Skip to main content

Google’s Waze accused of stealing data from rival traffic app

There’s possible trouble in the road ahead for Google and Waze, the traffic and navigation startup it acquired in 2013.

Competing service PhantomAlert this week filed a lawsuit in a San Francisco federal court claiming Waze stole some of its data to help improve its product prior to Google’s acquisition of the company.

Recommended Videos

PhantomAlert, which, like Waze, also offers drivers real-time data on things like traffic congestion and road construction as well as information on stoplights and red-light cameras, alleges in the suit that “Waze copied PhantomAlert’s proprietary database without permission and incorporated that misappropriated data into Waze’s popular iPhone and Android navigation apps.”

So with most road maps understandably looking pretty much the same, how did PhantomAlert arrive at the idea that Waze might be taking some of its data for its own iOS and Android apps?

Well, an old trick employed over the years by map makers keen to protect their work has been to drop in a few “trap streets” or “copyright traps,” fictitious roads or other fake data that would be hard for a rival to explain away should they get caught including it in their own map. In PhantomAlert’s case, the fake data comprised a small portion of content from its own “points of interest” database.

PhantomAlert boss Joseph Seyoum told Cnet he decided to take a closer look at Waze’s data after the $1-billion deal with Google went through. It was then that he claims to have spotted some of PhantomAlert’s fake points-of-interest data on Waze’s maps.

But here the story takes another turn. Some time after Google acquired the Israel-based company in 2013, some of those trap streets, as well as other data points from PhantomAlert’s own content, started turning up in some of Google’s own apps.

Washington, DC-based PhantomAlert has had dealings with Waze in the past. In 2010 the pair entered into discussions over a possible data-sharing deal, but talks ultimately collapsed because, according to PhantomAlert attorney Karl Kronenberger, “Waze did not have a substantial database to share at that time.”

Kronenberger said in a statement this week, “Waze needed to grow its database to increase its value and become more attractive to potential acquirers,” adding, “Our complaint alleges that Waze stole PhantomAlert’s database when Waze could not get it legally, and then sold itself to Google for over $1 billion.”

In the same statement, Seyoum makes his feelings clear: “I started PhantomAlert seven years ago as an entrepreneur with a dream, and now that dream has been crushed by companies that are profiting from the years of blood, sweat and tears our team put into our product.”

The startup is seeking monetary damages (amount unspecified) as well as an injunction to stop Waze and Google using the allegedly stolen data in their various apps.

Digital Trends has contacted Waze for comment and will update if we hear back.

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
Google urges iPhone users to switch to standalone Gemini app
Gemini app on iPhone.

Last fall, Google introduced a standalone Gemini app for iOS. At the same time, the AI assistant remained in the standalone Google app. That’s now changing. As 9to5Google first noted, Google is informing iOS users that it will remove Gemini support from the Google app. In doing so, it wants you to rely solely on the Gemini app.

In an email to iOS users, Google says: “We’re making some changes to create an even better Gemini experience on iOS. Gemini is now available as its own app, and that’s now the best place to use Gemini. To continue using Gemini, download the new Gemini app from the App Store. With the Gemini app, you’ll have access to all of the same features and more.”

Read more
Google Messages can now be your notes app. Please don’t do that
The Google Messages app on the Galaxy S25 Ultra.

Google Messages recently got an update that allows Android users to use it as a notes app as well as a regular messaging app. This update flew under the radar until Android Authority reported on it last Friday, saying that people can now send long messages, high-quality media, and other content to themselves via RCS messaging, freeing them of the restrictions imposed by its predecessor, SMS messaging. While that is a useful upgrade on paper, it's not a good idea in practice.

A lot of people use messaging apps as a substitute for the original notes app pre-installed in their phones. The problem is text messages sent through RCS are not encrypted, let alone messages sent to yourself, posing a host of security issues. Not long after Apple adopted cross-platform RCS messaging with Android late last year, a group of Chinese hackers called Salt Typhoon launched a cyberattack on U.S. communications networks, leading the FBI and CISA warning Americans to use encrypted messaging platforms, especially if messages are being sent from Apple to Android and vice versa.

Read more
Tired of downloading terrible apps? This Google Play Store update will help
A person holding an Android phone while on a bike. The display shows the Google Play Store.

The Google Play Store has an estimated 3.3 million apps available, but they most certainly are not all created equal. Some are no longer updated, some don't work the way they're meant to, and others are just plain terrible — but a new update to the Play Store could make finding the diamonds in the rough much easier.

This update is already live for some users, but it's still rolling out to others. When browsing the Play Store, warnings will appear just below the app information and provide a high-level overview of its performance. For example, it might warn that an app is frequently uninstalled, or the app might not get as much engagement compared to others, according to Android Authority.

Read more