Skip to main content

Amazon may be pursuing music streaming licenses for Cloud Player, despite earlier reports

amazon-cloud-player-launch-screenYou may have read yesterday that Sony Music isn’t a big fan of Amazon’s newly launched Cloud Player. The beef is that the online retailer’s new cloud service offers music streaming to users even though it never actually went about the process of negotiating for licenses to do so. Amazon contended that streaming licenses are not necessary, since the content is coming from each user’s personal storage space in the cloud-based network, making it analogous to a remote external hard drive.

Now there’s word that Amazon is “aggressively” pursuing music licenses in the hopes of improving its new service, which many believe was launched in a surprise move as part of an attempt to beat competitors Apple and Google — both believed to be working on cloud services of their own — to market. To be fair, the news comes from unnamed “people familiar with the matter,” according to a report in The Wall Street Journal. That said, there are reasons why obtaining streaming licenses might be attractive to Amazon even though the law seems to be on its side with regards to the Cloud Player launch.

One potential problem is the Cloud Player feature that allows up to five people to listen to the same song simultaneously. There is actually legal precedent to back up Amazon’s “no license is necessary” claims, the WSJ notes. A 2007 lawsuit involving Cablevision and its “remote DVR” plan eventually made its way to the U.S. Supreme Court, which ruled that the company could keep recorded TV and film content on a central server as long as there were separate copies for each user. While Amazon’s Cloud Drive and Player are fundamentally the same — streaming content comes from each user’s Cloud Drive locker — the streaming-for-five capability is more questionable.

Even if Amazon were to knock that feature out, there are still reasons for the company to seek out streaming licenses for its music. The big one is storage space. Say Kanye West releases a new album, and three million people buy it as an MP3 download through Amazon. That’s three million different copies of a single album in three million separate Cloud Drives. With a license from the record label to stream that content, all of the music available for purchase could be stored in a central server and accessed by anyone who owns it.

Suddenly, those three million copies shrink down to just one. Anyone who owns the digital album would still have access to streaming through Cloud Player and downloading through Cloud Drive, but the actual, physical data would be streamed from elsewhere. Of course, this would also raise a whole new set of concerns.

If Amazon secures the necessary rights to stream music and suddenly all MP3s are accessed by the cloud from a central database, will that purchased content still consume each user’s allotment of Cloud Drive storage space? Common sense says no since the data is technically stored elsewhere, but securing those licenses costs money. Instead of going the subscription route, as Sony‘s Music Unlimited does, Amazon could simply point to the drain on each user’s storage space as “payment” for the right to stream.

If the online retailer really is going after music streaming licenses, it appears that a rough road may lie ahead. Sony responded quickly yesterday with a vague threat of legal action, and now there’s another one from Sony/ATV Music Publishing chairman Martin Brandier. “This is just another land grab,” he said, in a nod to Amazon’s perceived attempt to beat Apple and Google to market. “I can’t make it any plainer than that. It’s really disrespectful, and of course we are considering all of our options.”

Adam Rosenberg
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Previously, Adam worked in the games press as a freelance writer and critic for a range of outlets, including Digital Trends…
This is the cheapest 17-inch laptop worth buying today
A woman video chats with her friends on an HP Envy laptop.

If you want your next laptop to come equipped with a larger screen compared to what its peers offer, then check out the HP Laptop 17z. The budget-friendly device is pretty affordable at its original price of $500, but it's even cheaper right now due to a $220 discount from HP that pulls its price down to $280. You're going to have to be quick with your purchase though, because like with most laptop deals, we don't expect the savings to stay up for a long time.

Why you should buy the HP Laptop 17z
The HP Laptop 17z with a 17.3-inch HD+ display is perfect if you want to build presentations, manage spreadsheets, browse websites, and watch streaming shows on one of the biggest screens that you can get on a laptop. Coupled with its relatively cheap price that's easy on the wallet, the HP Laptop 17z holds its spot in our roundup of the best 17-inch laptops as an affordable large-screen laptop.

Read more
This Dell PC with an RTX 4070, 32GB of RAM is $430 off today
Dell XPS Desktop sitting on a coffee table.

If you're on the hunt for desktop computer deals, you're going to want to check out everything that Dell has to offer. Here's a bargain that you wouldn't want to miss -- the Dell XPS Desktop, originally priced at $2,130, with a $430 discount that pulls it down to $1,700. It doesn't fall into the category of ultra-affordable PCs, but at this price, you're going to get amazing value. However, you're going to have to hurry with your purchase because we're not sure if you'll still be able to get the savings if you delay your transaction to tomorrow.

Why you should buy the Dell XPS Desktop
The Dell XPS Desktop is an excellent choice if you need a new PC, as it's our top choice in our roundup of the best desktop computers. Whether you need it for work or school, the machine will give you flagship performance with the 13th-generation Intel Core i7 processor, Nvidia GeForce RTX 4070 graphics card, and 32GB of RAM. The Dell XPS Desktop will be more than enough to multitask between several apps or to deal with demanding processes, such as editing multimedia files and playing the best PC games during your break times.

Read more
This could be your last chance to get this HP gaming PC for $480
The HP Victus 15L gaming PC on a desk.

HP is one of the most reliable sources of affordable gaming PC deals, and the HP Victus 15L is a great example. It's currently on sale with a $300 discount that pulls its price down to only $480 from $780, but you need to act fast if you want to get the gaming desktop for this cheap. There's probably not a lot of time left for this bargain, so if you want to enjoy the savings, you're going to have to push through with the transaction as soon as you can -- today, if possible.

Why you should buy the HP Victus 15L gaming desktop
With the price of the HP Victus 15L, you shouldn't expect it to challenge the performance of the top-of-the-line models of the best gaming PCs. However, it's going to be enough for casual gamers with its AMD Ryzen 5 5600G processor, AMD Radeon RX 6400 graphics card, and 8GB of RAM. You'll be able to play the best PC games on the HP Victus 15L, though for some titles, you may have to go with the lowest graphic settings to ensure that the game runs properly.

Read more