So you want to buy a hybrid, but which one? Breaking down the types of hybrid cars

types of hybrid cars

It’s rare for a compromise to generate broad appeal. The idea of combining two complete propulsion systems in one car sounds complicated, but since the first Toyota Prius and Honda Insight launched in the late 1990s, hybrids have proven to be the perfect solution for millions of buyers looking for better fuel economy, lower emissions, and everyday practicality.

However, not all hybrids are created equal. Different manufacturers use different combinations of internal combustion engines, batteries, and electric motors to build their hybrids. Like every other type of car, the term “hybrid” is more of a jumping off point for variation than a strict definition.

The basics

The one thing all hybrids have in common is that, as their name denotes, they combine two types of propulsion. In every production hybrid, that means an internal combustion engine like the ones found in the majority of cars, and one or more electric motors powered by onboard batteries.

There are obviously many different types of internal combustion engines, and that variety is reflected in hybrids. Displacement and cylinder count varies from the Honda Insight’s 1.3-liter inline four to the Lexus LS 600h L’s 5.0-liter V8.

2013 BMW ActiveHybrid 3 driver's side view

One thing you can expect from every hybrid is that it will be powered by gasoline. Peugeot makes diesel hybrids, but other manufacturers have shied away from this due to the added cost of diesels and the fact that they don’t jibe as well with the flat torque curve of an electric motor.

Batteries are more homogeneous  Most hybrids use lithium-ion batteries because they deliver the most storage capacity for their size. The only outlier is Toyota, which still uses nickel metal-hydride batteries. While these batteries are inherently less efficient, Toyota continues to make them work in its hybrids.

Mild to wild

What really sets each hybrid apart, though, is how it uses its gasoline engine and electric motor. Some cars use their engine as a generator and their motor as the prime mover, while others rely mostly on conventional power, leaving the electricity for an occasional boost of power or emission-free running.

Very basic hybrids, called “mild hybrids,” can only do the latter. Cars like the Chevrolet Malibu Eco use their batteries and electric motor to assist the gasoline engine, with no provision for running on electric power only. In fact, General Motors calls the Malibu Eco an example of “light electrification of a traditional powertrain,” not a hybrid. The result is a car that is slightly cheaper ($25,995) than other comparable hybrids, but with less spectacular fuel economy (26 mpg city, 38 mpg highway).

The next step up from a mild hybrid is something along the lines of Honda’s Integrated Motor Assist (IMA), which sandwiches an electric motor between the engine’s flywheel and the transmission. This gives cars like the Insight the ability to drive on electricity alone.

Honda Insight

According to the EPA, the Insight is good for 41 mpg city and 44 mpg highway. However, it’s doppelganger, the Toyota Prius, achieves 51 city and 48 highway mpg.

That’s mostly due to the fact that Toyota’s Hybrid Synergy Drive gives the electric motor its own way to power the wheels, which is more efficient. Since the Prius can spend more time running on electricity, it can take better advantage of low-speed city driving. That explains the Toyota’s higher city mpg number.

Getting a hybrid to spend most of its time running on electricity is the key to more miles per gallon, and sometimes that means spending more money gets less. The 2013 Ford Fusion hybrid is rated at 47 mpg in all three EPA categories, while the BMW ActiveHybrid 3 is rated at a (provisional) 25 mpg city, 33 mpg highway, and 28 mpg combined.

Why are BMW buyers spending more money ($49,300 versus $27,200) for fewer mpg? BMW had different priorities: the ActiveHybrid is the most powerful non-M 3 Series available; its electric motor is more of a power booster than an alternative power source. The ActiveHybrid 3 can only drive up to 37 mph on electric power, while the Fusion can reach 62 mph.

Plugging in

Plug-in hybrids bridge the gap between the Insights and Priuses of the world and fully-electric cars like the Nissan Leaf. Adding the ability to charge the car’s battery pack from an external socket means the engine doesn’t always have to be used as a generator.

This is where the EPA’s MPGe ratings come in. A Toyota Prius plug-in nets roughly the same mpg (51 city, 49 highway) as a regular Prius, but that doesn’t include the time the car spends on electricity. A Prius plug-in is rated at 95 MPGe, meaning the EPA thinks it can achieve the equivalent of 95 mpg by leaving its gasoline engine turned off much of the time.

