Skip to main content

Apple loses its patent battle against VirnetX, faces over $300 million in damages

apple store logo
Apple’s arch nemesis for the time being is not Samsung or another smartphone maker — it’s VirnetX, a company most of us probably haven’t even heard of. It’s a firm founded by ex-employees of government contractor SAIC Inc., and is responsible for producing the technology that allows for secure communications. And according to VirnetX, that technology is being used by Apple in applications like FaceTime without proper permissions. Now a federal jury in Texas has ordered Apple to pay over $302 million worth of damages.

It’s the latest in a patent saga that first began in 2010. VirnetX first filed a lawsuit in the Eastern District of Texas federal court, and said that four of its patents for secure networks had been infringed upon. Two years later, a jury ruled in the Nevada-based company’s favor, awarding it $368.2 million. But then, an appeals court partially overturned that decision, citing problems with how the original judge told jurors to calculate damages owed.

Soon thereafter, VirnetX combined two lawsuits, and in February another jury awarded the company an impressive sum of $625.6 million — one of the largest payouts ever ordered in an American patent case. This result was also ruled null and void, which leads us to present day. And on Friday, it looks like VirnetX was given the last laugh, to the tune of $302.4 million.

Apple spokeswoman Rachel Tulley did not comment on the latest proceedings, and it looks like the news could get even worse for the Cupertino company. Further court proceedings are yet to take place, which will determine whether or not Apple “willfully infringed the patents.” If a judge rules that the company did do so, the damages could be even greater. Worse still, Apple is involved in another lawsuit with VirnetX; this one not over FaceTime, but over iMessage and some other Apple security features.

Editors' Recommendations

Lulu Chang
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Fascinated by the effects of technology on human interaction, Lulu believes that if her parents can use your new app…
Best Salesforce alternatives 2023: 7 other CRM tools worth trying
A customer relationship management diagram.

In the realm of sales management, finding the right customer relationship management software (or CRM) is crucial for streamlining your sales funnel, nurturing customer relationships, and boosting your conversion rate. While Salesforce has long been a dominant player in the CRM market, there are a number of compelling alternatives that offer comparable functionalities and features.

This roundup explores seven powerful Salesforce alternatives, analyzing their unique strengths, customizable interfaces, and integration capabilities. Whether you're a small startup, a growing medium-sized business, or an established enterprise, these CRM systems provide diverse solutions to your specific sales management needs. From advanced AI-driven lead prioritization to intuitive visual pipelines, each alternative offers its own benefits that can transform how you approach sales. Ready to level up your sales game? Let's dive in:

Read more
Squarespace Courses: Empowering the next-generation of creative entrepreneurs
Squarespace Courses will allow entrepreneurs to create online learning solutions

This content was produced in partnership with Squarespace.
It's been clear from the very start that Squarespace was building and planning something truly special. If you don't already know, you can build professional-quality and beautiful websites through the platform with a remarkably easy tool set. You don't need any knowledge of web design or programming to get started, and you can have a site up in minutes. But thanks to how convenient it all is, it's become something of a go-to platform for digital and online creation. Now, Squarespace is elevating its all-in-one platform even more, offering something new to the next generation of entrepreneurs and creatives, who want to build their brands and monetize their audience. It's called Squarespace Courses, and like its website builder, the tool will allow customers to design and sell beautiful, multimedia courses to their customers.

Course designers will be able to create expansive programs across sequential lessons, using videos, and chapters, all while also offering progress tracking. As is customary for online courses, entrepreneurs can then create an overview of each course, set the prices for admission, and then allow potential students to preview content before making a purchase. Launching August 21st, 2023 this feature is simply not available through other easy-website-building platforms -- it's exclusive to Squarespace.

Read more
Semrush Free Trial: Try the advanced online marketing tool
how to clean up your keywords and refresh seo strategy semrush logo feature image large

Marketing will make or break your new venture. A lot more goes into running a traditional or ecommerce business than just registering a new domain, making a website -- even with a Wix free trial -- and calling it a day. Potential customers must be made aware that your business exists, and for that to happen in the digital age, you need to make use of modern online marketing tools. That's a broad field, though, encompassing keyword research, search engine optimization, data analytics, and other elements that can be pretty technical (not to mention intimidating) to the uninitiated. Enter Semrush, one of the best online marketing suites that makes all that stuff easy -- but it's not free. Maybe you want to give it a try before signing up for a premium subscription? If that's the case and you are looking for a Semrush free trial, then you're in luck. Read on. We have all the details for you, below.

Is there a Semrush free trial?

Read more