Skip to main content

Planet Nine could be a miniature black hole hiding in our solar system

An artist’s impression of a black hole. ANDRZEJ WOJCICKI/SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY

The concept of a ninth planet in our solar system which orbits far beyond Neptune captured the public’s imagination in 2016, and earlier this year the idea gained steam again when astronomers found more evidence in support of “Planet Nine’s” existence. Now, a different team of astronomers has suggested an even more intriguing idea: That the strange body we’re seeing evidence of is not a planet but a miniature black hole.

The researchers consider what they describe as an “exciting possibility,” that the strange movements of the objects which orbit the sun beyond Neptune could be explained by the presence of a primordial black hole. Despite how unlikely that sounds, the authors believe that “this scenario is not unreasonable” and they suggest a way to test it by looking for evidence of a dark matter microhalo around the mini black hole.

Primordial black holes are a theoretical type of black hole that formed in the earliest universe, soon after the Big Bang. As the early universe was very dense, it may have been possible for black holes to form not from the collapse of stars but on a much smaller scale. These tiny speculative objects could weigh as little as one times the mass of the Earth, and a black hole five times the mass of the Earth could fit in the palm of your hand, while one 10 times the mass of the Earth would be about the size of a bowling ball.

That means these black holes would be far smaller than the ones we are used to studying, so it would be possible for one to be located within our solar system and us to have not noticed it yet.

To search for the potential mini black hole in our cosmic backyard, we’ll have to be creative in the tools we use. Black holes absorb any light which passes beyond their event horizon, so they’re hard to spot. But the researchers suggest that a planet-mass black hole would have a halo of dark matter around it, which could stretch up to 1 billion kilometers from its center. Although we can’t detect dark matter directly, we can look for dark matter particles interacting and creating bursts of gamma rays which would give a clue to the presence of a black hole.

To test their theories, the researchers’ next step is to search through data from the Fermi Gamma-Ray Space Telescope, looking for telltale gamma-ray bursts that could help them identify our solar system’s potentially most elusive body.

The paper is available to view online on the pre-publication archive arXiv.

Editors' Recommendations

Georgina Torbet
Georgina is the Digital Trends space writer, covering human space exploration, planetary science, and cosmology. She…
Astronomers spot a monster black hole ‘practically in our backyard’
The cross-hairs mark the location of the newly discovered monster black hole.

Black holes come in a variety of sizes, from stellar black holes a few times the mass of the sun all the way up to supermassive black holes, which are millions of times the mass of the sun and lurk at the heart of galaxies. Recently, astronomers discovered a massive black hole just 1,550 light-years away, which is right in our neighborhood, astronomically speaking. It is one of the closest black holes ever discovered, with a mass 12 times that of the sun. Being so close to us, it's an exciting target for future research.

The cross-hairs mark the location of the newly discovered monster black hole. Sloan Digital Sky Survey / S. Chakrabart et al.

Read more
Something strange is up with this black hole
Artist’s illustration of tidal disruption event AT2019dsg where a supermassive black hole spaghettifies and gobbles down a star. Some of the material is not consumed by the black hole and is flung back out into space.

One of the first things that people learn about black holes is that they absorb everything which comes close to them, but this isn't exactly accurate. It is true that once anything passes the event horizon of a black hole it can never escape, but there is a significant area around the black hole where its gravitational effects are still extremely strong but things can still escape. In fact, black holes regularly give off dramatic jets of matter, which are typically thrown out when material falls into the black hole and a small amount is ejected outward at great speeds.

But astronomers recently discovered a totally mysterious phenomenon, where a black hole is ejecting material years after it ripped apart a star. The black hole AT2019dsg is located 665 million light-years away and was observed tearing apart the star in 2018, then for unknown reasons, it became extremely active again in 2021. “This caught us completely by surprise — no one has ever seen anything like this before,” said lead author Yvette Cendes, a research associate at the Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian (CfA).

Read more
Astronomers want your help to spot hidden black holes
This simulation of a supermassive black hole shows how it distorts the starry background and captures light, producing a black hole silhouettes.

Black holes are some of the most mind-bending objects in the universe. They are so dense that anything which passes their event horizon, even light, can't escape. That's where they get their name, as the black hole itself is impossible to see. Fortunately for researchers, many black holes have material like dust and gas around them, and when this material falls into a black hole it can give off bursts of X-rays which allow them to locate the black hole.

But this isn't the case for every black hole. Some are not taking in material, meaning they don't give off X-rays and are much harder to locate. Now, a citizen science project is inviting members of the public to help search for these "hidden" black holes.

Read more