Skip to main content

A fake picture won Nikon’s photography contest, and the Internet had a field day

At first glance, Chay Yu Wei’s shot of a plane passing overhead looks like a remarkable capture, with the aircraft perfectly framed by a ladder and its safety cage.

Indeed, Nikon Singapore was so impressed with the picture that last Thursday it awarded the photographer a prize in a contest titled Look Up. However, other photographers quickly spotted that Yu Wei’s winning image was actually the result of some rather ropey post processing.

“Yu Wei chanced upon a set of ladders while on a photowalk with his friends in Chinatown, and thought the view above would make an interesting perspective,” Nikon wrote in a Facebook post announcing the prizewinning shot, adding, “Little did he expect to catch an airplane in mid-air.” That’s absolutely true, which is probably why he decided to insert one himself.

As many of Nikon’s Facebook followers pointed out, a simple of adjustment of the image’s exposure reveals Yu Wei’s photo for what it is  – a fake.

Of course, once others had drawn attention to the mischievous transgression, it didn’t take long for the connected masses to wade in with their own humorous take on the matter….

plane 2
Render Brant
Render Brant
plane 3
Glenn Guan
Glenn Guan
plane 4
Zhirong Fu
Zhirong Fu
plane 5
Eric Benson
Eric Benson

[Images via BoredPanda]

On Saturday, Nikon told its Facebook fans it’d made “an honest mistake,” while promising to “tighten our image review process to avoid similar situations in the future.”

It also thanked everyone for their humorous responses.

Apparently still niggled by the slip-up, the camera company took to its Facebook page again on Sunday to announce that it was about to remove the competition page – including all the witty responses –as the fake image “should not have a place beside other good contributions from the community.”

One user pleaded with Nikon to keep the page, saying many were enjoying “the massive work contributed by the community in the comments section [which] brought joy and unity to the masses.” But Nikon took it down anyway.

As for the photographer, he, too, has since apologized for causing such a fuss. In a post on Instagram, Yu Wei wrote, “I snapped a picture of [the ladder] and subsequently felt that a plane at that spot would make for an interesting point of view. Hence, I inserted the plane with PicsArt and uploaded it to Instagram….it was not meant to bluff anyone. I would have done it with Photoshop if I really meant to lie about it, but no, it was a playful edit using the PicsArt app and uploaded to Instagram.”

He said he’d “crossed the line” by submitting the photo for a competition, adding, “I’m really sorry to Nikon for disrespecting the competition and I sincerely apologize….to all Nikon Photographers, and to the photography community as general.”

Editors' Recommendations

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
How to hide photos on an Android phone or tablet
Google Photos

While today's best Android phones are quite secure as long as they remain locked with a passcode or biometrics like a fingerprint, by default those features only protect the front door. If someone picks up your phone while it's unlocked, there aren't typically any barriers that will keep them out of exploring everything from your contacts and emails to your photos.

This can be particularly challenging when it comes to photos, since those are the things we like to show off the most from our phones. We've likely all had those moments when we want to show a friend or co-worker a funny cat meme, so we hand over our phone and trust that they won't swipe right and see the photo of the hairy mole that we sent to our doctor that morning.

Read more
Best Sony A7 III deals: Save $300 on the full frame mirrorless camera
Sony A7 III

Sony A7 III Daven Mathies/Digital Trends / .

Even if you have one of the best camera phones at the moment, if you're a photography fanatic, you're probably feeling the burn for something new and exciting. For example, the Sony A7 III line is like none other in the world of handheld cameras and you can find several cameras in that line on sale right now at Best Buy. Here, we round up the best deals in the sale, then analyze how buying a Sony Alpha A7 III looks at the moment.
Today's best Sony A7 III deals

Read more
How to use (almost) any camera as a webcam for Zoom and more
how to use any camera as a web cam v2 00 58 01 still007

Cameras, even those in phones, brag about megapixels and lens specifications -- but laptops? Not so much. There’s a reason computer companies don’t say much about the webcams that come built into the bezels of their screens. Most of these cameras are low-quality, with tiny sensors and cheap lenses. Sure, they work for basic videoconferencing, but they aren’t very impressive and certainly leave us wanting something more.

While you could just buy a stand-alone webcam that connects over USB, to really take production value up a notch, you can opt for a DSLR or mirrorless camera. You’ll need a few workarounds to get this type of camera to be recognized as a webcam by your computer, but the trouble is worth it for the higher resolution, much better low-light performance, and cinematic background blur.

Read more