Skip to main content

Seattle’s vote-by-phone system could be a game changer, but only if it’s secure

When King County, Washington, voters cast a ballot for King Conservation District Board of Supervisors this year, they’ll be able to do so by smartphone, if they wish. While the county, which includes the city of Seattle, has about 1.2 million voters, in the past only between 1 and 3 percent usually participate in these types of elections. Supporters of the move are hoping it will empower more people to vote, but critics worry about the security of such a system.

By inputting their name and birthday via their phone’s internet browser, King County voters can log in to the portal. They choose and verify their candidate, then use their phone’s touchscreen to submit their signature.

Washington is a vote-by-mail state, which uses signature verification for its paper ballots. The signature verification by phone would work much the same way. Because so many residents send their ballots through the mail or via dropbox, a fair amount are rejected because the signatures don’t match those on record. Not everyone signs their name the same way that they did on their voter registration card. Signing via touchscreen might make scrawls even less likely to look the same.

bizoon / 123RF Stock Photo

Tusk Philanthropy, a nonprofit that wants to expand mobile voting, is funding the pilot. In 2018 and 2019, it helped West Virginia, Denver, and Utah run similar vote-by-phone programs. These were mainly focused on smaller communities, like deployed members of the military. Several states already allow some overseas citizens to vote by mail or fax.

Still, turnout tends to be smaller than the general population and harder to count. The West Virginia election was statewide and had 999 different ballot styles, Sheila Nix, president of Tusk Philanthropy, told Digital Trends. “So, those elections were actually — even though there were fewer people — they were more complicated,” she said.

For the past pilots, Tusk Philanthropy worked with Voatz, a technology company that created a voting app. Nix said an independent firm, ShiftState Security, audited Voatz technology, but Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Oregon) has noted that Voatz hasn’t published the results. A number of technology professionals have expressed concern over Voatz’s app and voting by phone in general. Democracy Live, a Seattle-based voting company, created the technology for the King County election, and Nix said ShiftState audited that company as well.

In addition, the National Cybersecurity Center will conduct a post-vote review, comparing a paper record of votes against digital receipts sent to voters and the anonymized blockchain records. However, Dr. Duncan Buell, a computer science professor at the University of South Carolina, told NPR that such a review may merely be double-checking votes that were already altered as the result of a cyberattack.

Nix said she realizes that not everyone will be comfortable using the new technology to vote. “It’s not intended, in the short term, to be a substitute for anything,” she said. But people with visual impairments may prefer to use their phones’ accessibility features to vote privately. Tusk Philanthropy is planning on funding twice as many pilots this year as in 2019, with a goal of between 35 and 50 in the next five years — just in time for current, digital-native 14-year-olds to participate.

Editors' Recommendations

Jenny McGrath
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Jenny McGrath is a senior writer at Digital Trends covering the intersection of tech and the arts and the environment. Before…
Apple’s A17 chip could have a huge 3nm upgrade, but only for some iPhones
Camera array of the iPhone 14 Pro

With the introduction of new smartphones at the Far Out event earlier this month, Apple set the stage for a nasty surprise. The company kept the next-generation A16 Bionic processor limited to the pricier iPhone 14 Pro models, while the vanilla iPhone 14 was restricted to the same A15 Bionic chip as the iPhone 13 quartet. If you felt stung by the controversial product decision, there’s more bad news.

According to Nikkei Asia, Apple has locked TSMC’s upgraded 3nm fabrication technology for designing the next-gen A17 Bionic. Work on the next-gen A-series processor has already begun at Apple, but once again, the upgraded smartphone chip will be limited to only the Pro models in the iPhone 15 series that will debut a year from now.

Read more
You need to update your iPhone and iPad right now to fix a critical security flaw
iOS's App Library page shown on an iPhone 13 Pro.

This is a friendly -- and important -- reminder to update your iPhone and iPad, if you haven’t already.

Apple this week issued an urgent security update for iPhone and iPad owners to patch a flaw that could allow hackers to take control of the devices.

Read more
How Apple’s tight ecosystem of products can undermine its own security
Person accessing a state ID using their Apple Watch.

There’s an old belief that you can’t have both security and convenience, and that’s seen as especially true in your digital life. I’m sure Apple would dispute that assertion, pointing to things like Face ID as evidence it can do both.

Yet, as we've seen in recent months, there are actually times when Apple’s ecosystem, so tightly linked across its platforms, can actually undermine its own security. If your dwelling only has one locked door, it only takes one key to have access to the whole house.
Face ID, the iPhone, and the Apple Watch

Read more