IIHS tests advanced driver-assist tech, gets mixed results

2017 Volvo S90 T6Advanced driver-assist systems like Tesla’s Autopilot and Volvo’s Pilot Assist are often touted as the cutting edge of safety tech, and possibly a stepping stone to self-driving cars. But in a recent test of these systems, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) found their real-world performance to be lacking.

“Evaluations of adaptive cruise control and active lane-keeping show variable performance in typical driving situations, such as approaching stopped vehicles and negotiating hills and curves,” an IIHS statement said. “The early results underscore the fact that today’s systems aren’t robust substitutes for human drivers.”

Adaptive cruise control can automatically vary speed based on the car in front, slowing down when the lead car slows and accelerating when appropriate. What the IIHS refers to as active lane-keeping systems allow the car to steer itself to a certain degree in order to stay centered in a lane. The ability of these systems to manipulate steering, acceleration, and parking, has led some media reports to describe them as enabling fully autonomous driving, but that is not the case. These systems still require an attentive human driver.

For its test, the IIHS selected a 2017 BMW 5 Series equipped with Driving Assistant Plus, a 2017 Mercedes-Benz E-Class with Drive Pilot, a Tesla Model 3 and Tesla Model S equipped with Autopilot (software versions 8.1 and 7.1, respectively), and a 2018 Volvo S90 with Pilot Assist. All five cars also had autonomous emergency braking systems that received the IIHS’ top rating of “Superior.”

Testers evaluated the cars on a closed course and on public roads. While the adaptive cruise control systems performed fairly well under controlled conditions, performance can vary in the real world, the IIHS said. On the test track, the BMW, Mercedes, and Teslas braked to avoid a completely stopped target vehicle, even though some vehicles’ owners’ manuals specifically said adaptive cruise control may not recognize a vehicle that has already stopped. Sure enough, on a real-world road, IIHS senior research engineer Jessica Jermakian found that the E-Class did not identify a pickup truck stopped at a red light. She had to apply the brakes manually.

“At IIHS we are coached to intervene without warning, but other drivers might not be as vigilant,” Jermakian said in a statement. “ACC [adaptive cruise control] systems require drivers to pay attention to what the vehicle is doing at all times and be ready to brake manually.”

Testers also noted “unnecessary or overly cautious braking” to be an issue with the Model 3. Over 180 miles, the car unexpectedly braked 12 times, according to the IIHS. Seven of those instances were for tree shadows, the rest for oncoming vehicles in another lane, or vehicles crossing the road far ahead. Jermakian said this quirk “didn’t create unsafe conditions” because the car didn’t brake very hard, but noted that erratic braking may cause owners to lose confidence in Autopilot.

But the Model 3 was also the only car to stay centered in its lane in every active lane-keeping test for curves. The Model S overcorrected on one curve, causing it to cross the inside line in one turn.  The E-Class and S90 both stayed within the lane in nine of 17 runs, while the 5 Series could only keep itself in a lane in three of 16 runs.

The IIHS also tested active lane-keeping on hills. Testers noted that the systems were “sometimes flummoxed” by hills because they obscure lane markings. The Model 3 once again had the best score, staying in its lane in all but one trial, where it “hugged the line.” In contrast, the 5 Series failed to stay in its lane in all 14 runs. Testers also noted that the Model S had a propensity to swerve while cresting a hill, as it apparently lost track of lane markings. The car “rarely” warned drivers to take over in these situations, the IIHS said. It shows that drivers have to remain vigilant.

“We’re not ready to say yet which company has the safest implementation … but it’s important to note that none of these vehicles is capable of driving safely on its own,” IIHS chief research officer David Zuby said in a statement. “A production autonomous vehicle that can go anywhere, anytime isn’t available at your local car dealer and won’t be for quite some time. We aren’t there yet.”

Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Insect drones and kinetic sculpture robots

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it's fun to gawk!
Product Review

Want an electric car that doesn't look like an electric car? Meet Audi's E-Tron

The 2019 Audi E-Tron is the German automaker’s first series-production electric car. Rather than make a bold statement with its first electric vehicle, Audi chose to make the E-Tron as much like its other cars as possible.
Cars

GM thinks up new electronic brain for its cars, allowing over-the-air updates

General Motors is launching a new electrical architecture to support more tech features in its cars. The system debuts on the 2020 Cadillac CT5, and will roll out to most other GM models by 2023.
Product Review

Mercedes-Benz fires its first salvo in the luxury electrification war

The EQC is Mercedes-Benz's answer to the Tesla threat, bringing performance, tech features, and luxury to the growing electric SUV segment. We headed to Norway, the electric car capital of the world, to get a taste of it.
Cars

Nissan claims its upgraded ProPilot system enables hands-off highway driving

Nissan is launching a new version of its ProPilot Assist system that's much smarter than the current version. It can handle acceleration, braking, and steering on highways, while using a camera to ensure the driver doesn't fall asleep.
Cars

Semi-autonomous and always available: A peek into the near future of car rental

Soon we will see connected rental fleets with a dedicated lane at airports for self-driving cars, where drivers control the car to the airport, and then the empty car drives itself to the rental lot.
Cars

Walmart slashes prices on electric hybrid bicycles for National Bike Month

Electric bikes can be economical, convenient, and fun. Heading into summer, Walmart slashed the prices for two pedal-assist Hyper E-ride Mountain and City Electric Hybrid Bikes by 40%. We found a variety of e-rides for under $1,000.
Cars

Ford aluminum truck beds prove haters wrong, are cheaper to repair than steel

Repair costs were a major concern for truck buyers when Ford launched its aluminum F-150. But insurance data indicates that, if anything, the F-150 may be cheaper to repair than traditional steel trucks.
Cars

Mercedes-Benz safety-car concept monitors the road ahead and your kids

The Mercedes-Benz Experimental Safety Vehicle 2019 was designed for a world where humans and machines share driving duties. It can use lights to communicate with other road users and even monitor an infant's vital signs.
Cars

GM hits reverse with Maven carsharing as it closes service in eight cities

GM-owned Maven will close its carsharing service in 8 of the 17 North American cities where it currently operates. Competing with the likes of Zipcar and Car2Go, the app-based service offers car rental by the hour or day.
Cars

Crisp and connected, the Volkswagen Golf will get a digital reboot in 2020

Volkswagen is putting the final touches on the eighth-generation Golf. The hatchback will still be recognizable as a member of the Golf family, but it will receive a crisper design inside and out.
Cars

With Tesla bleeding money, Elon Musk initiates hardcore spending review

After posting a sizable $700 million loss in the first quarter of 2019, Tesla announced it will review every expense, no matter the size, to keep spending in check. Company CEO Elon Musk will personally approve every 10th expense page.
Cars

Bosch sensors used in Skywalker’s lightsaber will keep flying taxis in the air

Bosch wants to help companies make flying taxis a reality. Aviation technology is too big and too expensive to power a flying taxi, so the German firm is developing a universal control unit using smaller, cheaper sensors already used in…
Cars

Seat belts will be required in Chevrolet’s new Teen Driver Mode

Seat belts are a simple technology, yet teens are terrible at wearing them. To curb this tendency, Chevy has announced a new safety feature for its Teen Driver Mode that prevents the car from leaving Park if seat belts are not engaged.