Skip to main content

NYC just dealt a major blow to Uber and Lyft

New York City regulators just placed a cap on how many operational licenses it grants potential Uber and Lyft drivers in an effort to save the city’s Yellow Cab system — the latest in an ugly clash with regulators in several metropolitan areas across the country.

Taxicab liveries and Uber and Lyft are at odds because Ride-hailing apps have long threatened the taxicab companies by stealing their business. It’s resulted in controversy and even physical altercations as drivers fight for their share of fares.

The threat has many worried after some taxicab drivers even committed suicide for the financial burden from the onslaught of overwhelming competition from Uber and Lyft.

To keep the playing field level in such a highly competitive market for individual cabs and drivers, the New York City Council voted to cap the number of licenses available for ridesharing services for one year.

It’s the first major blow to the ridesharing companies that have ultimately relied on the largest U.S. metropolitan city as a main source of business. New York is also the first major U.S. city to place such a cap.

Worawee Meepian

“The city’s 12-month pause on new vehicle licenses will threaten one of the few reliable transportation options while doing nothing to fix the subways or ease congestion,” Uber said in a statement.

“These sweeping cuts to transportation will bring New Yorkers back to an era of struggling to get a ride, particularly for communities of color and in the outer boroughs,” Lyft said in its statement.

The policy wasn’t met without controversy, obviously from the ridesharing companies. But the city continued to support its decision, saying it will not only help the dwindling taxicab industry, it will also aid in reducing traffic congestion and could potentially hike driver paychecks on both sides from a possible hike in fees for riders. In July, Uber sent an email to its 5 million subscribers in New York to notify them that riders could face rate hikes, longer wait times, and increased difficulty searching for service to the city’s outer suburban areas.

According to the New York Taxi Workers Alliance, the explosive growth from Uber and Lyft completely overturned the morale of taxicab drivers, leading to as many as six taxicab drivers committing suicide over the past several months from a seriously uncertain financial future — especially when you consider the costs of just even obtaining a medallion (license to operate a taxicab) in New York City.

Reuters reports the number of ridesharing vehicles skyrocketed from 12,600 in 2015 to about 80,000 this year. The New York City Taxi and Limousine Commission report that there are 14,000 yellow cabs in service throughout the metro area.

Although this particular cap only applies to the New York City metro area, New York isn’t the only city experiencing this clash between government-sanctioned taxicab and livery services and private ridesharing programs. Other cities abroad have seen strikes and even violent riots between taxicab drivers and ridesharing drivers competing over fares. And we’re certain this probably won’t be the last of such decision among governmental bodies of major metro cities as ridesharing continues to grow at rapid rates.

Editors' Recommendations

Chris Chin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Since picking up his first MicroMachine, Chris Chin knew his passion for automobiles was embedded into his soul. Based in…
Uber may be banned in London. Could the same thing happen in the U.S.?
The Uber app being used in London, England

The city of London on Monday announced it would revoke Uber’s operating license for the second time in two years over “persistent safety problems." The move means that the app might soon be banned in a city that's grown accustomed to easy rideshares, just as many American cities rely on similar apps.

For reasons that include safety issues for both riders and drivers, further congestion in cities, workers’ protections, and bucking regulations, Uber, Lyft, and similar apps have been a target of ire since they first appeared on the streets and disrupted how ordinary people around the world commute. That means they’ve been banned and fined multiple times over now -- and while some American cities want to crack down on ridesharing apps, there's little many of them can do to outright ban them as London, Uber's largest European market, is attempting to do.

Read more
Recording rides won’t fix Uber’s assault problem, lawyers say, but it’s a start
An Uber App on a smartphone.

Thorough background checks, kicking accused predators off the apps, reporting assaults to police, and working more closely with authorities. These might be reasonable ways for ridesharing apps like Uber and Lyft to deal with the tsunami of complaints the companies face from riders who say their drivers have sexually assaulted them. Or, more easily, you could just record your ride on your phone.

Indeed, Uber on Wednesday announced it would be rolling out a new feature on the app: The ability to make audio recordings of rides and send the audio to the company in the case of severe misconduct.

Read more
The best cars for Uber
Thinking of driving for Uber? These cars are safe, comfy, and fuel-efficient
2019 Hyundai Ioniq

It doesn't make a whole lot of sense to go through the effort of driving for Uber or Lyft if you spend every cent you earn (or more) on fuel and maintenance. So don't do that.
Further reading

Uber vs. Lyft
Best cars for teens and first-time drivers
How does Uber work?

Read more