2012 Chevy Volt

Things aren’t quite that simple, though. Some plug-ins, including the Prius and Ford C-Max Energi, are basically “regular” hybrids with plug-in capability added on. The Chevrolet Volt (the first of the breed, and still known as GM’s “moon shot”) only couples its gasoline engine to its wheels in very specific circumstances. The Fisker Karma’s engine is not physically connected to its wheels at all, making it a true generator.

Which is best? The Karma (54 MPGe) is a bit of an outlier, since it’s a big, performance-oriented luxury car, while the others are sensible hatchbacks. Among those hatchbacks, it’s nearly a dead heat: 95 MPGe for the Prius, 98 MPGe for the 2013 Volt, and 100 MPGe for the 2013 Ford C-Max Energi.

For now, a plug-in is a plug-in when it comes to MPGe, whether the gasoline engine stays coupled to the wheels or not. These cars do command a premium over other hybrids, but they provide maximum mileage without the range anxiety of fully electric vehicles. That puts them at the top of the hybrid pyramid.

Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: 1-handed drone control, a pot that stirs itself

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!

Where are you going this weekend? These 5 off-road vehicles say 'anywhere'

The body-on-frame SUV is going extinct, but there are still several options for buyers looking to skip the asphalt. To help you sort the good from the bad, we've rounded up the best off-roaders currently available.

How do Nintendo Switch, Xbox One X compare to each other? We find out

The Nintendo Switch is innovative enough to stand apart from traditional consoles, but could it become your primary gaming system? How does the Switch stack up against the Xbox One?

Thinking of driving for Uber? These cars are safe, comfy, and fuel-efficient

Uber is a viable means for making money on the side, but you won't earn much if all of your profits are going direct toward fuel and maintenance. Thankfully, these five cars are a perfect fit for those looking to shuttle passengers from…

Honda HR-V vs. Honda CR-V: The differences explained

The Honda HR-V and CR-V may overlap in some regard, but they're not the same vehicle. In this comparison, we highlight the design, technology, performance, and fuel economy unique to each ride.

Roborace wants human drivers and machines to work together

Roborace believes the future of racing is autonomous, but it's keeping human drivers in the picture for now. For its first race season, Roborace will use a car called DevBot 2.0 that can be driven by humans or machines.

Tesla raises prices and simplifies options on Model S and Model X

Tesla is making changes to its offerings of the Model S and Model X. The lower-range 75D models will increase in price, while the higher-range 100D models will decrease in price.

Tesla brings track mode to Model 3 Performance

The new Track Mode introduced for the Tesla 3 Performance model adds stability to the drive while you're behind the wheel and is specifically designed for driving on closed track courses.

Jaguar’s rally-ready F-Type roadster is happiest off the pavement

Jaguar is celebrating the XK120's 70th birthday by turning the F-Type roadster into a rally warrior. Built to FIA specifications, the model receives suspension and braking upgrades plus a full roll cage to protect the occupants.

Lyft’s new rewards program promises ride discounts and comfier cars

If you're always hopping in and out of a Lyft car, then you'll be pleased to hear that the ridesharing service is about to launch a rewards program. Perks include discounts on future trips and upgrades to comfier cars.

Study suggests autonomous cars could become red-light districts on wheels

Fully autonomous cars can change the way we commute, but they can also have a far-reaching impact on the tourism industry. Two researchers published a study that outlines how self-driving technology could create a new dimension in tourism.

VW will use Siri as the designated driver for its connected car party

Volkswagen of America added Apple's Siri to help drivers control and interact with their cars. Owners can customize voice commands to tell Siri to change access settings such as interior climate, vehicle lock status, and fuel checks.

Meet the born-again Ford Bronco that will soothe your ’90s nostalgia

Ford has confirmed it will bring the Bronco back to American showrooms in a few short years. While it's still very much a work in progress, this is what we expect from the Blue Oval's born-again off-roader.

Waymo will launch its commercial autonomous ridesharing service in December

Waymo will launch a commercial ridesharing service using self-driving cars in December, according to a new report. As previously discussed by Waymo, the service will operate in specific areas around Phoenix, Arizona.