Skip to main content

GitHub pull requests affected by gender bias, new study suggests

github gender bias coding
Pixabay
Evidence that gender bias exists in the field of computer science has emerged in the form of a new study examining acceptance rates of contributions from men and women in an open-source software community. The study’s findings indicated that women’s contributions were rejected more often, but only if their gender is identifiable. If, in fact, it is unclear whether the contributor is a man or a woman, women’s contributions tended to be accepted at a greater rate.

“There are a number of questions and concerns related to gender bias in computer programming, but this project was focused on one specific research question: To what extent does gender bias exist when pull requests are judged on GitHub?” Emerson Murphy-Hill, corresponding author of a paper on the study and an associate professor of computer science at North Carolina State University, told phys.org.

In order to conduct this research, Murphy-Hill and his colleagues analyzed more than three million pull requests (methods to improve code on a project) from around 330,000 GitHub users, about 21,000 of whom were women. Within this group, 78.7 percent of women’s pull requests were accepted, while 74.6 percent of men’s requests were accepted.

But when gender got involved, things got a bit more complicated. Murphy-Hill also looked at pull requests from individuals who were not considered “insiders” on a project, and found that gender appeared to play a role in acceptance. Computer scientists who were easily identifiable as women (as a result of their name or profile picture) ended up with lower pull request acceptance rates at 58 percent than male users at 61 percent. Curiously enough, female programmers with gender neutral profiles had the highest acceptance rates of all in this group (70 percent), even more so than men with gender neutral profiles (65 percent).

“Our results indicate that gender bias does exist in open-source programming,” Murphy-Hill said. “The study also tells us that, in general, women on GitHub are strong programmers. We don’t think that’s because gender affects one’s programming skills, but likely stems from strong self-selection among women who submit pull requests on the site.”

You can check out the full results of the study in the open-access journal PeerJ Computer Science, where the research is published under the title, “Gender Differences and Bias in Open Source: Pull Request Acceptance of Women Versus Men.”

Editors' Recommendations

Lulu Chang
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Fascinated by the effects of technology on human interaction, Lulu believes that if her parents can use your new app…
Built for web browsing, this Dell Inspiron 15 laptop is discounted to $280
Dell Inspiron 15 3000 Laptop on a white background displaying a colourful scene.

There are laptop deals for top-of-the-line machines, but there are also offers for budget-friendly devices like the Dell Inspiron 15. It's an excellent choice if you're only planning to use your laptop for basic tasks like browsing the internet, especially now that it's on sale from Dell for a very affordable $280 following a $50 discount on its original price of $330. It's highly recommended that you proceed with the purchase right now though, as we're not sure if stocks will still be available tomorrow.

Why you should buy the Dell Inspiron 15 laptop
For its price, you shouldn't expect the Dell Inspiron 15 to challenge the performance of the best laptops. It's only equipped with the 12th-generation Intel Core i3 processor and Intel UHD Graphics after all, with 8GB of RAM that our guide on how much RAM do you need says is typical for entry-level laptops. However, with these specifications, it will be more than enough to handle simple activities. If you're thinking about using the Dell Inspiron 15 for checking emails, typing documents, and watching streaming shows, then it's going to serve you just fine.

Read more
Microsoft finds a sneaky way to slip more ads into Windows
The new windows 11 start menu.

Microsoft is currently testing a new way to showcase ads on the Windows 11 Start Menu, and it's meant to encourage users to download more applications.

The brand has used the top of the Windows start menu as an area to showcase general ads in the past, and it was not well-received by system users. However, it is now experimenting with putting what it calls “app promotions” at the bottom of the start menu area, according to Windows Central.

Read more
Watch this BBC report about computer addicts … from 1983
A man using a computer in a BBC report from 1983.

1983: Meet the COMPUTER ADDICTS | Newsnight | Retro Tech | BBC Archive

The BBC has just shared another video from its archives, this one showing a report about computer addicts from way back in 1983, when computers were just starting to find their way into the workplace and home.

Read more