Skip to main content

Should you accept Atom in your next PC?

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Intel introduced the Atom processor nearly five years ago. It was intentionally designed to enable products that Intel called “mobile Internet devices,” which were more or less tablets that weren’t very popular.

The iPad wouldn’t hit until two years later, however, which meant the possibilities of Atom weren’t explored. Instead, the processor ended up in the tidal wave of netbooks that ambushed the market and then quickly retreated. Atom was caught in the undertow of that receding wave, and hardware manufacturers turned towards ARM processors capable of running Android.

Windows 8 is giving Atom a second chance. Finally, after years of waiting, the products that Atom was designed to enable can be built. Tablets and convertibles with Atom processors are already available, and their numbers are growing. But should you buy a tablet or laptop with an Atom processor, or is the processor popularized by the netbook only suited for that role?

What is an Atom, anyway?

Before we talk about the two types of devices in which Atom appears (besides the netbook), you should first understand a bit about what Atom is and where it came from.

Since the company pushed Core so aggressively, it’s easy to forget they make anything else at all. Atom is quite different from the Intel Core processor you’re likely familiar with. Atom uses its own architecture designed with efficiency, cost, and physical size as priorities. Speed – well, not so much. An Atom processor is around four to six times slower than a third-gen Core i7 in many benchmarks.

Though originally single-core, most of today’s Atom products are dual-core. They have integrated graphics and are fully x86 compatible, which means they’ll run (almost) any software a Core processor can run.

Atom in tablets

Intel Atom InsideIntel saw the tablet coming. Kinda. The company started to talk about “mobile Internet devices” in 2007 and released several platforms with the cooperation of hardware partners. Because Intel makes x86 processors, however, it had to stick with Windows. The products looked the part – they had small touchscreens, miniature keyboards, and often required the use of a stylus.

Today’s Atom tablets, however, are similar to their Android competitors. They’re generally a bit thicker, often have large displays, but are otherwise hard to tell apart. Windows 8 will be the giveaway, of course, but the new operating system’s touch interface banished the stylus from most devices.

Atom is a good fit for tablets. Though slow compared to an Intel Core processor, it’s quicker (sometimes much quicker) than any ARM processor on the market today. And while the architecture has become faster over the last five years, Window’s system requirements have barely budged. This means the performance of Intel’s least capable of chip is truly adequate. It’s not great, perhaps not even good – but good enough.  

Unfortunately there is a skeleton in Atom’s closet: graphics performance. Graphics was a sore spot for the chip when it was released in 2008, and there hasn’t been much improvement. Even the Intel HD 4000 graphics found in a Core processor will knock the socks off Atom. Want to play a 3D game? Too bad. The game probably won’t run; and if it does, it won’t run well. That will be a shock to anyone who has enjoyed immersive 3D gaming on a smaller, less expensive Android device.

Battery life will vary from tablet to tablet but, overall, Atom doesn’t appear to be at a disadvantage. Tablets based on the processor can last between six and ten hours depending on settings and battery size.

Atom in convertibles

Convertible laptops are also seeing Atom’s return, which is no big surprise. Inexpensive convertibles were always the obvious next step for netbooks. Hardware manufacturers were just waiting for Windows to catch up with the touch revolution.

Everything we’ve said about Atom in tablets also applies to convertibles, yet there’s more to consider. Convertibles, unlike tablets, are going to be used at least partially as a traditional PC. That means more time spent with the Windows desktop, more multi-tasking, and heavier use of demanding applications.

This is where Atom starts to stumble. Though quick enough for Web browsing, the processor feels seriously slow when encoding videos or even editing large photos. Tasks that seem to take a blink of an eye on an Intel Core laptop can take five seconds on an Atom system.

Who cares? You will care. Maybe not at first, but after a few hours or weeks the constant lag, lengthy load times, and almost imperceptible stutters will begin to gnaw at you. Atom processors are the perfect way to recreate the feel of computing ten years ago.

