Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Audio / Video
  3. Legacy Archives

Comcast encrypts all cable channels, requires all customers to use a set-top box

Add as a preferred source on Google

Comcast DTAGot Comcast? Hope you like little black boxes, because you’ll be needing them to get any kind of cable TV service soon. According to a recent statement made on its website’s help and support pages, Comcast is making good on an FCC ruling which allows the company to encrypt even its most basic channels such that they can’t be viewed without the use of a digital adapter, converter box or CableCard-enabled device. 

Until now, Comcast customers with a digital television, DVR or TV tuner card for their computers could access Comcast’s most basic channel packages without the use of any additional equipment. In some markets, those packages may even include channels like Discovery, AMC and WGN in addition to local affiliates of ABC CBS, NBC, FOX and PBS, all of which broadcast their signals over the air for free. Most people pay for the basic channel packages, but a little-known secret is that, in some areas, if you subscribed to Comcast’s Internet service, these channels were being piped into your home anyway and were available at no additional cost. In fact, we know a few folks who have taken advantage of this little loophole over the past few years. 

Recommended Videos

It is important to note that the DTA (digital transport adapter) box brings no advantages to the table. In fact, it will strip some of Comcast’s customers of their ability to watch some of their stations in HD. The DTA doesn’t allow access to on-screen programming guides or any on-demand services either. It is, in essence, a de-scrambler and nothing more. Customers are faced with the added hassle of either programming the extremely basic DTA remote with their TV’s remote code or, conversely, programming their TV remote with the DTA’s code. 

Is Comcast just closing this loophole? Hardly. By requiring the use of company-owned equipment, Comcast not only ensures nobody gets a free ride, it also secures itself a new revenue stream. To be fair, Comcast is offering Limited Basic customers who have been getting their service box-free up to two DTA devices (digital adapters) free of charge for up to two years. After the two years is up, each DTA in use will come with a fee assessed at “market rate” – currently $1.99 per device. Those who make changes to their service will have to start paying the fees right away. 

The move also presents Comcast with an opportunity to soften the impact of lost revenue when fledgling cord-cutters call to cancel their cable service in favor of on-demand services such as Netflix, Hulu and Amazon Instant. Comcast recently began offering a new Internet package which tacks on its Limited Basic cable service on top of its Blast Internet service for just $5.00 more – a deal that seems hard to pass up. Add in two or three DTA boxes, though, and the fees go up further still. 

Are there any options to renting Comcast’s DTA boxes? Not really. You can pick up a DTA at ebay for a few bucks, but Comcast considers devices like that as “stolen” and will not activate them. For now, if you want to watch any Comcast cable channels, you’ll have to pick up a DTA for each TV you want serviced. Otherwise, you might want to start warming up to the idea of picking up a good digital antenna for free OTA (over the air) reception of your local channels. For tips on this and other cord-cutting ideas, visit our Cord Cutting 101 topics page

image via stopthecap.com

Caleb Denison
Caleb Denison is a sought-after writer, speaker, and television correspondent with unmatched expertise in AV and…
Stop joining group projects with a blurry laptop webcam and buy one of these instead
Your laptop webcam is sabotaging your first impression. These five can fix it
I'm holding my Logitech C920 1080p webcam in my hands.

The webcam built into your laptop might be good enough for a quick call with friends and family. But its shortcomings become much harder to ignore when you are presenting a semester project, interviewing for an internship, or maybe if you're planning to stream for fun.

Laptop cameras also tend to sit far too low, especially when the computer is placed directly on a desk. Meanwhile, a dedicated webcam lets you position the camera closer to eye level. This improves the framing and brings larger sensors, better microphones, and more effective low-light processing.

Read more
I desperately want a new classic Walkman, but Sony probably can’t give me one
Tech minimalism is begging for a new Walkman. Though rebuilding it may be close to impossible
Sony Walkman WM2011

Every few months, another piece of tech that seems obsolete crawls out of a drawer and becomes cool again. The age of minimalism has revived the popularity of iPods among younger buyers. Dumbphones have become an escape hatch from endless notifications. Similarly, digital cameras are dangling from bags again. Physical media keeps attracting people who want something they can actually hold instead of another frustrating subscription.

All of this makes it the perfect time for Sony to bring back the classic Walkman, which was a phenomenon during the 80s and 90s. I would love one. Give me a compact cassette player, physical buttons, and wired headphones. Keep the apps, notifications, and algorithms that shape your taste of music. No more AI assistants or personalzied feeds, just you and your Walkman. There is only one problem though. Recreating the Walkman that people love and remember, would be far harder than putting an old design back into production.

Read more
Proton reveals how smart TVs track you and the escape situation is pretty grim 
Modern smart TVs fingerprint your screen content at the chipset level.
Google TV applications on the Sony A95K TV.

Your smart TV may know far more about your viewing habits than you realize, even if you rarely use its smart features. In a new privacy explainer, Proton warns that many modern TVs quietly collect data about everything displayed on the screen and share it with manufacturers, advertisers, and analytics companies.

The worrying part is that escaping this tracking is becoming increasingly difficult because many privacy controls are buried deep in settings or enabled by default. Proton argues that buying a smart TV today often means accepting a level of surveillance that most people never knowingly signed up for.

Read more