Skip to main content

Porsche and McLaren battle again to see which is faster: the P1 or 918 Spyder?

porsche 918 and mclaren p1 battle head to mp1p918
Autocar
It may be a while before Top Gear manages to sort itself out and get the triple crown of supercars together for one big shootout, but in the mean time, we can at least find out which is faster: McLaren P1 and Porsche 918.

The crew at Motor Trend set out to succeed where they didn’t (or haven’t yet, if you want to remain optimistic), trying to procure the trio for their own test. While they did bag a LaFerrari, it was La-not-allowed-to-be-used-for-data-acquisition, as Ferrari did not grant their request for permission.

Still, a shootout between two hypercars is hardly a waste of a day, right?

McLaren’s P1 packs a 3.8-liter twin turbo V8 that, in conjunction with an electric motor, will put out 908 horsepower to the rear wheels through a seven-speed dual-clutch transmission.

McLaren P1 ( class=
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Similarly, the Porsche 918 is powered by a 4.6-liter V8 coupled to two electric motors, giving it a total output of 887 horsepower to all four wheels by way of Porsche’s own seven-speed PDK dual clutch.

These are two interestingly different approaches to the same concept: Hybrid hyper performance, and while numbers can be talked about all day, its what happens on the track that mattered.

Porsche 918 Spyder
Image used with permission by copyright holder

MT had both set to give it their all around Mazda’s Laguna Seca raceway, and through the many runs, it seems that this time, the Porsche came out on top with a 1:29.89 followed closely by the McLaren in 1:30.71.

Both cars had their own nuances, according to driver Randy Pobst who took both out for their times.

It looks like a pretty clear win for the Porsche, who have won this battle, but there are many tracks out there, so they have yet to securely win the war. We’re looking forward to seeing more side-by-side tests like these, but we’re even more eager for Ferrari to let the LaFerrari join in on the fun.

Editors' Recommendations

Alexander Kalogianni
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Alex K is an automotive writer based in New York. When not at his keyboard or behind the wheel of a car, Alex spends a lot of…
The 10 best car battery brands in 2024
How to test a car battery

You must know this, but your car needs a battery to run properly. A dead battery means a car won't start, but various electronics in the car won't work properly either, including overhead dome lights, the radio, and even some security features, like door locks or alerts. So, it's in your best interest to ensure your vehicle's battery is in tip-top shape at all times. It's especially important if your car or vehicle sits unused for long periods. A trickle charger can help keep the battery powered in those situations, or worst case, a portable jump starter can help you get it going. But eventually, you're going to need to replace your battery, and it will help to know the best car battery brands out there so you know precisely what to replace your old one with. Let's discuss.
AC Delco
In operation for more than a century, AC Delco has been recommended as "the only batteries" for GM vehicles. You'll find them at retailers like AutoZone, O'Reilly Auto Parts, Amazon, and even some Walmarts. They're reliable, reasonably priced, and come with a good warranty, 18 months or above, depending on where you buy. A great AC Delco battery to call out is the Advantage series.

Bosch
Bosch is a solid mid-grade battery provider both in quality and price. They do have some affordable options, but their premium lines are still reasonably priced, with several tiers available for a wide variety of vehicles. The downside is that Bosch batteries are not carried by all retailers like some of the other options on our list, but you can find them online. You can also visit a Bosch service center if there's one near you. Callouts are the S4 to S6 series and the T4 to T6 series. We will say the brand's four-year free replacement warranty is unmatched.

Read more
Tesla’s fix for faulty Cybertruck pedal is simpler than you might think
Tesla Cybertruck

Less than five months after handing over the first Cybertrucks to customers, Tesla has had to recall the electric pickup to fix an issue with the accelerator.

In a notice issued on Friday, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) said that the recall impacts Cybertruck vehicles manufactured from November 13, 2023, to April 4, 2024. This suggests that all -- or almost all -- of the 3,878 Cybertrucks being recalled are those that have been manufactured to date.

Read more
Ford Mustang Mach-E 2024 vs. Mach-E 2023: What’s new in Ford’s electric Mustang?
Blue Ford Mustang Mach-E on a rooftop

The Ford Mustang Mach-E is easily one of the best EVs for the price, offering a solid range, sleek design, and pretty good tech on the inside. In recent years, it has gotten even cheaper -- thanks in large part to a price war between it and the Tesla Model 3. And, the company just took the wraps off of the latest and greatest version of the Mach-E, labeled as the 2024 model.

The 2024 Mustang Mach-E is notably different from the 2023 iteration in some meaningful ways. So much so that we decided to take a look at the two head-to-head -- to see if it was better to pay for the 2024 model or save some cash on any remaining 2023 stock.
Design
The Mustang Mach-E looks relatively unique -- in a good way. And thankfully, Ford has largely kept the overall design the same for the 2024 model, at least when it comes to the more consumer-focused models. The car retains the slatted taillights and crossover size. It also offers a large selection of colors, including the very blue Grabber Blue Metallic, as well as Rapid Red Metallic. It's a good selection of colors, and there should be an option for most buyers.

Read more