Skip to main content

Google vs. Bing: The war continues

google-vs-bingThe war of words between Google and Bing hit a fevered pitch Wednesday, with Google search engineer Amit Singhal blasting Microsoft in a post on the official Google Blog for allegedly stealing search results, calling Bing’s results a “cheap imitation.”

“However you define copying,” writes Singhal, “the bottom line is, these Bing results came directly from Google.”

Related Videos

The public battle between the online search competitors began Tuesday after Danny Sullivan at Search Engine Land reported that Google had staged an undercover “sting operation” to trick Bing into copying bogus search results after engineers noticed Bing results for an obscure eye surgery, called tarsorrhaphy, looking suspiciously similar to their own.

In Google’s newest presentation of evidence, Singhal further explains how they came to discover that Bing was copying Google spelling corrections and search results:

We noticed that URLs from Google search results would later appear in Bing with increasing frequency for all kinds of queries: popular queries, rare or unusual queries and misspelled queries. Even search results that we would consider mistakes of our algorithms started showing up on Bing.

Microsoft has denied claims that it copied Google’s data about what people search and click to fine-tune Bing’s search results, telling ZDNet unequivocally that Bing does “not copy Google’s results.”

Bing VP Harry Shum continued the Microsoft line on the official Bing blog, saying: “To be clear, we learn from all of our customers. What we saw in today’s story was a spy-novelesque stunt to generate extreme outliers in tail query ranking. It was a creative tactic by a competitor, and we’ll take it as a back-handed compliment. But it doesn’t accurately portray how we use opt-in customer data as one of many inputs to help improve our user experience.”

This exchange was followed by a heated (and highly entertaining) back-and-forth on Twitter between Googlers and Microsoft’s communications chief Frank Shaw, who claimed that Google was the “pot calling [the] kettle black” because “Google collects customer data from Chrome and Android,” among other refutations.

The Google vs. Bing confrontation has sparked a wave of criticism — aimed at both sides — from the tech community. But to Google’s critics, Singhal says that the company’s goal is simple: “We would like for this practice to stop.”

Editors' Recommendations

How to convert a PDF to a Word document
Young Adult Laptop Lifestyle

PDFs are a great way to share documents because the format can be read by mostly anyone. It's generally used with digital manuals, sales receipts, manuscripts, and so on — documents that aren't meant for editing. Think of PDFs as digital printouts with pretty designs.

Read more
How to drop a pin in Google Maps
google maps

Pins are a convenient Google Maps feature that allows you to save a location. You can drop a pin to save an address or mark a location if it doesn’t have an address or if the address is incorrect. Your pins will help you navigate to these locations again, and you can also share them with your friends to indicate a meetup location.

Read more
These are the new AI features coming to Gmail, Google Docs, and Sheets
Google has announced a host of new writing focused AI features for its Workspace suite.

Google Workspace is getting a generative AI boost at the same time that many other productivity suites are adding new features that allow users to simplify clerical tasks with just a prompt.

Following up on the visual redesign to Google Docs and the announcement of Google Bard, these new AI features are the company's latest attempt to bring more buzzy goodness to its most popular applications.

Read more