Deepfake or fake news? Zuckerberg says Facebook might treat them differently

mark zuckerberg deepfakes aspen ideas festival facebook hosts annual f8 developer conference in san jose
(Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images) Justin Sullivan / Getty Images

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg says that his company is considering treating deepfakes differently from traditional fake news and misinformation, which could make it easier for Facebook to delete the altered videos before they spread.

Deepfakes, or incredibly realistic altered videos that can make it seem like a person said or did something they never did, have become an increasing problem on social media platforms. Facebook came under fire recently over a less-advanced deepfake purporting to show Nancy Pelosi slurring her words, which spread throughout the network.

“We’re going through the policy process of thinking through what the deepfake policy should be,” he said Wednesday during an interview with Harvard Professor Cass Sunstein at the Aspen Ideas Festival. “This is certainly a really important area as the A.I. technology gets better and one that I think is likely sensible to have a different policy and to treat this differently than how we just treat normal false information on the internet.”

Right now, Facebook relies on independent fact-checkers to verify controversial content. If they determine that something is fake or misleading, the network will limit its distribution — so it won’t show up in your news feed. If you do see a photo or video that’s been flagged as false, it’ll be labeled as such. 

But the system doesn’t always work: Zuckerberg said the Pelosi video “got more distribution than our policies allowed” and was able to spread across Facebook over the course of more than a day before fact-checkers could flag it as false, something Zuckerberg called an “execution mistake on our side.” The company still hasn’t removed the video, and Zuckerberg said Facebook has to be cautious about when and how it removes content.

The Pelosi video was a more basic form of a deepfake that made her seem like she was slurring her words by cutting it up and slowing it down. Zuckerberg said that simple edits that eliminate context or change speed or pitch aren’t quite at the level of advanced deepfakes.

“I think we need to be very careful,” he said, adding that it’s not up to Facebook to delete every video that’s edited in a way that its subject dislikes. 

The Pelosi video remains online, but a more advanced deepfake — like a one purporting to show Zuckerberg himself praising a shadowy organization called “Spectre” might be a different story. 

“I definitely think there’s a good case that deepfakes are different from traditional misinformation, just like spam is different from traditional misinformation and should be treated differently,” he said. 

As technology advances, deepfakes are likely to become an increasing nuisance or even a major problem on social media. Experts say we’re not far away from almost anyone being able to create a convincing deepfakes from a single photo. Other social networks, notably YouTube, have struggled to keep up pace with the rapid development and spread of deepfakes, most notably when and how to delete them.

Celebrities like Zuckerberg or Kim Kardashian have legal teams to deal with deepfakes, but as they become more common and begin to target normal users, Facebook and others will likely need to determine exactly how to treat them.  


Is Facebook biased against conservatives? Here’s what a GOP-led report found

A report by former Arizona GOP Senator Jon Kyl took a look at whether Facebook is biased against conservatives. The report found that conservatives don't trust Facebook, but found little in the way of anti-conservative bias on the platform.
Social Media

How to control the private data that apps and websites share with Facebook

Facebook finally introduced a tool that allows you to control and limit the data that third-party apps and websites share with the social media giant, a feature that should help improve Facebook's much-criticized stance on privacy.

China is running Hong Kong disinformation campaigns through Facebook and Twitter

Facebook and Twitter removed accounts from their platforms that they say were focused on discrediting the protests in Hong Kong. The social networks found accounts, pages, and groups that had coordinated, manipulative content.

Facebook admits it was listening to your private conversations, too

Facebook outsourced contractors to listen in on your audio messenger chats and transcribe them. Contractors were not told why they were listening in or why they were transcribing them. Facebook said it is no longer transcribing audio. 

Facebook is going to add its name to Instagram and WhatsApp

Facebook plans to add its name to both Instagram and WhatsApp as politicians call for the social media giant to be broken apart and the FTC investigates Facebook’s acquisition of both companies.

These are the 10 most disliked videos on YouTube

Ever wondered which videos are the most disliked videos on YouTube? Well, we have the top ten list you’re looking for. Here are the latest videos with the most dislikes currently on YouTube.

WhatsApp has 400 million users in India, but no fix for its fake news problem

WhatsApp is struggling to stem the tide of fake news in India, its biggest market. In the last few years, its platform has been inundated with an around-the-clock avalanche of misinformation -- misleading mobs into lynching innocents and…

Telegram’s new Slow Mode aims to bring order to noisy group chats

Messaging app Telegram has just released some new features that are bound to please. Slow Mode aims to bring some order to group chats, while Silent Messages ensures you won’t wake your buddy if you get in touch late in the day.
Social Media

The EU could hit Facebook with billions in fines over privacy violations

The European Union is reportedly nearing the end of its investigations into some of the cases it has opened against Facebook pertaining to the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation or GDPR. The EU currently has 11 open cases against the…
Social Media

Quit hitting refresh: Twitter is testing a subscribe to tweet replies feature

Soon you might be able to get a push notification when a tweet has been replied to as well. Twitter is currently testing a new feature that will allow users to turn on notifications for a particular thread.

How to make a GIF from a YouTube video

Making a GIF from a YouTube video is easier than ever, but choosing the right tool to use isn't always so simple. In this guide, we'll teach you how to make a GIF from a YouTube video with our three favorite tools.
Social Media

How to add music to Instagram videos

Have you ever taken a beautiful video, only to have it ruined by some jerk in the background yelling curse words? Here's a list of apps you can use to add your own music to Instagram posts as well as your Story.

The best dating apps for 2019

Everyone knows online dating can be stressful, time-consuming, and downright awful. Check out our top picks for the best dating apps, so you can streamline the process and find the right date, whatever you're looking for.
Social Media

Twitter’s latest effort to tackle abusive content focuses on Direct Messages

Twitter launched a new feature designed to filter out abusive Direct Messages from people you don't follow. The content is collected in one place and can still be viewed if you want to periodically check what's coming in.