Skip to main content

Minority Report for poachers: Can predictive algorithms prevent wildlife crime?

Iguana
Dr. Meredith Gore

When you think of wildlife trafficking, what springs to mind is likely elephant ivory and rhino tusks. But it also encompasses rosewood, lizards, and pangolins. Estimates for its worth range from $7 billion to $23 billion. With over 7,000 species involved in trafficking — ranging from plants to reptiles to mammals — in practically every country in the world, the problem is dizzying. That’s why Dr. Meredith Gore wants to stop poachers before they cut the tree or kill the animal.

Recommended Videos

A human problem

Beyond saving wildlife threatened with extinction, trafficking has an impact on humans as well. “I think that the coronavirus, the COVID-19 situation that’s happening right now is just really emblematic of kind of the worst-case scenario,” Gore, an associate professor in the Department of Fisheries and Wildlife at Michigan State University, told Digital Trends. She describes her science as conservation criminology.

Dr. Meredith Gore
Dr. Meredith Gore, associate professor in the Department of Fisheries and Wildlife at Michigan State University Image used with permission by copyright holder

Pangolins look like scaly anteaters. The mammals are prized for both their meat and scales, which some believe to have medicinal properties. The trafficking route might stretch from the Democratic Republic of Congo through multiple countries to Nigeria and then on to Singapore, said Gore. The Chinese government recently issued a temporary ban on wild animal trade, because pangolins are one suspected cause of the coronavirus.

Animal skulls on shelf
Dr. Meredith Gore

If something is illegal, usually we don’t see it,” said Gore. “And if we don’t see it, we can’t monitor it. And if we can’t monitor it, that means that we’re usually in a position of just reacting.” Among the difficulties with tracking these illegal goods are porous borders. Often countries don’t inspect exports as thoroughly as imports, according to the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. There are many ways to get goods into a country — through air, land, and sea — and they don’t always arrive in their original, more-recognizable form. Bear gallbladder might show up ground into a powder, for example, only discernible with DNA testing. Because the problem crosses nations, it requires cooperation amongst countries with varying levels of resources and differing rules and regulations.

At the same time, traffickers are getting more sophisticated and turning to technology in a variety of ways. Even as national parks are putting up anti-poaching technologies like human-sensing cameras and metal detectors to go off when someone approaches with a gun or knife, poachers leverage GPS and smartphones to track animals and avoid patrols. A 2016 study found there wasn’t much wildlife trade happening on the dark web, indicating law enforcement perhaps wasn’t scouring the regular internet well enough to deter activity there. A year later, researchers found that things had changed, and dark-web transactions were growing.

If we could stop poachers before they have the gun in their hand, though, it could make all the difference, says Gore. As a social scientist, she’s looking at the issue differently than a biologist or botanist. People have been collecting and trading wildlife for ages — look at Marco Polo or the Silk Road. But it’s only been in the last couple of decades that organizations like the U.N. have begun treating it as a crime. While Gore has worked on problems involving sea cucumbers, vultures, and pangolins, she says her real species of interest is humans. “It’s this idea that human behavior and people’s attitudes are really central to being able to use natural resources in a sustainable way,” she said.

What does Cincinnati have to do with it?

By adapting frameworks like situational crime prevention (SCP), conservation criminology can be more scientific and more effectively implemented. SCP uses 25 tactics to dissuade people from committing crimes, things like reducing incentives and upping risks. Gore and her team expanded to 30 techniques and adapted them for wildlife. You might be able to reduce the risk of car theft by putting vehicles in a garage, but you can’t lock up an entire forest.

Some of the techniques involve deterring criminals, including implementing tech like drones and CCTV. Others focus on increasing rewards, such as creating alternative livelihoods to poaching or providing compensation for conservation efforts. “These are strategies and tactics that you can implement on the ground to prevent crime from occurring in the first place,” said Gore.

turtles
Dr. Meredith Gore

One important dimension is that while these ideas are taken from the U.S. criminal justice system, Gore doesn’t advocate for fines and prison sentences as deterrents. “Throwing people in jail and really harsh sentences, those have their own follow-on collateral impact on society,” she said. Sometimes offenders have had their lives or livelihoods threatened by wildlife, and the goal is to reduce these occurrences and protect the environment without criminalizing vulnerable members of societies.

If you look a map of Kinshasa in the Democratic Republic of Congo and only focus on the source of wildlife trafficking, you’re missing a large part of the picture, said Gore. Modifying a technique developed for Cincinnati police, Gore has mapped the four “C’s” in crime-place networks: crime sites, comfort sites, corruption points, and convergent points. Where do offenders, or potential offenders, go when they’re not offending? Where are newcomers recruited? If researchers can identify those spots, conservation organizations can put their resources in those hot spots, again in the hopes of stopping the wildlife capturing before it happens. Tailoring a program created in Ohio to regional customs and regulations is paramount and requires participation from locals.

A technical solution?

The same is true for tech solutions. Some research has found that residents don’t appreciate drones flying overhead, even if they’re surveilling for poachers.  In her own research, Gore has found apps aren’t universally adopted by everyone and Wi-Fi can be spotty. “I also do work in Madagascar where sometimes, you know, technology breaks, and then you don’t have anybody to fix it or the spare parts are used for other local problems,” she said. No matter how well-intentioned, she said, “if they’re not implemented in ways that are like locally responsive, and there’s not local buy-in, they’re not going to really go that far.”

Combating Wildlife Trafficking Institute, Durrell Wildlife Conservation Trust and Michigan State University

Apps like Wildlife Alert and WildScan help officials identify trafficked wildlife, and citizen-science apps like Instant Wild let anyone help ID species. But Gore is worried that data collected from disparate efforts isn’t going to be helpful unless it’s properly organized. “We need to make sure that these systems are compatible with each other,” she said, adding, “One of the challenges with the conservation community faces is that we’re not really that good at sharing data.”

