Skip to main content

Researchers wreck hundreds of drones in the name of safety

NTU researchers test damage from drones on dummy heads
If Amazon ever gets its way and fills the skies with thousands of delivery drones, the worst thing that can happen to us folks on the ground is for one of them to lose control and fall on our head.

The potential for accidents goes some way to explaining why the Federal Aviation Administration has been proceeding so cautiously when it comes to loosening regulations for businesses and organizations keen to make use of drone technology.

And that’s exactly why researchers are hard at work looking into the effects of drone crashes and how drone design can be improved to lessen the effects of any unfortunate impact.

A team at Singapore’s Nanyang Technological University (NTU), for example, has recently been willfully destroying hundreds of quadcopters in the name of research, smashing them at speed into the head of a crash test dummy, the Straits Times reported.

In a video that’s likely to provoke a wince or two, we first see a medium-sized drone dropped from the side of a building before scoring a direct hit on the dummy’s head. It makes a mess of the drone but more importantly, if the dummy was a real person, they’d be walking away with much more than just a headache. If they were able to walk away at all, that is.

Next up is the “side impact” demonstration. This imagines a low-flying drone traveling at great speed before hitting someone, again in the head. The video gives you an idea of the kind of impact that could result, and confirms what you probably already knew: Having a drone career into your head is never going to end well.

Led by Professor Low Kin Huat from NTU’s School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, the 10-person team has so far wrecked nearly 600 drones in the name of research, using machines weighing between 2.2 pounds (1 kg) and 19.8 pounds (9 kg). To give that some context, DJI’s Phantom 4 Pro weighs 3.1 pounds (1.4 kg), while the Inspire 2 tips the scales at 7.25 pounds (3.3 kg).

Data from the research will help government agencies make more informed decisions about drone regulations and offer drone makers pointers toward how they might improve the design of their machines for better safety.

With companies like Amazon keen to make drone deliveries in busy urban areas, the safety challenge is huge. The online shopping company was recently granted a patent describing how a drone could essentially self-destruct in midair should it get into difficulties, ensuring that its components come down over a wide area rather than crashing to the ground as a single, heavy unit.

The NTU team said another solution would be to carefully map routes that take drones away from pedestrianized areas, such as over the tops of buildings and covered walkways.

Similar research is being carried out at Virginia Tech, where researchers have suggested drone features such as “bumpers, enclosed rotors, and airbags” to help reduce the risk of injury in the event of a collision. But such components would have to be very light to avoid compromising the drone’s performance.

Editors' Recommendations

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
Once again, a drone has reportedly caused a shutdown at a major airport
Biggest airplanes in the world

A drone reportedly came within 30 feet of an aircraft close to New Jersey's Newark Liberty International Airport early Tuesday evening, January 22, forcing the airport's operator to suspend flights for a short period.

Air traffic control audio obtained by ABC News has pilots describing what "looks like a drone" as the aircraft made its final approach. "Missed the drone by about 30 feet off our right wing," one of the pilots said in the recording.

Read more
Rogue drones prompt major airports to spend millions on protection
Biggest airplanes in the world

Reported sightings of at least two rogue drones flying close to the U.K.'s second busiest airport in December 2018 caused an unprecedented level of disruption at one of the most hectic times of the year for air traffic control.

Safety concerns at Gatwick airport in southern England on December 20 meant that no planes were allowed to take off, with all inbound flights diverted to airports in cities across the U.K. and northern Europe.

Read more
This intelligent parachute system can bail out clumsy drone pilots
drone parachute rescue system

Drone technology has advanced markedly in the last few years, with improved stability and handling making them easier than ever to fly.

But whether through mechanical malfunction or sheer pilot incompetence, there will always be occasions when we're left watching helplessly as our crippled quadcopter plummets from the sky as if it was never meant to be up there in the first place.

Read more