Skip to main content

Apple Would Ditch DRM ‘In a Heartbeat’

Facing pressure from European nations and other market forces to open up its iTunes store or at least license its FairPlay DRM technology to other companies, Apple CEO Steve Jobs has made an unusual move: he’s published an open letter, “Thoughts on Music” in which be says Apple would get rid of digital rights management technology “in a heartbeat” if only record companies would let it sell unprotected music.

In the letter, Jobs outlined three possible paths forward for the digital music industry:

  1. The industry could stick with the current model, with DRM technology “protecting” media and irritating consumers.
  2. Apple could license FairPlay to competitors, potentially enabling them to build devices and services compatible with protected media purchased from iTunes.
  3. The industry could get rid of DRM entirely and sell music in open, licensable formats.

Jobs notes that DRM was one of the requirements of the big four record labels (Sony BMG, EMI, Warner Music, and Universal) when Apple sparked the digital music industry with the iTunes Music Store: since those four labels distribute some 70 percent of the world’s music, the industry needed to have them on board if the business was to go anywhere. Those labels haven’t altered their stance: if their music is going to be sold digitally, it must be protected. So Apple (and other online music vendors) employ DRM systems to deter copyright infringement.

Jobs concludes that licensing FairPlay to others would ultimately do more harm than good, even if some consumers benefitted from increased interoperability and Apple earned some money from licensing the technology. Jobs’ stance: ultimately, licensing FairPlay means the details of the technology will leak. That means tools which cripple and strip FairPlay-encoded media of its protections will run rampant, and Apple will be unable to move quickly to stop the bleeding. Ultimately, that would undermine the entire industry, and Jobs says Apple has refused to license FairPlay to prevent this scenario, and speculates that might be why Microsoft abandoned Windows DRM in its Zune media player.

The third option—getting rid of DRM entirely—”is clearly the best alternative for consumers, and Apple would embrace it in a heartbeat.” The problem? Those big four record labels. Jobs notes that these music companies are selling 90 percent of their music without DRM already (in the form of audio CDs), and wonders what benefit they get from requiring DRM on downloadable music. Jobs then goes on to urge consumer and music listeners—particularly in European countries—to stop hassling Apple over its use of DRM technology, and get to work on convincing the record labels that a DRM free digital music market would ultimately be to their benefit. Apple would embrace a DRM-free market “wholeheartedly.”

Jobs’ public letter is an interesting move for a leading figure in the digital media industry, and the sort of thing one would generally like to encourage amongst the movers and shakers of the world. However, it’s implication that he (and Apple) are somehow powerless to influence the big four record companies falls a little flat. After all, Apple and Jobs are the ones who convinced the labels to take their content online, and has held them to uniform pricing despite much grumbling. As Jobs notes, only about three percent of the content on an average iPod is purchased via iTunes, and the record companies’ mandate for protection has essentially shown that DRM systems don’t work as a way to combat music piracy. Perhaps consumers are trying to vote with their feet by purchasing 2 billion online tracks during 2006, and Apple could help the record companies add two and two behind closed doors, where the world doesn’t have to see them counting on their fingers.

Editors' Recommendations

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
This BLUETTI portable power station is truly weatherproof
Man using BLUETTI AC240 portable power station while camping to cook

It seems like we're covering a new BLUETTI launch here at Digital Trends every month, but that's okay. Thanks to the brand's excellent products, innovative advancements, and great features, people all over can access reliable power. Its latest launch, the BLUETTI AC240, is an IP65-rated weatherproof portable power station that delivers a comprehensive energy solution for outdoor enthusiasts, first responders, and beyond. Protected against dust, water, and elements, this expandable station creates an uninterrupted power source in any environment at any time. Moreover, it empowers users to stay connected, even with power-hungry devices, to tackle demanding tasks regardless of the current weather, environment, or location. Right now, you can save big by taking advantage of Early Bird pricing.
Buy Now
 
Why you should buy the BLUETTI AC240 all-weather portable power station

Imagine for a moment that you're camping with your family, hiking through the great outdoors, or even taking a long, scenic road trip through the countryside. In all of these situations, even when you're off-grid, you'll still need reliable access to power to charge your phone and tablet(s) and power up other electronics -- like a coffee maker when you wake up in the morning. Of course, power stations and power outlets don't exist randomly out in the wild. You could use your vehicle, but that will drain the battery and, in some cases, still won't provide enough power for what you want to do. Cue the BLUETTI AC240 portable power station and devices like it.

Read more
Snag this Roomba robot vacuum while it’s discounted to $180
iRobot Roomba 694 at Best Buy - WiFi connected robot vacuum

If you're on the hunt for robot vacuum deals because you think you need help from one of these cleaning devices to keep your floors spotless, you should head on over to Crutchfield where the iRobot Roomba 694 is available at $95 off. From its original price of $275, you'll only have to pay $180, which is an excellent price for all of the conveniences that you'll get from this machine. We're not sure how much time is remaining before this offer expires though, so you better hurry and complete your purchase while you can still pocket the savings.

Why you should buy the iRobot Roomba 694 robot vacuum
For its relatively affordable price, the iRobot Roomba 694 offers most of the important features that you would expect from a robot vacuum. It comes with a three-stage cleaning system that includes an edge-sweeping brush, roller brushes, and powerful vacuum suction. You'll be able to control the device through the iRobot Home app on your smartphone or using voice commands through smart home devices that are powered by Google Assistant or Amazon's Alexa. Once the iRobot Roomba 694 is done, or when its battery runs low in the middle of cleaning, it will automatically returns to its base station for recharging.

Read more
DeWalt Spring Black Friday sale: Power tools and accessories from $15
A DeWalt drill being used.

If you have grand plans for a major home renovation project, you need the right power tools to facilitate this. Fortunately, there’s a huge DeWalt Spring Black Friday sale going on at Amazon so you can save big on plenty of great power tools as well as accessories for enriching the experience. There are hundreds of options within the DeWalt sale so the best thing you can do is hit the button below right now and see what’s out there for yourself. However, if you want some inspiration of what to consider, keep reading and we’ll take you through what we love most.

What to shop for in the DeWalt Spring Black Friday sale
Seemingly every household renovation task can be made easier with a good quality drill. That’s why it’s a great idea to buy the which is down to $99 from $179. A considerable saving of 45%, you get a compact and lightweight drill driver which can deliver 300 unit watts out of power. Its high speed transmission has two speeds of either 0-450 and 1,500 rpm with a 1/2-inch single sleeve ratcheting chuck which provides tight bit gripping strength. It’s the workhorse everyone needs and is sure to last.

Read more