All of this might be acceptable if the price was low. That was the premise of netbooks, after all – good enough for the ‘net and cheap enough to fit almost any budget. Modern Atom convertibles don’t fit that mold and often ship with a price between $500 and $800. That’s a lot to spend for an okay tablet that can also be used as a sub-par laptop.

You wait, you win

One of Intel’s most important announcements at CES 2013 was a new line of Atom quad-cores that should be showing up in products by the end of this year. Though details were scarce at the conference, leaks from late 2012 indicate that the Atom quads will have higher clock speeds than current processors and will also include Intel HD 2500 and HD 4000 graphics. If true, the new line of Atoms will be a huge upgrade over what is currently available.

We think that consumers eyeing an Atom-powered tablet or convertible should turn their eyes elsewhere until the new version is available. In the meantime, buyers on a budget should instead consider an Android tablet or an iPad. They provide far more value for your money

Editors' Recommendations

Matthew S. Smith
Matthew S. Smith is the former Lead Editor, Reviews at Digital Trends. He previously guided the Products Team, which dives…
The best gifts for PC gamers
A Pc gamer playing games.

PC gamers are fickle and opinionated, which makes tracking down the best gifts for PC gamers quite the chore. We rounded up 11 gifts that any PC gamer would be happy to find in this year, from budget stocking stuffers to massive gaming monitors.

We split our guide into two sections. The top five gifts will work for anyone. If you're not sure what to buy for the PC gamer in your life, these are the ones to stick with. The bottom six are our favorite peripherals in various categories, but make sure to check with who you're shopping for to make sure they need an upgrade in the first place.
A Steam gift card

Read more
Warhammer 40,000: Darktide will bring your PC to its knees (and you’ll love every minute)
A horde rushing at the player in Warhammer 40K Darktide.

Rejects, get your lasguns and chainswords ready. There's a heretic about in Warhammer 40,000: Darktide, and it's up to you and three other criminals to venture into the Hive city of Tertium, eradicate the plague, and wipe out the traitors before heresy spreads. Between some performance drops and intermittent crashes, that is.

I hit the ground running with Darktide, and I've put 30 hours into the PC game prior to its full release. I've rounded up a few tips to optimize performance, and will also cover what frame rates you can expect on different hardware, as well as some vital considerations to keep in mind before you buy the game.
Warhammer 40,000: Darktide system requirements

Read more
Should you buy a gaming PC on Black Friday or wait for Cyber Monday?
Gamer using Discord on a gaming desktop PC.

The fear of missing out on a great gaming PC deal is real; for some, that means they would prefer to wait for Cyber Monday. Well, let's take a look at whether it's worth waiting an extra few days for those cheap gaming PC deals or if it's better to grab one of the several deals we've collected for you here.
Should You Buy a Gaming PC on Black Friday?
While you might feel like waiting for Cyber Monday to buy a gaming PC is a better idea, the likelihood of finding better deals on the same gaming PC is very slim, if you find deals on them at all. As such, it's better to grab one of the several Black Friday gaming PC deals now than risk not getting any deals altogether. That said, it's true that Cyber Monday tends to mirror Black Friday sales, so if you find something better, you can always refund your Black Friday purchase and buy the newer and better deal.
Our 5 Favorite Black Friday PC Deals
Lenovo Legion Tower 5 -- $730, was $990

While this Lenovo Legion Tower 5 didn't make our list of best all-AMD gaming PCs, it still comes close. The AMD Radeon RX 6500XT GPU is entry-level and roughly equivalent to the RTX 3050 if you aren't familiar with the AMD lineup, which means you can get a lot of indie and casual gaming done quite easily. You can also push some more modern games with lower graphical settings; most free-to-play games will do just fine. The AMD Ryzen 5-5600G is a mid-range CPU for gaming and general productivity work, making it pretty versatile. Sadly, there are only 8GB of RAM, which is the bare minimum, but you could always upgrade it with another 8GB to get that extra dual-channel performance. Finally, the 512GB SSD should be more than enough for most use cases, although you might want to grab one of the external hard drive deals to supplement it.

Read more