Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

Are EVs safe? From battery fires to autopilot, here are the facts

While many people will be primarily concerned with EV range before buying their first electric vehicle, others are a little nervous about having a giant lithium-ion battery strapped to their car’s undercarriage. Those things can catch fire — just ask Chevy Bolt owners. But how much of a real danger is that? And should it prevent you from buying an EV?

What safety features do EV batteries have?

The major safety issue with lithium-ion batteries is their temperature. If they get too hot, they’re prone to igniting. If they get too cold, they freeze and permanently stop working. Charge and discharge rates need to be carefully regulated too, or you’ll get electrical fires. Over time, small imperfections in a battery’s structure can lead to short circuits and reduced lifetime.

Electric GT e-Crate Motor Tesla battery
Image used with permission by copyright holder

EVs have what are called battery management systems (BMS) to keep tabs on all of these variables. The BMS will generate warnings when needed and intervene directly by cutting off power if things get out of hand. EV battery packs also have thermal management systems. Typically, this is a closed loop of liquid coolant flowing alongside the battery cells, but air cooling and welding battery cells directly to the car chassis are also means of mitigating extreme heat.

How well do EVs handle a crash?

Since there’s no engine at the front of an EV, the hood typically houses a frunk — meaning a front trunk. This acts as a large crumple zone in the case of a head-on accident. One crash in Germany avoided casualties thanks to this inherent characteristic of electric vehicles. Crash tests bear this out. Popular EVs like the Tesla Model 3, Hyundai Ioniq 5, and Nissan Leaf have all received overall five-star ratings from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).

Tesla

Though you might worry about the risk of fire from the batteries, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety has crashed 55 different models of EVs and has yet to encounter a fire. But they do happen infrequently, like when a speeding Tesla Model S crashed in 2019.

As with any car, you need to take precautions with an electric vehicle. Luckily, the technology in them is advanced enough to be able to mitigate more risks than ever. An incredible amount of intelligence is tucked inside that is able to keep tabs on what’s happening in your battery and around you on the road to ensure a safe ride. Over time, those safeguards are only going to get better.

Is autopilot driving safe?

Not all electric vehicles have autopilot, and truly autonomous driving is a ways off, but EVs tend to have more intelligent driving features built-in than your average car. Sensors for proximity detection are a welcome safety feature, and rearview cameras have become a mainstay in all cars, not just EVs. Things get a little trickier when it comes to advanced features like lane assist and Tesla Autopilot.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

A recent German study found that cars capable of passing, merging, and swerving on their own increase safety by 18%. Vehicles on highway autopilot are 5% safer. A 2018 literature review by AAA is even more optimistic, suggesting 40% of passenger vehicle crashes could be avoided with advanced driver assistance systems. Tesla publishes its own data quarterly, and has indicated that per mile driven, autopilot drivers crash nearly 10 times less than the national average.

The NHTAS is now publishing monthly data on crashes involving advanced driving assistance technology. This is fairly new, so the data is fuzzy. For now, all we see from this reporting is that the cars had features like autopilot equipped, not that they were necessarily active at the time of the crash. Still, of all the 130 crashes tabulated between July 2021 and May 2022, only 16 reported any injuries, one that was serious.

Despite all of that, U.S. legislators aren’t entirely sold. Sens. Edward Markey (D-MA) and Richard Blumenthal (D-CT) have issued a joint statement that applauds the NHTSA’s investigations while casting serious doubt on the safety of driving with autopilot:

“NHTSA’s findings will be essential to improving the safety of automated driving and advanced driver assistance systems for the sake of public safety. Every day that Tesla disregards safety rules and misleads the public about its Autopilot system, our roads become more dangerous.”

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Simon Sage
Simon has been publishing in tech since before the first iPhone was released. When he's not busy lighting a candle for the…
Ford EV drivers can use 12,000 Tesla Superchargers starting in 2024
A Tesla Supercharger.

Drivers of Ford’s electric vehicles (EVs) will find charging them a little easier starting next spring after Tesla on Thursday promised the availability of 12,000 of its Superchargers across the U.S. and Canada.

The move will double the number of fast-chargers currently available to Ford’s EV owners.

Read more
The Sony Honda Afeela car is peak CES, and I’m totally here for it
Yasuhide Mizuno, representative director, chairman and CEO of Sony Honda Mobility Inc., introduces the Afeela EV.

Everyone knew what was coming. Sitting a half-dozen rows back at the Sony press conference the afternoon before the CES show floor actually opened, you could tell by the layout of the booth — drastically different from what Sony had in previous years — that something big was going to be wheeled out.

That something, of course, was a car. It wasn't a big secret. Folks were talking about it on the bus ride to the Las Vegas Convention Center from the Mandalay Bay Convention Center, where a good chunk of the work happens before the CES doors are open. Folks were talking about it — in all sorts of languages — in the long line down the hallway that separates two of the bigger halls at the LVCC. English. Japanese. Spanish. So many others. And you didn't have to actually know what they were saying to know what they were talking about.

Read more
What’s the environmental impact of EV battery manufacturing and recycling?
EV battery

One major caveat to the spread of electric vehicles is the question of what we're going to do with all of these car batteries once their time is up. There's also concern about the environmental impact of lithium mining, not to mention that of other essential metals, like cobalt and nickel. Let's take some time to look at what goes into EV batteries, where they go when they're dead, and whether EVs are in the end still the best choice for the environment.
Are EV batteries recyclable?
EV batteries are highly recyclable. Over 95% of a lithium-ion battery's components can be extracted via hydrometallurgy. This involves grinding up battery components and running them through an acidic solution. A series of solvents and rounds of electroplating are able to pull individual elements out of the solution. Smelting recovery is common but more energy-intensive and less effective. The pollution caused by this recycling process is negligible. The problem right now is that we don't have enough recycling facilities currently running at the scale needed to meet the deluge of EV batteries coming off their end of life. We're currently only recycling about 5% of our lithium-ion batteries, but luckily the growing value of lithium, cobalt, and nickel makes the prospect of recovering it much more attractive.

Making the recycling process profitable can be challenging, depending on the materials you're targeting, but this study runs down the economics pretty well.
"Most process routes achieve high yields for the valuable metals cobalt, copper, and nickel. In comparison, lithium is only recovered in few processes and with a lower yield, albeit a high economic value. The recovery of the low value components graphite, manganese, and electrolyte solvents is technically feasible but economically challenging."
What's the environmental impact of lithium mining?

Read more