Skip to main content

Federal judge finds grounds for examining alleged fraud in Uber antitrust case

how to delete your uber account
Prathan Chorruangsak / Shutterstock
An antitrust case filed in a U.S. district court in New York in December 2015 has taken an unexpected turn. U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff wants information about whether a private investigator hired by Uber concealed his identity — which would constitute fraud — when seeking information about an opponent in the lawsuit, according to Reuters.

The lawsuit, in which Uber CEO Travis Kalanick is the defendant, alleges that Kalanick and Uber drivers are guilty of price-fixing. It alleges, “Uber has a simple but illegal business plan: to fix prices among competitors and take a cut of the profits.” Unlike the other lawsuit involving Uber that has gotten a lot of attention, this is not a lawsuit between Uber drivers and Uber, but against the Uber CEO and the drivers. Uber itself is not a defendant in the case but is nevertheless actively helping Kalanick.

The lead plaintiff in the antitrust suit is Spencer Meyer, who is represented by Andrew Schmidt. The alleged fraud involves an investigative company, Ergo. After originally denying any knowledge of the investigator, Kalanick through his attorneys admitted to hiring Ergo to find information about Meyer and Schmidt, which is legal. Where the alleged fraud may have happened is if an Ergo employee misrepresented himself in his efforts to uncover details about the plaintiff and his attorney.

Kalanick’s attorneys moved to dismiss the suit in March. At the time, the attorneys argued that under the Uber passenger agreement, riders give up their right to bring a class action against the company. Judge Rakoff denied the request.

In the current issue, Rakoff has ordered Uber to submit to the court all documentation between Ergo and the company. Specifically, he wants to see evidence backing Uber’s claim that it did not know anything about the Ergo investigator misrepresenting himself.

“An Ergo investigator hired by Uber in connection with this case made false representations in order to gain access to information about plaintiff and his counsel, thus raising a serious risk of perverting the process of justice before this Court,” wrote Rackoff. The Ergo investigator “falsely stated that he was compiling a profile of up-and-coming labor lawyers in the United States,” Rackoff continued.

Uber’s attorney’s argued that the communications were privileged, but Rackoff denied their request. “The Court finds that plaintiff has provided an entirely ‘reasonable basis’ to suspect the perpetration of a fraud and to suspect that Uber communications furthered such a fraud,” Rakoff wrote.

Bruce Brown
Digital Trends Contributing Editor Bruce Brown is a member of the Smart Homes and Commerce teams. Bruce uses smart devices…
EVs may produce more emissions during manufacturing, but they quickly catch up
european cars getting bigger engines emissions car pollution smog

Electric vehicles are here in full force, and while they're still more expensive than their gas-powered counterparts, prices are slowly, but surely coming down. In fact, EVs are likely to be just as affordable as internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles in the next few years. But like anything, there are pros and cons to buying an EV over an ICE vehicle. For example, on average, it's cheaper to charge an electric vehicle than to fill the gas tank of an ICE vehicle -- not to mention the lower costs of maintenance.

At face value, having a smaller impact on the environment is also a tick in the EV column. But as many have been rightfully pointing out, the impact that EVs have on the environment is a little more complicated than the simple fact that they're not using gasoline and themselves emitting carbon dioxide. For example, what about the emissions involved with manufacturing an electric vehicle compared to a gas-powered vehicle? What about the materials in those huge batteries?

Read more
Used EV prices are falling quicker than those of gas cars, and that’s good
2022 Hyundai Ioniq 5 Limited AWD rear end side profile from driver's side with trees and a metal fence in the back.

Let's face it. Electric vehicles are getting cheaper, but they're still expensive, with so-called "budget" models still costing north of $35,000. That, however, really only accounts for new electric vehicles -- and it turns out that used ones are getting much more affordable. In fact, a new report suggests that the price of used electric vehicles is falling much quicker than that of gas counterparts.

I get it -- the concept can be scary. New EV buyers certainly don't want to find that their shiny electric vehicles are worth so much less after just a few years. But, in the grand scheme of things, this is actually a good thing.
The numbers
The report from iSeeCars notes that while in June 2023, average used EV prices were 25% higher than used gas car prices, by May 2024, used EV prices were 8% lower. That's a pretty dramatic change.

Read more
Bentley Continental GT and GTC Speed get performance boost as plug-in hybrids
Front three quarter view of the new Bentley Continental GT Speed coupe.

A few years ago, Bentley set off on a path to electrification that was paved with plug-in hybrids and added models like the Bentayga Hybrid to its lineup. However, that path was more of a parallel side road, with plug-in hybrids augmenting the lineup rather than replacing traditional gasoline-only models. Now they're heading for the fast lane.

Unveiled Tuesday, the fourth-generation Bentley Continental GT Speed coupe and GTC Speed convertible are the most powerful Bentley road cars ever — and they're plug-in hybrids. These performance models herald a new era for the Continental GT, Bentley's signature vehicle, along with its GTC convertible variant.

Read more