blocks out vital details. But thanks to research from an oceanographer and engineer and a new artificial intelligence program called Sea-Thru, that haze and those occluded colors could soon disappear.

Besides putting a downer on the photos from that snorkeling trip, the inability to get an accurately colored photo underwater hinders scientific research at a time when concern for coral and ocean health is growing. That’s why oceanographer and engineer Derya Akkaynak, along with Tali Treibitz and the University of Haifa, devoted their research to developing an artificial intelligence that can create scientifically accurate colors while removing the haze in underwater photos.

Read more