Skip to main content

Apple removes Civil War games from App Store for showing the Confederate flag [updated]

apple confederate flag apps ultimate general
Ultimate General: Gettysburg / Game Labs
Updated by Will Fulton on 6-26-2015: Apple released a statement to TechCrunch saying that it did not intend to remove historical or educational apps, and they are working with developers to restore them shortly:

“We have removed apps from the App Store that use the Confederate flag in offensive or mean-spirited ways, which is in violation of our guidelines. We are not removing apps that display the Confederate flag for educational or historical uses.”

The games mentioned below will be restored, while other apps like Confederate flag wallpaper will remain absent. This is obviously good news, but Apple’s reactionary and indiscriminate use of the banhammer remains troubling, however quickly it responded to the collective chastisement of the Internet.

Original Story: In the wake of last week’s horrific shooting at a black church in Charleston, South Carolina, much of the public outrage has fixated on public displays of the Confederate battle flag, a historically loaded symbol that shooter Dylann Roof was shown to frequently embrace in pictures that emerged after the attack. Major retailers such as Walmart, Amazon, and Sears have publicly pulled any items displaying the notorious “stars and bars” from their stores as a sign of solidarity with people that see it as a symbol of violent white supremacy. Apple has now joined the charge by removing any and all apps that contain images of the flag from the App Store.

The App Store purge follows a recent tweet from Apple CEO Tim Cook, criticizing the flag and calling for its suppression:

My thoughts are with the victim's families in SC.Let us honor their lives by eradicating racism & removing the symbols & words that feed it.

— Tim Cook (@tim_cook) June 21, 2015

The developers of Civil War strategy games, however, are understandably irked that their products are being pulled regardless of the historically accurate context in which the flag is used. Touch Arcade reports that games like Ultimate General: Gettysburg and multiple Civil War games from developer Hunted Cow were pulled down for displaying “images of the confederate flag used in offensive and mean-spirited ways.”

Ultimate General developer Game Labs expressed its disappointment in a statement to Touch Arcade, pointing out its earnest commitment to sharing and exploring history, rather than a racist agenda, as its reason for including the flag in the game:

“We receive a lot of letters of gratitude from American teachers who use our game in history curriculum to let kids experience one of the most important battles in American history from the commander’s perspective. Spielberg’s Schindler’s List did not try to amend his movie to look more comfortable. The historical Gettysburg movie (1993) is still on iTunes. We believe that all historical art forms: books, movies, or games such as ours, help to learn and understand history, depicting events as they were. True stories are more important to us than money.”

That second point, implying a degree of hypocrisy in still selling other artistic media that contain the flag, gets at an underlying assumption in Apple’s decision: Games are not art.

This is not the first instance of Apple taking a less-than-nuanced approach to censoring games in the App Store. Hunted Cow’s Tank Battle 1942 was initially rejected from the App Store for referring to Russian and German soldiers in the game as “enemies.” More recently, Lucas Pope’s fantastic indie bureaucracy simulator Papers, Please was rejected for its distinctly nonsexual, highly pixelated nudity being too pornographic. Both of these games were eventually approved, but are indicative of Apple’s conservative and reactionary approach to games. By the same logic, World War II games should be pulled down as well for including equally-hateful Nazi symbolism. All manner of sex, violence, and historically uncomfortable subject matter are found in books and movies that can be purchased just as easily on iTunes, but games — long considered the domain of children — are held to a stricter set of standards.

Editors' Recommendations

Will Fulton
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Will Fulton is a New York-based writer and theater-maker. In 2011 he co-founded mythic theater company AntiMatter Collective…
U.K. agency says Apple and Google are stifling user choice in their app stores
App store icon showing three notifications.

Apple and Google's mobile platforms have faced a maelstrom of criticism regarding their respective app store and operating system rules, and the U.K.'s Competition and Market Authority (CMA) is adding to that cacophony of voices. After the result of a probe this year, the CMA concluded that the mobile duopoly is leading to "less competition and meaningful choice" for customers.

The CMA highlighted a few incidents of concern. Apple famously not allowing Microsoft's xCloud game streaming app into the App Store merited a mention, as did Google's deals with smartphone makers to include Chrome and other Google apps in exchange for access to the Google Play Store and Google Play Services.

Read more
Apple’s first attempt to delay third-party app store payments fails in court
App store icon showing three notifications.

Apple will have to allow third-party developers the ability to link outside the App Store pretty soon. After appealing the ruling in the Epic case that said it had to allow for third-party links and buttons in App Store apps and requesting a denial, the company was met with a refusal by a federal court in Oakland.

By its telling, Apple's motion for a stay was based on a need to protect its customers and developers by building new policies to accommodate the new state of play and remove the prohibition on anti-steering it had enshrined.

Read more
Epic v. Apple case shows just how much of the App Store’s money comes from games
App store icon showing three notifications.

Over the course of the Epic v. Apple case, much has come to light about how both companies generate profit. One of the biggest shocks comes from the closing ruling of the case, which reveals that 70% of the App Store's money comes from games.

This lawsuit was brought by Epic Games in August 2020. The general gist of the case is that Epic added a payment system to Fortnite mobile that allowed players to avoid an extra 30% fee usually applied to App Store purchases, which goes to Apple. In response to the workaround, Apple removed Fortnite from its marketplace, which prompted Epic to take the matter to court.

Read more