Digital Trends’ 2013 game of the year nominees

The end of the year is a time for reflection. We put bookends at the front of January and end of December, then begin the inevitable process of sorting through everything in between to sift out the best. It’s human nature, and we here at Digital Trends embrace it.

For the last few years we have our winners and nominees for the best games of the year in an assortment of categories, generally focusing on the best of each genre. This year though, we tried something a bit different. The lines between genres blurs more and more each year, which makes some of the assignments of where a game “belongs” almost arbitrary. That’s only going to get worse, as phrases like “massively multiplayer online” lose all meaning, since they may soon describe the bulk of the games coming on PC and through the next-gen consoles.

Instead, we looked at what it was about the games we liked this year, and broke it down by categories. Selecting some of these nominees were more difficult than others, as were some of the omissions.

We also tried to take “bigger picture” factors into account, so – just for example – if a game had major issues with the online, and those issues are still ongoing, it is not one of the best games of the year. It may have the potential to be, and it may outstrip other nominees, but we can only deal with games as they are right now. There will no doubt be disagreement, and we encourage that. If you think a game should be on the list but wasn’t, make you case in the comments below (respectfully).

Check back on Sunday, December 22 for a list of the winners.

PC Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: "Antichamber"
PC Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: “Antichamber”

Best Action

This category isn’t quite the same as best “action game,” which typically refers to the action/adventure genre. Instead, these nominees are the games that feature the best simulated action. You could also call this category “Best combat,” but that wouldn’t be entirely accurate either. They are the games that got us to grip our controller tightly and lean forward towards our TV/monitor, oblivious to the world around.

BioShock Infinite

Grand Theft Auto 5 

Tomb Raider

Best Small Studio Game, Best Mechanics and Game of the Year Nominee: "Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons"
Best Small Studio Game, Best Mechanics and Game of the Year Nominee: “Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons”

Best Art

This was one of the most difficult and varied categories to nail down, because there were so many games this year that helped bolster the fact that games are, in fact, art. For this category though, we specifically looked at the art in terms of the artwork, the design. Graphics are improving to the point that photo-realism is just around the corner, but that will always be trumped by art that can move you, awe, you, and make you take a moment to stop playing and just appreciate what you’re seeing.

Antichamber

BioShock Infinite

Puppeteer

Best Xbox Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: "Dead Rising 3"
Best Xbox Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: “Dead Rising 3”

Best DLC 

Not to be confused with best downloadable games, a category that is increasingly hard to define, these are the additional content DLCs that truly impressed us. Each of these picks is a supplement to another game, but in each instance it actually made the game better as a result.

Borderlands 2: Tiny Tina’s Assault on Dragon Keep

Dishonored: The Brigmore Witches

Walking Dead: 400 Days

Best Real Life Simulator and Xbox Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: "Forza Motorsport 5"
Best Real Life Simulator and Xbox Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: “Forza Motorsport 5”

Best Small Studio Game 

This category was originally called “Best Indie Game,” but that doesn’t carry as much meaning as it used to. Studios are self-publishing more and more, and the line between what we used to define as an independent studio and a more traditional development team continues to blur. That will only continue in the future, making the designation “indie” harder to pin down. So instead we decided to honor the spirit of the award and nominate outstanding games developed outside of the traditional system, and created by a handful of people.

Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons

Gone Home

The Stanley Parable 

Best Small Studio Game, Best PC Game, Best Writing and Game of the Year Nominee: "Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons"
Best Small Studio Game, Best PC Game, Best Writing and Game of the Year Nominee: “Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons”

Best Mechanics

This category is a vital one for gaming. Good mechanics are almost taken for granted these days. If a game fails on this front, it fails completely. The games in this category though go beyond just being polished though, they help us to consider new ways to play.

Antichamber

Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons

Device 6 

Best Action Game, Best Online Game and Game of the Year Nominee: "Grand Theft Auto 5"
Best Action Game, Best Online Game and Game of the Year Nominee: “Grand Theft Auto 5”

Best Online game 

This category exists to honor the games that really went above and beyond when it came to existing in the online space. This category was open for everything from competitive shooters to racing games, but these games stood as the richest online experiences.

Dota 2

GTA Online

Payday 2

Best Handheld Game Nominee: "Guacamelee"
Best Handheld Game Nominee: “Guacamelee”

Best Re-release 

With new technology comes new ways to breathe life into older, previously released game. The games in this category all had strong foundations to build on, but they were made even better, or at least offered a new experience thanks to their re-release.

