As AI gets smarter, humans need to stop being sore losers

Earlier this month, Google’s DeepMind team made history when its AlphaGo software managed to defeat professional Go player Lee Sedol in a five-game match. The contest was billed as a battle between man and machine — and it saw the human player largely outclassed by his AI opponent.

Artificial intelligence is only going to grow more sophisticated in coming years, becoming more of a factor in everyday life as the development of this technology continues to progress. With artificial minds growing ever more powerful, humans may have to change the game to maintain superiority.

Back to the 90s

To get a true impression of how much progress has been made in the field of artificial intelligence in recent years, it’s useful to compare the AlphaGo AI facing Lee with IBM’s Deep Blue computer, which faced Chess grandmaster Garry Kasparov in the 1990s.

At the time, Kasparov was widely considered to be the best Chess player on the face of the planet. He had already seen off an AI opponent quite handily, dispensing of IBM’s Deep Thought computer — named for the fictional system capable of deciphering the answers to life, the universe and everything in The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy — in a two-game series held in 1989.

Undeterred, IBM continued development of its Chess-playing computer. In 1996, a new iteration of the project known as Deep Blue was transported to Philadelphia to face Kasparov. The computer became the first to win a game against the reigning world champion under normal time controls, but was dominated by Kasparov after that early victory and lost the series 4-2, with two draws contributing half a point each.

Fifteen months later, a rematch was held in New York City. Deep Blue took the match with two draws and two outright wins. Frustrated, Kasparov accused IBM of cheating and demand a rematch. The company flatly refused, and the system was dismantled.

Advance to Go

Kasparov made attempts to explain away the loss to Deep Blue, pitching the idea that the match was a publicity stunt carried out by IBM. He theorized that human players had intervened to improve the computer’s performance, something that the company vehemently denied. Others in the Chess community would suggest that the machine was simply running a problem-solving program, and that it shouldn’t be considered true intelligence, or a real mastery of the game.

That said, the result of the high-profile series was enough proof for many that computers had eclipsed human ability in the game of Chess.

Deep Blue beat Kasparov using the ‘”brute force” method of computation. This technique is an exhaustive search that systematically works its way through all possible solutions until it finds the appropriate option. Its greatest strength is that it will always find a solution if one exists, but it’s let down by the fact that complex queries can take a great deal of time to work through.

Given that this brute force technique had proven so effective to the game of Chess, it became clear that any subsequent challenge would have to change the parameters in some manner. As such, competition veered away from Chess and towards Go.

In the end, it’s meaningless that Deep Blue’s move came as a result of a glitch.

While Chess and Go are both equally revered as classical strategy games, there is little doubt that the latter is the more complex. A Chess board is made up of 64 squares, compared to the 361 intersections on the playing field of Go. And the fact that Chess centers around putting your opponent in Checkmate, as opposed to the land-grab tactics necessary in Go, makes the latter a more complex problem for a computer to solve.

When discussing these games in relation to computer play, the numbers are all that really matter. There are 400 possible opening moves in Chess, compared to 32,490 in Go — a figure that rises to a staggering 129,960 when symmetrically identical moves are taken into account.

This staggering complexity means that brute force techniques are not enough to crack the game of Go. As well as an extensive training program playing against computer and human opposition, AlphaGo used a potent mixture of different approaches.

Monte Carlo tree search, an algorithm devised to help computers make quick and potent decisions during gameplay, was implemented to help AlphaGo prioritize between options under the tight time constraints of competitive Go. Meanwhile, neural networks inspired by biological brains provided a groundwork for the system to actively learn.

A brisk training regimen is one element that sets AlphaGo apart from Deep Blue. Google’s computer played countless practice games against human and machine opponents, and its neural networks. The researchers working on the project have referred to the process as trial-and-error, which would seem to bear a closer resemblance to the way a human would prepare for professional competition than brute force methodology.

These techniques were enough to defeat Lee — with the exception of the anomalous fourth game, where Lee managed to conquer the AI.

Move 78 and move 44

Pundits looking for an explanation of why Lee managed to best AlphaGo point to his 78th move in the fourth game. This play was met with praise from all directions, being called “beautiful” by Wired and described as a “masterful comeback” by Go Game Guru.

Chinese commentator Gu Li described Lee’s 78th move — which was an example of a play referred to as a Tesuji by players — as the “hand of God.” English language commentator Michael Redmond noted that the move “would take most opponents by surprise.”

Some Chess fans contended Kasparov’s loss to Deep Blue didn’t mean the AI had ‘real’ mastery of the game.

AlphaGo crumbled in its response to Lee’s power play. Shortly afterward, the human won his first game in the series.

