Skip to main content

Modern cars take touch controls too far. This company found a balance

Cars are rapidly evolving, and it seems like just about everything about them is going digital. Of course, for the most part, that’s a good thing. It allows for more remote control over your car, a cleaner look to your car’s dashboard, and more.

Unfortunately, it also seems like car companies are going a little … too far. It’s one thing for things like audio playback controls, mood lighting controls, and others to be pushed into a screen. But for some reason, it feels like another thing entirely for climate controls, for example, to be controlled exclusively digitally.

But digital controls can be done well — and recently driving the Lucid Air proved that to me.

Car companies are software companies?

There’s one simple explanation for why digital controls in cars can be, and often are, bad. They’re unsafe. When you’re supposed to be watching the road, it’s simply dangerous to be hunting around an interface just because you’re a little cold.

Infotainment panel in a 2021 Ford Mustang Mach E
Stephen Edelstein/Digital Trends

The simple truth is that car companies want your attention on their interface — not CarPlay or Android Auto. Sure, they include those interfaces because customers demand them, but there’s a war going on in that screen of yours. If car companies can convince you to stick within their interfaces, they could eventually convince you to subscribe to more features, pay for things in their software, and so on.

The result of all this? Car companies are software companies now. Well, they’re aspiring software companies. Car companies have been building software for years, but for the most part, it’s been inconsequential — bad software with few ramifications. The likes of Apple and Google, however, have been forced to develop easy-to-use software for the better part of two decades now. And companies like Tesla and Lucid have benefitted from their work, not only poaching many of the employees that refined those software systems but taking the lessons learned too.

For the most part, traditional car companies are starting to clue into this, but they clearly have a long way to go. Most of the major automakers have placed a heavy emphasis on their software over the past few years, but even the big ones, like Ford, still struggle. I don’t mind the overall interface on the Mach-E, for example, but it’s dogged by sub-par processing power which means it takes precious seconds for button presses to actually do anything, and in a fast-paced situation like driving, those precious seconds can be very important.

It can be done well, but rarely is

All of this takes me to the Lucid Air experience, which should serve as an example to the rest. In the Lucid Air, it’s actually very easy to tweak climate controls straight from the software. There’s a whole tab dedicated to climate controls, and to even navigate to that tab you’ll get a giant button that I actually got used to tapping without seeing within a week of driving the car (our car review loans are usually a week). From that tab you can turn up and down both temperature and fan speed with ease.

A close up of manual and touch controls on a Lucid Air infotainment panel.
Christian de Looper / Digital Trends

But Lucid has another trick up its sleeve. Despite being one of those fancy tech-heavy new car companies, Lucid has enough awareness to know that physical controls are important. Both the driver and the passenger have their own physical fan speed and temperature controls that are tactile and easy to use with no more than a split-second glance.

It’s not as if Lucid actually needed to do this. As mentioned, its software controls actually aren’t bad. And even if they weren’t the best, car companies have started adopting better tactile feedback, as smartphone manufacturers have been doing for years, ensuring that drivers know that their pressing a button without having to actually look at the screen.

Safety is key

The Lucid Air proves that there really can be a good balance between physical and digital controls, and other companies should take note.

The infotainment panel of a Lucid Air.
Christian de Looper / Digital Trends

Here are the rules, explicitly laid out. Settings that you would control every time you drive, like audio playback and climate settings, should be immediately accessible from whatever screen you’re on in the software interface. If there are controls of this kind that don’t have corresponding physical controls, feedback of some kind should be included (whether it’s haptic or audio), so that drivers know they’re pressing buttons when they tap the screen.

And, it goes without saying that button presses should be instantaneous. Your car should have enough processing power to handle the software both as it is from the factory, and as it will be years from now. Otherwise, you shouldn’t claim that your car will offer OTA updates, and yes, that means you’ll lag behind the competition.

This is really the bare minimum. Car companies that want to pretend to be software companies should at least prioritize safety — and that means ensuring that drivers don’t have to stare at a screen to avoid being freezing cold in the middle of winter. After all, any time spent not watching the road puts drivers at risk. Until car companies can build fully self-driving cars (not faking full self-driving like Tesla), they should do better.

Christian de Looper
Christian’s interest in technology began as a child in Australia, when he stumbled upon a computer at a garage sale that he…
Don’t get stranded: The best portable tire inflators in 2024
The DeWalt 20V Max portable tire inflator at a construction site.

There’s nothing worse than getting stranded on the side of the road because of a bad tire. That’s why it pays to drive around with a portable tire inflator hanging out somewhere in your car or truck. These devices aren’t very big, and you probably won’t even use it that much. That being said, when your tire-pressure sensor lights kicks on, you’ll be happy you have it.

Here are five of the best portable tire inflators you can toss in your trunk for 2024.

Read more
The 5 best front and rear dash cams for cars in 2024
The Onn. Dual Dash Cam, installed in a vehicle.

Owning a dash cam is like owning a second or third set of eyes for the road. While these devices can be a bit expensive, they’re worth their weight in gold. Not only will a dash cam provide critical footage of any accidents that may occur, but they’re also great deterrents for would-be malcontents who may want to break into your car.

Like most automotive tech, there’s no shortage of front and rear dash cams to choose from. But when there’s a lot of one thing, shopping can become quite the challenge. That’s why we’ve put together this roundup of our five favorite models.

Read more
Mercedes-Benz G580 vs Rivian R1S: rugged electric SUVs, compared
Range of Mercedes-Benz G580 vehicles

Mercedes-Benz has finally unveiled the long-rumored and heavily teased electric G-Wagon. The new vehicle, officiallydubbed the "G580 with EQ Technology," retains the beloved design of the G-Wagon, but with an interior refresh and, more importantly, an all-electric powertrain. But the vehicle goes up against tough competition -- especially in the rugged electric SUV space. Perhaps the most-loved electric SUV so far is the Rivian R1S, a three-row SUV from a new startup that, for many, is the go-to option above a certain price range.

Now, of course, there are some big differences between the two vehicles. But is one better than the other? Here's a look at the Mercedes-Benz G580 and the Rivian R1S, head-to-head.
The designs of these two vehicles is radically different, but they do have some similarities. They're both boxy and square, and are high enough off the ground to allow for some off-roading.

Read more