First Drive: 2016 Honda Pilot Elite

Like Liz Lemon, Honda’s 2016 Pilot comes close to ‘having it all’

Honda’s 2016 Pilot might not be able to drive itself, but, inside its comfortable cabin, tech-savvy families will feel like they can ‘have it all.’

The 2016 Honda Pilot is a bit like Liz Lemon (Tina Fey) from the famed NBC sitcom 30 Rock. Along with running her show within a show and wrangling the wild characters that orbited her, Liz was constantly striving to “have it all.” She wanted a successful career, fulfilling love life, and, eventually, kids. Most of these things, however, were hilariously out of her reach – for most of the show, anyway.

Now, don’t get me wrong; comparing the Pilot to miss Lemon is a good thing. The Pilot, like Liz, is tough, capable, and undeniably lovable and – not to mention that both sport rather child-friendly shapes, an observation oft made of Liz by characters on the show. While neither the Pilot nor Liz is foible free, both will quickly steal your heart.

Styling and seating

For 2016, Honda has smoothed out all the lines of the Pilot and made the crossover longer and lower, turning what was once a boxy truck fit for a family of reliability-obsessed ruffians into a friendly, accessible, and tech-savvy living room on wheels. I think it looks like a CR-V in the front, a Mercedes-Benz GL-Class in side profile, and an Acura MDX from the rear – with all the distinctive design lines from all three ironed into nonexistence.

Though still a bit bland, the exterior is a far sight better looking than the outgoing Pilot, which, if slathered in red paint, could have been mistaken for a barn.

Thankfully, on a car like this, exteriors don’t so much matter; it’s the interior that sells. Accordingly, it’s on the inside where the Pilot truly shines. In the cabin of the all-new Pilot, families will be greeted with eight seats (only seven on the top Elite trim) that are exceedingly easy to access thanks to a 1.2-inch lower ingress and an automatic folding second-row, which leans and slides forward with the push of a single illuminated button.

If you’re seated up front, you’ll find optional heated and cooled seats, a moon roof, 8.0-inch touchscreen powered by an Android OS, a simply capacious center storage cubby with a sliding lid strong enough to hold a bag, several cup holders, no fewer than two smartphone trays, and a slick push-button shifter for the transmission. In the back, the kids will be treated to an optional ‘panoramic’ moonroof that can open independently of the front moonroof (you’re welcome, parents) and a roof-mounted flip-down entertainment screen. Honda was keen to keep both the entertainment screen mounted to the ceiling and retain a second moonroof … because today’s kids simply have to have it all.

The Pilot is tough, capable, and undeniably lovable.

Occupants will also find five USB ports strewn throughout the cabin, four of which have been wired with a 2.5-amp charging capacity. So, pretty much wherever you are in the new Pilot, you won’t be far from a charging port for one of your gadgets.

In the way back, even with the third row of seats up, Honda has found more space than some large, five-seater crossovers. The rear stowage area even includes a reversible cargo lid with a rubberized finish on one side and a carpet cover on the other. The lid can either cover the extra trunk-like cargo area, lock into a mid-point for extra above carrying space, or be removed altogether, which extends the rear area vertical carrying capacity significantly. I only dwell on this little addition because I find it exceedingly cool and something I wish every car offered.

Power and efficiency

Under the new, round-y hood, Honda mounted a direct-injected 3.5-liter V6, which produces 280 horsepower and 262 pound-feet of torque. Depending on trim level, the engine is mated one of two automatic transmissions: six- or nine-speed. Buyers can also specify any trim from LX to Elite with front- or all-wheel drive (AWD).

2016 Honda Pilot Elite

Nick Jaynes/Digital Trends

While this powertrain is fairly plebian by full-size crossover standards, the Honda has a trick up its sleeve. Unlike its competitors, the AWD Pilot is fitted with an Intelligent Variable Torque Management AWD system, which Honda boasts is the most technologically advanced AWD system offered in a mainstream, three-row SUV. In addition to the torque-vectoring rear differential, Honda has developed the Intelligent Traction Management system, allowing drivers to choose what kind of surface they’re driving on, including Normal, Snow, and Mud and Snow, further improving inclimate weather capability.

Even with seating for eight and a techy AWD system on board, Honda anticipates the EPA to rate the 2016 Pilot to achieve between 18 and 20 mpg in the city and 26 and 27 mpg on the highway (depending on trim and powertrain) on regular octane gasoline, which is pretty darn good, considering its size.

As for driving dynamics, not that those much matter in this segment, I’d have to say the Pilot’s handling was good — if not a bit boat-y in the bends — and its steering quite relaxed … in a good way. Beyond that, like the SUV of the Year-nominated CR-V, the driving experience is pretty darn forgettable. Admittedly, this is great for most of the buyers attracted to the Pilot. They have enough to remember; how their car handled shouldn’t be one of them.

As a whole, the Pilot seems like a knockout. And it is … but just like our beloved Liz Lemon, it’s not perfect.