Baldur’s Gate: Enhanced Edition

Hotline: Miami

Knights of the Old Republic

Best Writing. Most Thought Provoking and Sony Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: "The Last of Us"
Best Writing. Most Thought Provoking and Sony Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: “The Last of Us”

Best Real Life Simulator

While most games offer a fantastic and heavily dramatized look at some aspect of life that could never really happen, this category is for the games that simulate real world things, including sports and racing simulations. It may not be realistic for the average gamer to be able to dunk on LeBron James, but it’s more realistic than fighting aliens.

FIFA 14

Forza 5

NBA 2K14 

Best Handheld Game, Best Nintendo Exclusive and Game of the Year Nominee: "The Legend of Zelda: Link Between Worlds"
Best Handheld Game, Best Nintendo Exclusive and Game of the Year Nominee: “The Legend of Zelda: Link Between Worlds”

Best Team Game 

People like to play games with their friends. That bombshell revelation should come as no surprise to anyone that has ever gamed, and more and more developers are moving away from the well-trodden competitive multiplayer fields in favor of a slightly more social experience. The games in these categories all offer the best co-op play around, creating a mixture of objectives, action, teamwork, and maybe even a hint of good natured competition.

Diablo III (console)

GTA Online

Payday 2

Best Nintendo Exclusive Game Nominee: "Pikmin 3"
Best Nintendo Exclusive Game Nominee: “Pikmin 3”

Best Writing

As the gaming industry continues to mature, so too do the stories told using the games as a medium. This year continued to feature more and more sophisticated stories, so much so that this was a very difficult category to select. It isn’t just the general plot either, it’s the dialogue, the tone, even the atmosphere. The medium is growing up, and the writing plays a big part of that.

Beyond: Two Souls

Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon

Gone Home 

Best Art and Best Sony Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: "Puppeteer"
Best Art and Best Sony Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: “Puppeteer”

Most Thought Provoking

The games in this category all have an aspect or a twist that went beyond the frequently narrow confines of entertainment, and offered something that stayed with us. It shocked us in the best way possible, and sent us running to talk to our friends that had experienced it online and off. It’s difficult to go into more detail about this category without giving specifics, and therefore spoiling the very thing we loved, but if you played the nominees, you probably know exactly why these games were nominated.

BioShock Infinite

The Last of Us

The Stanley Parable

Xbox Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: "Ryse: Son of Rome"
Xbox Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: “Ryse: Son of Rome”

Best Handheld

The handheld systems were responsible for some exceptional games this year, and that is a trend that is likely to continue. The 3DS and PS Vita are getting stronger and stronger, and this year proved that. The nominees are for the best handheld game, but they could just as easily be for the best game, period.

Guacamelee

The Legend of Zelda: Link Between Worlds

Tearaway

Best Small Studio Game, Most Thought Provoking and Game of the Year Nominee:"The Stanley Parable"
Best Small Studio Game, Most Thought Provoking and Game of the Year Nominee:”The Stanley Parable”

Best PC Game

Although the consoles are stealing all the headlines this year, the PC exclusive market had several excellent titles. Nothing new in that. Here are our choices for the best of the year.

Antichamber

Gone Home

Total War: Rome II

Best Nintendo Exclusive Game: "Super Mario 3D World"
Best Nintendo Exclusive Game: “Super Mario 3D World”

Best Sony Exclusive

The exclusive launch games for the PlayStation 4 may not have blown the gaming world away, but Sony still had an incredibly strong year when it came to exclusive titles – and not just on the PS3. It was a big year for Sony on all fronts, and much of that was fueled by exclusives.

The Last of Us

Puppeteer

Tearaway

Best Handheld Game and Sony Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: "Tearaway"
Best Handheld Game and Sony Exclusive Game of the Year Nominee: “Tearaway”

Best Xbox Exclusive 

The battle of the next-gen systems has barely begun, but when it comes to next-gen launch titles, Microsoft came out swinging. For the launch of the Xbox One, Microsoft released more exclusive games than it had throughout the rest of the year. Thankfully for gamers, they were all solid titles.

Dead Rising 3

Forza Motorsport 5

Ryse: Son of Rome 

Best PC Game Nominee: "Total War: Rome II"
Best PC Game Nominee: “Total War: Rome II”

Best Nintendo Exclusive 

One of the problems with Nintendo recently is a lack of software, especially when it comes to the Wii U. But when it does release a game, Nintendo doesn’t mess around. There may not have been a ton of Nintendo titles released this year, but there were some very good ones.

