Skip to main content

More drone crashes caused by technical glitches, not human error, study shows

drone crashes caused by technical glitches 53174738 ml
Fineart / 123RF
While pilots may take a brunt of the public’s worries on drone safety, a new study suggests that, most of the time, they’re not the ones at fault. About 64 percent of drone crashes are caused by technical issues, a study released today by the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology (RMIT) says.

The study is the first to dive beyond general finger pointing when drone crashes cause a stir. After a drone hit a British Airways plane en route to Heathrow Airport in April, Graham Wild and Glenn Baxter, both from the RMIT engineering department, and John Murray from Edith Cowan University, decided to conduct a study on just what caused most drone accidents.

The researchers looked at 150 reported drone crashes worldwide, occurring between 2006 and 2016. The study showed that technical glitches were the guilty party in more than half the cases. Dividing those causes down even further, the team said that the loss of communication between the drone and the operator was the most common error.

“Large transport category aircraft, such as those from a Boeing or Airbus, are required to have triple redundant systems for their communications,” Wild said. “But drones don’t and some of the improvements that have reduced the risks in those aircraft could also be used to improve the safety of drones.”

Many drones have fail-safes that will automatically land the aircraft when it looses communication with the pilot — while that prevents “runaway” drones in many cases, landing automatically means there’s nothing to tell the drone what’s below. Many fail-safes also have to be calibrated, something that many novice drone users fail to do. An online poll in 2014, for example, showed that out of 774 DJI Phantom owners, a third of them had lost control at some point and 122 of them never actually saw their unmanned aircraft again.

The results from the RMIT study led Wild to conclude that the regulations aren’t quite keeping up with the growth of drone technology. Lightweight drones aren’t expected to meet the same standards as their larger counterparts, yet they can still cause damage if they fly in a built-up area, he said.

Another issue is that drone crashes are seldom reported unless they cause damage. Being able to analyze more crash data would help drive additional research to support government regulations.

“Drones are being used for a wide range of tasks now and there are a lot of day-to-day activities that people want to use them for — delivering pizzas and packages, taking photos, geosurveying, firefighting, and search and rescue,” Wild said. “It’s essential that our safety regulations keep up with this rapidly growing industry.”

Editors' Recommendations

Hillary K. Grigonis
Hillary never planned on becoming a photographer—and then she was handed a camera at her first writing job and she's been…
Meet the startup that transports human organs via drone
MissionGO Organ transplant

Every year, approximately 5,000 Americans die while they’re on the waiting list for kidney transplants. It’s a terrifying figure, and it’s one that’s brought into sharp relief by a second data point: That each year around 3,500 donated kidneys are discarded. Overall, according to a 2019 study published in the journal JAMA Internal Medicine, around 17% of kidneys that are donated in the United States are ultimately thrown out.

Dr. Joe Scalea, a transplant surgeon at the University of Maryland’s School of Medicine and University of Maryland Medical Center, wants to reverse this trend. And he believes that, along with cutting-edge medicine, cutting-edge technology has a big role to play. To that end, his new commercial venture seeks to do something that, just a few years ago, would have sounded totally crazy.

Read more
Why engineers are studying dragonflies to build the next generation of drones
dragonfly inspired robot common darter 1  lin lab

Various dragonfly drops Lin Lab

Nature is a consummate problem-solver. After all, it’s had billions of years of evolutionary iteration to figure out (in a roundabout way) what works and what doesn’t. For that reason, researchers frequently look at the natural world for answers -- even when they’re solving a problem that, technologically, might be pretty new.

Read more
Tesla sudden accelerations caused by driver error, NHTSA concludes
Tesla Model 3

Tesla vehicles do not have a design flaw that can cause sudden unintended acceleration (SUA), according to the results of a yearlong review by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).

The investigation — launched by the agency after it received a petition with 232 complaints about the alleged fault, 203 of them involving crashes — concluded that the incidents were caused by the driver hitting the wrong pedal.

Read more