Skip to main content

Surprising Hard Disk Life Data from Google

Surprising Hard Disk Life Data from Google

A new report from Internet titan Google examined the performance of 100,000 consumer-grade hard drives ranging from 80 to 400 GB in capacity in use in Google’s operations since 2001. The report’s conclusions: heavy use and high temperatures may not contribute to drive failure as much as “common knowledge” suggests.

In their report (PDF), Eduardo Pinheiro, Wolf-Dietrich Weber, and Luiz Andr´ Barroso wrote that, initially, they expected to find that heavier drive use would correspond with higher failure rates; instead, the results of their study hint at a more complicated pattern to drive failure—and, amusingly, hint that data from drive’s built-in SMART self-monitoring technology isn’t enough to go on when trying to predict the failure of individual drives. Some SMART parameters were found to have a strong correspondence with higher probabilities of failure—for instance, a drive was 39 times more likely to fail within 60 days of their first scan error than they were if they didn’t produce any errors. However, a large portion of Google’s failed drives showed no SMART errors at all, suggesting monitoring SMART data alone is not enough to predict individual drive failure, although it might be useful in aggregate across “populations” of drives.

Recommended Videos

Google also found that drives less than three years old but which received heavy use were less likely to fail than drives of a similar age which received infrequent use. “One possible explanation for this behavior is the survival of the fittest theory,” the authors wrote. “Drives that survive the infant mortality phrase are the least susceptible to that failure mode, and result in a population that is more robust with respect to variation in utilization levels.”

The study also found that drive failures do not increase with the average temperature; in fact, the authors found that lower temperatures were associated with higher drive failure rates. “Only at very high temperatures,” above 45° C, “is there a slight reversal of this trend.” However, older hard drives (three years old or more) were mire likely to suffer a failure in warmer environments.

Google very politely omits mention of the observed performance of specific drives and drive manufacturers, but its results do serve as an interesting starting point for discussions of how we store our data, and what we can reasonably expect from it. As the authors note, over 90 percent of new information produced in the world is being stored on magnetic media—and, as I would note, the failure rate of hard drives is (eventually) 100 percent.

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Remove personal data from Google and reduce spam with this tool
Delete my data?

There's a lot of information about you out there on the web. From dating app data to health information, things that you likely don't want others to know about are inevitably floating about online. Many because you've "opted in" due to tapping "Agree" after an a lengthy boring legal disclaimer on an app, others from companies gathering publicly available government data and compiling it in one spot. A sane person might be tempted to go about deleting all of this data. They would, however, find that the task is quite difficult. That's why you should consider using Incogni, which not only does the heavy lifting for you, but is also 50% off right now. A typical monthly rate for the Incogni service is $12.98 per month, but now you can get it at a rate of $6.49 per month if you buy a full year of the service. That's brings a year of scrubbing your name off the net to $78, from $156, if you tap the button below.

Why you should try Incogni — Limit, Lower, Prevent
As a service, Incogni works on your behalf to limit overall information about you online. Incogni takes a three-pronged approach to increasing your online privacy: Limiting access to your information, lowering identity theft risk, and preventing your data from being sold. Here's how each prong works.

Read more
How to delete a file from Google Drive on desktop and mobile
Google Drive in Chrome on a MacBook.

Google Drive is an excellent cloud storage solution that can be accessed from numerous devices. Whether you do most of your Google Drive uploading or downloading from a PC, Chromebook, or mobile device, there’s going to come a time when you’ll need to delete a file (or two). Fortunately, the deletion process couldn’t be more straightforward.

We’ve also put together this helpful guide to show you how to trash your Google Drive content a couple of different ways.

Read more
How to download files from Google Drive
The official logo for Google Drive.

Google Drive is a common cloud storage choice for work and education projects, especially if you are collaborating with other people or are part of a broader workflow process. However, sometimes you need to download a file to your device for more direct work or to more easily move it somewhere else.

Read more