Compare this to an exchange from the 1997 series between Kasparov and Deep Blue. The 44th move from the computer baffled Kasparov — he would later attribute it to “superior intelligence.” While the champion would win the first bout very soon after the play, that move in particular has been singled out as the turning point that threw Kasparov off his game. It made him doubt his chances.

We now know that the move was not genius, but a fall-back in Deep Blue’s programming. Unable to find a useful play, the computer simply resorted to a fail-safe.

These plays by Lee and Deep Blue both had the same effect. They shocked onlookers, and provided a win over a favored opponent. More importantly, both moves led to victory through the same means — confounding an adversary by making an audacious play.

In the end, it’s meaningless that Deep Blue’s move came as a result of a glitch. Part of the strategy involved in games like Chess and Go is holding your nerve, making your rival feel as if you’re one step ahead of them, even when you’re not. Kasparov — albeit erroneously — allowed the “superior intelligence” of the computer get in his head.

As a human reading this article, it’s only natural to jump to the defense of an organic life-form over his machine opponent. Fluke or not, Deep Blue managed to carry its momentum from an irregular play into a five-game unbeaten run.

A Time headline from last year asked the question, “did Deep Blue beat Kasparov because of a system glitch?” Implicitly, that wording tries to explain away the result as a failing of the computer. Compare that to praise-laden coverage of Lee’s victory in the fourth match against AlphaGo which, while worthy of congratulations, didn’t prompt the kind of turnaround that Deep Blue accomplished.

This contrast should illustrate something that may well be obvious. Humans are bad losers.


Turn your iPad into a display for your new Mac Mini with this workaround

The folks at Luna Display have figured out a workaround which lets you get the best of both worlds and use Wi-Fi and an adapter in order to turn your iPad into a display for the 2018 Mac Mini.

Your PlayStation 4 game library isn't complete without these games

Looking for the best PS4 games out there? Out of the massive crop of titles available, we selected the best you should buy. No matter what your genre of choice may be, there's something here for you.

These are the best Xbox One games available right now

More than four years into its life span, Microsoft's latest console is finally coming into its own. From 'Cuphead' to 'Halo 5,' the best Xbox One games offer something for everyone.

Check out 30 of the best iPhone games you need to be playing

The iPhone has some of our favorite games available for any mobile platform. Here are the best iPhone games for every big-name genre, whether you're into puzzles, strategy, or something else entirely.

The best free-to-play games you can play right now

Believe it or not, free-to-play games have evolved into engaging, enjoyable experiences. Here are a few of our favorites that you can play right now, including Warframe and the perennially-popular League of Legends.

Latest SMS breach could allow hackers access to your online accounts

A new security breach that exposed more than 26 million text messages could be a huge nightmare for users relying on two-factor authentication. Many of the SMS on the database contained security codes and account reset links.

Microsoft’s Windows 10 Mail client goes freemium with the introduction of ads

Microsoft Windows Insiders are finding a nasty surprise inside the Mail app on the latest Windows 10 preview build in the form of banner ads. These ads will appear in the Mail app regardless of the webmail service you use.

All the best Apple MacBook deals for Black Friday 2018

Shoppers looking for a new Apple laptop could find huge savings on a new MacBook come Black Friday. Retailers are offering discounts as much as $650 on select MacBook, MacBook Air, and MacBook Pro models this holiday season.

Apple discontinues AirPort Extreme, Time Capsule as it exits Wi-Fi router business

Apple is now officially no longer in the router business. The company had already stopped selling the AirPort Express, and now its retail stores and websites have stopped offering the AirPort Extreme and Time Capsule.

Secure your Excel documents with a password by following these quick steps

Excel documents are used by people and businesses all over the world. Given how often they contain sensitive information, it makes sense to keep them from the wrong eyes. Thankfully, it's easy to secure them with a password.

Lost your router? Here's how to find its IP address to help track it down

Changing the login information for your router isn't always easy, that's why so many have that little card on the back. But in order to use it, you need to know where to go. Here's how to find the IP address of your router.

PDF to JPG conversion is quick and easy using these simple methods

Converting file formats can be an absolute pain, but it doesn't have to be. We've put together a comprehensive guide on how to convert a PDF to JPG, no matter which operating system you're running.

Crypto hangover could take blame for Nvidia’s potential GeForce RTX 2060 delay

Nvidia's delay in announcing a ship date for its GeForce RTX 2060 GPU could be due to a burst in the cryptocurrency mining bubble. Executives blamed the crypto hangover for an oversupply of inventory on existing GTX 1060 cards,

Save $900 on the ThinkPad X1 Carbon and more with Lenovo’s Cyber Monday sales

In the latest set of holiday sales, Lenovo is heavily discounting its fifth-generation ThinkPad X1 Carbon and other popular Windows laptops and 2-in-1s for the holiday shopping season.
1 of 2