This is something the UNODC discovered when assembling its 2016 World Wildlife Crime Report. Some illegal rosewood seizures were listed by weight, volume, log count, or number of containers. “We don’t collect data in the same format, which means that even if we want to share data, sometimes we can’t because it’s like comparing apples with zebras,” said Gore. Another concern of conservation criminology is ethnically gathering such data. If the information were to fall into the wrong hands, someone who reported trafficking might be put in danger.

Combating Wildlife Trafficking Institute, Durrell Wildlife Conservation Trust and Michigan State University

Yet the data, if properly collected and shared, could disrupt some of these networks, Gore said. For example, she’s been working on Women in Wildlife Trafficking Survey. It’s an area that hasn’t been thoroughly researched, she said, even though “we’re 50% of the problem, we’re 50% of the solution.” Using a literature review, key informant interviews, and a quantitative survey, Gore and her fellow researchers hope to learn more about women who participate, prevent, and observe wildlife trafficking.”One of the things that we’re finding, you know, in some of our work is that in some instances, women and men do things very differently,” she said. “And then, here’s a scientific shocker, sometimes women and men do things the same.” At least in one instance, it’s proven valuable to study offenders by gender. In one Central African country she doesn’t want to name, Gore found that women and men use different modes of transportation to traffic certain wildlife products. “That’s interesting,” she said, “because if you’re only going to target trains as your transport method, you could be potentially missing out on a huge transport route.”

While that could certainly help local authorities, it’s not Gore’s ideal outcome. She’d prefer to get to people before they commit the crime. With the right data sharing, governmental and organizational cooperation, and local participation, she’s optimistic that can start to happen. “It’s a massive amount of resources going into combating wildlife crime,” she said. “So you want to make those resources count.”

Jenny McGrath
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Jenny McGrath is a senior writer at Digital Trends covering the intersection of tech and the arts and the environment. Before…
ChatGPT’s awesome Deep Research gets a light version and goes free for all
Deep Research option for ChatGPT.

There’s a lot of AI hype floating around, and it seems every brand wants to cram it into their products. But there are a few remarkably useful tools, as well, though they are pretty expensive. ChatGPT’s Deep Research is one such feature, and it seems OpenAI is finally feeling a bit generous about it. 

The company has created a lightweight version of Deep Research that is powered by its new o4-mini language model. OpenAI says this variant is “more cost-efficient while preserving high quality.” More importantly, it is available to use for free without any subscription caveat. 

Read more
Star Wars legend Ian McDiarmid gets questions about the Emperor’s sex life
Ian McDiarmid as the Emperor in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker.

This weekend, the Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith 20th anniversary re-release had a much stronger performance than expected with $25 million and a second-place finish behind Sinners. Revenge of the Sith was the culmination of plans by Chancellor Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid) that led to the fall of the Jedi and his own ascension to emperor. Because McDiarmid's Emperor died in his first appearance -- 1983's Return of the Jedi -- Revenge of the Sith was supposed to be his live-action swan song. However, Palpatine's return in Star Wars: Episode IX -- The Rise of Skywalker left McDiarmid being asked questions about his character's comeback, particularly about his sex life and how he could have a granddaughter.

While speaking with Variety, McDiarmid noted that fans have asked him "slightly embarrassing questions" about Palpatine including "'Does this evil monster ever have sex?'"

Read more
Waymo and Toyota explore personally owned self-driving cars
Front three quarter view of the 2023 Toyota bZ4X.

Waymo and Toyota have announced they’re exploring a strategic collaboration—and one of the most exciting possibilities on the table is bringing fully-automated driving technology to personally owned vehicles.
Alphabet-owned Waymo has made its name with its robotaxi service, the only one currently operating in the U.S. Its vehicles, including Jaguars and Hyundai Ioniq 5s, have logged tens of millions of autonomous miles on the streets of San Francisco, Los Angeles, Phoenix, and Austin.
But shifting to personally owned self-driving cars is a much more complex challenge.
While safety regulations are expected to loosen under the Trump administration, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has so far taken a cautious approach to the deployment of fully autonomous vehicles. General Motors-backed Cruise robotaxi was forced to suspend operations in 2023 following a fatal collision.
While the partnership with Toyota is still in the early stages, Waymo says it will initially study how to merge its autonomous systems with the Japanese automaker’s consumer vehicle platforms.
In a recent call with analysts, Alphabet CEO Sundar Pichai signaled that Waymo is seriously considering expanding beyond ride-hailing fleets and into personal ownership. While nothing is confirmed, the partnership with Toyota adds credibility—and manufacturing muscle—to that vision.
Toyota brings decades of safety innovation to the table, including its widely adopted Toyota Safety Sense technology. Through its software division, Woven by Toyota, the company is also pushing into next-generation vehicle platforms. With Waymo, Toyota is now also looking at how automation can evolve beyond assisted driving and into full autonomy for individual drivers.
This move also turns up the heat on Tesla, which has long promised fully self-driving vehicles for consumers. While Tesla continues to refine its Full Self-Driving (FSD) software, it remains supervised and hasn’t yet delivered on full autonomy. CEO Elon Musk is promising to launch some of its first robotaxis in Austin in June.
When it comes to self-driving cars, Waymo and Tesla are taking very different roads. Tesla aims to deliver affordability and scale with its camera, AI-based software. Waymo, by contrast, uses a more expensive technology relying on pre-mapped roads, sensors, cameras, radar and lidar (a laser-light radar), that regulators have been quicker to trust.

Read more