HTC levels new infringement suit at Apple

By Geoff Duncan August 16, 2011

iPad 2 — Image used with permission by copyright holder

HTC might have been making polite overtures to Apple lately about resolving the companies’ high-stakes and complex patent litigation, but the company seems to have returned to the tried-and-true legal tactic of putting more pressure on its opponent. Reuters reports HTC has filed a new infringement suit against Apple in the U.S. District Court in Delaware, claiming all of Apple’s major hardware product lines—iPods, iPads, iPhones, and even Macs—infringe on three HTC patents.

As is typical with infringement suits, HTC is asking that allegedly infringing products be barred from import in to the United States; HTC is also asking for triple damages and other compensation.

One of the patents in HTC’s lawsuit was developed by HTC and involves connecting a PDA to a wireless communications system. The other two patents in the suit involve mobile communications technology patents that came from ADC Technologies, which HTC acquired back in April for $75 million.

The lawsuit is the latest in a complex series of suits between the two companies, which the industry is viewing as a bit of a battle-by-proxy over Google’s Android platform—which Google may have just tried to protect with its announced $12.5 billion acquisition of Motorola Mobility. So far, Google has yet to confront Apple directly over patent issues related to Android, but that day may be coming soon: Apple and Motorola also have a complex web of infringement suits and countersuits between them.

HTC’s decision to quickly go after Apple with patents acquired from ADC Technologies may also be a harbinger of legal action to come: HTC recently just announced plans to acquire S3 Graphics, and the U.S. International Trade Commission has issued a preliminary ruling that Apple’s Mac OS X—though not iOS—violates two S3 Graphics patents.

Neither Apple nor HTC have commented on the latest lawsuit.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…

Mobile

Apple has quietly killed its cheapest iPad

Three 2021 iPads are stacked on a table.

The iPad lineup has received a price bump after Apple quietly killed its cheapest iPad model. Apple’s 9th-generation iPad used to cost $329, but has been discontinued. At the same time, the company has reduced the 10th-gen iPad’s starting price by $100, which means it’s now priced at $349. As a result, getting the cheapest iPad means you'll now spend $20 more than before.

The 9th-gen Apple iPad was launched in 2021 with the A13 chipset and Apple's Center Stage featur,e but retained the same old design with the already-old Lightning port and home button. With Apple moving to a USB-C port on all devices to comply with EU laws, it was inevitable that Apple would discontinue the 9th-gen iPad this year. The iPhone SE remains the only Apple product with a home button and a Lightning port that's still available in the company's lineup.

Mobile

Apple updated two of its biggest iPad apps, and they look amazing

A screenshot of the new Final Cut Pro app.

Apple pulled off a surprise today with a pair of new iPad Pros that leverage the new M4 silicon. To go with it, the company has also revealed updated versions of the Final Cut Pro and Logic Pro apps that introduce a healthy bunch of new features to take advantage of all the firepower the M4 offers.

Starting with Final Cut Pro 2 for iPad, the app gains new tricks such as Live Multicam, external drive support, Live Drawing, and more. Apple claims that thanks to the M4 silicon, the updated app boosts rendering speeds by 2x and opens the doors for 4x higher streams for editing ProRES RAW content.

Mobile

Apple’s new iPad Air is official, with a lot of big upgrades

An official photo of the 2024 iPad Air.

Apple unveiled two new iPad Air models -- an 11-inch version and a 13-inch version -- at its May 7 "Let Loose" event. This is the first time that two iPad Air models have been launched simultaneously, and they're both packed with big upgrades.

The new iPad Air models still feature a Liquid Retina display. However, the 12MP front-facing ultrawide camera with Center Stage has been relocated to the landscape edge, making it perfect for video calls. The camera provides high-resolution photos and detailed 4K video, with support for 240 frames-per-second (fps) in slow-motion.