The Legend of Zelda: Link Between Worlds

Pikmin 3

Super Mario 3D World 

Game of the Year

And finally we come to the Game of the Year. The nominees this year all offered something a little different, something a little more than their counterparts. Some of the games on this list may not be the most graphically impressive or have the best audio. They may not redefine gaming mechanics. But they all offered something new and unique, and they all surpassed all expectations. These are the best of the best, and they remind us why 2013 was a great year for gaming.

Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons

Gone Home

Grand Theft Auto 5

The Legend of Zelda: Link Between Worlds

The Stanley Parable  

Deals

Walmart drops prices on Apple Watches and other fitness trackers

Smartwatches, fitness trackers, and wearable heart rate monitors from Apple, Samsung, Fitbit, and Garmin are popular gifts. Wearables are smarter and more capable than in earlier years. We found the best wearables deals on Walmart.
Deals

The Super NES Classic is the perfect holiday gift for Nintendo lovers

Whether you're a long-time Nintendo fan looking to relive the 16-bit glory days or just doing some holiday shopping, the SNES Classic -- now in stock at multiple retailers for $80 -- might just be the perfect Christmas gift for gamers of…
Deals

The NES Classic is back in stock just in time for the holidays

The NES Classic is back in stock at multiple outlets at its original launch price of $60 in time for Christmas. Retailers offering it online are Walmart, GameStop, Target, and Best Buy -- if you're looking for the perfect holiday gift for…
Deals

Save big on these Braun electric razors and women’s epilators

Amazon and Walmart are currently offering limited-time deals for Braun electric razors and women's epilators. If you plan to make your way through all the festive parties this year with fresh smooth these tools will help.
Gaming

Fancy ‘Kingdom Hearts III’ PlayStation 4 Pro launches alongside game in January

A limited edition PlayStation 4 Pro bundle for Kingdom Hearts III will launch alongside the game in January. The system included has a special design on the side, as does the controller.
Gaming

Want to share your Xbox One games? Here's how to do it

Sharing games on modern consoles is possible, but it takes a few steps. Here's how to start sharing games on your Xbox One console, so friends and family can easily access your library.
Gaming

‘Fortnite’ removes the Infinity Blade weapon after player backlash

Following player backlash over the Infinity Blade weapon's inclusion in Fortnite's battle royale mode, Epic Games decided to remove the weapon from the game completely. It was not limited to a special mode.
Gaming

Here's where Xur is and what he has for wares this week in 'Destiny 2: Forsaken'

The weekly vendor in Destiny 2: Forsaken always brings Exotic weapons and armor, some of the toughest loot to find in the game. Here's everything you need to know to track down Xur: Where he is, when he shows up, and what he's stocking.
Gaming

Want every suit in 'Marvel's Spider-Man' for PS4? Here's how to get them all

Marvel's Spider-Man features a whopping 33 different suits for Peter Parker to wear as he swings across New York City knocking out baddies. Here are all the suits and how to unlock them.
Gaming

Everything about 'Red Dead Online', including its new microtransaction store

Red Dead Online will gradually rolled out to Red Dead Redemption 2 players via a beta. We've got all the details about the beta's suite of competitive and cooperative modes, as well as what to expect going forward.
Computing

HDR monitors are beginning to have an impact. Here are the best you can buy

HDR isn't the most common of PC monitor features and is often charged at a premium, but the list of available options is growing. These are the best HDR monitors you can buy right now.
Virtual Reality

Oculus Rift vs. HTC Vive: Prices drop, but our favorite stays the same

The Oculus Rift and HTC Vive are the two big names in the virtual reality arena, but most people can only afford one. Our comparison tells you which is best when you pit the Oculus Rift vs. HTC Vive.
Gaming

Xbox One X vs. PS4 Pro: Which console is more powerful?

Far from cooling down, the console wars are only getting more intense. We compare Microsoft's Xbox One X to Sony's PlayStation 4 Pro to help you decide which premium console is right for you.
Gaming

Find the perfect weapon in 'Call of Duty: Black Ops 4' multiplayer with our guide

Call of Duty: Black Ops 4 has several different guns to choose from in its multiplayer mode, and they're split across multiple classes. Here's a guide to all of them and when you should use them.