During my day of testing the new Pilot, a few weaknesses showed through its list of achievements. In downtown Cincinnati, for example, the Garmin-powered navigation couldn’t find the car among the buildings and showed us driving through buildings – in 3D. Honda chalked this up to the Pilot having been parked underground over night. To which Liz Lemon would say, “Nope, that’s not a thing.”

Then, on the open road, I found much of the same Lane Keeping Assist System (LKAS) issues that plagued Peter Braun in his recent excursion in the new CR-V. The solution to these, I wager, is to only activate LKAS while using adaptive cruise control … or simply not at all.


Really, while I found those issues aggravating, in the grand scheme of things, knocking a car for its imperfect piloted driving technology is like dismissing a TV show because its witty writing is a bit too cerebral (like 30 Rock); it’s actually more of a compliment than a criticism.

It was clear to me that, when creating the new Pilot, the Honda engineers did truly want buyers to have it all. And they’ve succeeded.

The 2016 Pilot Elite parallels the capability of the Honda’s minivan, the Odyssey, without losing any of the utilitarian charm that attracted buyers to the first two Pilots. It might not navigate you through a city so well … or drive itself … but it is a reliable, extremely capable family runabout that truly makes us “want to go to there.”


  • Sleek – not boxy — styling
  • Storage you could get lost in
  • USBs galore
  • Real torque-vectoring AWD
  • Comfortable as the day is long


  • Imperfect piloted driving tech
  • No volume knob on infotainment unit
  • Forgettable driving experience

Six advanced tech features that make off-road driving easy

It wasn’t too long ago that driving off-road required serious skills and a lot of equipment. Thanks to technology, any family crossover SUV can hit the trail today and have a good chance of coming back in one piece.
Product Review

Mercedes-Benz fires its first salvo in the luxury electrification war

The EQC is Mercedes-Benz's answer to the Tesla threat, bringing performance, tech features, and luxury to the growing electric SUV segment. We headed to Norway, the electric car capital of the world, to get a taste of it.

The recently revealed McLaren GT is a road trip-ready supercar

This is the first-ever McLaren built exclusively for the road and not the racetrack.

Mini’s most powerful models to date will make you want to take the long way home

While the original Mini wasn't born to race, it didn't take long for pilots to uncover its potential. The firm is channeling its performance heritage into performance-oriented variants of the Clubman and the Countryman.

The 2020 Hyundai Elantra keeps an eye on the road even if you’re not looking

Hyundai has again updated the Elantra, one of its most popular and most affordable models. For the 2020 model year, the Elantra receives standard driving aids like lane-keeping assist and forward collision warning.
Product Review

The 2019 Ford Mustang GT 350 finally has the grip to (almost) tame its V8

Four years after its debut, the standard GT350 finally gets the suspension and tire package it always needed. While evolutionary rather than revolutionary, Ford’s update takes the Shelby’s track prowess and fun factor to a new level.

Lamborghini’s ST-X will likely spawn a super-Urus with the soul of a race car

Lamborghini is taking the Urus racing in 2020. The racing version will be lighter than the production model it's based on, and we expect it will be a good deal quicker. It is also trickling into a performance version of the Urus.

Volvo’s new app walks you through what to do after an accident

Volvo's Accident Advisor sends information on what to do after an accident directly to a driver's smartphone. Drivers can also use it to notify their insurance companies and find a repair shop.

Aston Martin will revive James Bond’s DB5 at a price only Goldfinger can afford

Aston Martin will build 25 new versions of the DB5 from the 1964 James Bond film Goldfinger, complete with gadgets. These "continuation cars" will cost millions of dollars, but won't be road legal.

Hyundai wants to make sure you’re seeing the outside world, not inhaling it

Hyundai is developing an intelligent air purification system for its cars that continuously monitors the quality of the air inside the cabin, and cleans it when it detects the presence of harmful particulates.

Nissan claims its upgraded ProPilot system enables hands-off highway driving

Nissan is launching a new version of its ProPilot Assist system that's much smarter than the current version. It can handle acceleration, braking, and steering on highways, while using a camera to ensure the driver doesn't fall asleep.

2020 GMC Sierra sees a bunch of updates, including adaptive cruise

GMC announced updates to its 2020 GMC Sierra pickup truck, including much-needed adaptive cruise control, a 3.0-liter turbo-diesel engine option, improved towing cameras, and expanded availability of the 10-speed automatic transmission.
Home Theater

Why you can’t buy Car Thing, Spotify’s first hardware device

Spotify created a voice-activated, in-car device that lets you listen to music and podcasts. But Car Thing, as it is known, is not for sale. Instead, it will be used to gather data from a limited set of customers.

Car designers can predict your future desires. This is how they do it

Automakers employ small armies of designers, and they’re relentless about asking consumers what they want. So, how do you get from the voice of the customer to the designer’s pen, and why does it go wrong so often?