Skip to main content

The PS5 and Xbox Series X still haven’t convinced me to ditch my Switch

It’s been a strange year for consoles. Despite the popularity of the PlayStation 5 and the Xbox Series X, both of which had their first anniversaries this week, few consumers have been able to get their hands on one thanks to chip shortages and manufacturing delays caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. Despite talk of the exclusive, high-tech features like ray-tracing that these consoles can deliver, developers and publishers have been forced to publish their games on both PS5/Series X and the last-generation PS4 and Xbox One in order to reach a larger audience. Despite both of these consoles being a year old, some are still referring to the PS5 and the Series X as “next-gen,” and there are very few true exclusives for either platform.

In the middle of all this mayhem sits the Nintendo Switch, a four-year-old console that’s still going strong despite its age. The Switch was also caught up in manufacturing delays and chip shortages, but because it has been on the market longer, the delays didn’t make quite as much of a splash.

Even as the PS5 and the Series X are slowly becoming more readily available, I don’t have much interest in investing in one yet. Why? My Switch has just about everything I need.

Prize-winning exclusives

A little bit of a disclaimer: I was a Nintendo kid growing up.

I spent a decade of childhood on the GameCube and the Wii before I got my hands on a PlayStation 2, my first non-Nintendo console. Back in those days, one of the major complaints about the Big N’s platforms was that they didn’t have the biggest third-party titles on them. You couldn’t play Call of Duty on a Nintendo system, for example, at least not until Black Ops came to the Wii. A lot of kids I grew up with had both the latest Nintendo console and either a PlayStation or Xbox equivalent so they could experience everything.

These days, Nintendo has gotten a lot better about giving major third-party games space on its consoles. You can now play big-name, non-Nintendo titles like Apex Legends on the Switch, if that’s your cup of tea. Nintendo is also experimenting with cloud gaming to bring modern games that normally couldn’t run on a Switch to the platform. While these games and shows might not look as good on the Switch as they do on more powerful consoles, Nintendo lifers have never come to the company for raw processing power. The PS5 and Xbox Series X unequivocally trounce the Switch in that area, but the gap isn’t as restrictive as it used to be.

Mario and Bowser in Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury.

The Switch’s incredibly strong library of exclusives, which includes the likes of Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury, Splatoon 2, and The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, have enough depth and variety to provide a strong experience for any kind of gamer. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, a repackaging of the Wii U title Mario Kart 8, recently outsold the next best-selling entry in the franchisedespite having been on the market since April 2017. More copies sold means more players playing online, which means a more robust and competitive online experience. Few other individual games can boast the longevity of Mario Kart 8.

A sunny disposition

Though it might be harder to back up with facts and figures, my Switch has simply kept me perfectly content during the dark days of the pandemic. Sometimes all I wanted during social lockdowns was something bright and happy to take my mind off of what was going on in the world just outside my door. That’s one of the reasons that Animal Crossing: New Horizons sold so well: People were hungry for joy. There are positive and wholesome games on all platforms, but it’s what Nintendo specializes in. When I’m using my Switch, I know that, with very few exceptions, I’m probably going to be playing something that’s colorful, funny, and engaging.

Animal Crossing player poses with their terraformed waterfall.

When I was stuck inside at the height of COVID-19, my Switch kept me moving, laughing, and looking up. Even after things opened back up, it was easier to take my Switch to someone’s house for a round of multiplayer than it was to lug another, more permanent console over. It’s something that no other console has been able to do yet for me. While the PS5 and the Series X have joyous experiences of their own, something about the Switch keeps me coming back again and again to discover what other charms lay hidden within its deep library.

Console choice isn’t arbitrary. Each platform’s marketing, exclusives, and non-gaming content (like streaming services) influence our investments. Historically, players tend to stay in one or two consoles’ ecosystem, rather than jumping around every generation if another had a better launch title or suite of streaming content. Since the Wii, Nintendo has made a conscious effort to make its consoles part of its fans’ lifestyles rather than just another black box that sits underneath the family TV. My Wii and Switch have always felt like members of the household — tools I would use to complete daily tasks, like working out in Ring Fit Adventure, alongside more purely gameplay-oriented experiences. I value the combination of breadth and depth when it comes to console possibilities, and the Switch has stood up in every way possible.

I may very well end up investing in a PS5 or Xbox Series X down the road. Each console has perks and high points that fans continue to sing the praises of. In the last several years I’ve been introduced to franchises that remain exclusive to those platforms, and one day I may decide that I want to experience Halo Infinite on an Xbox or Horizon Forbidden West on a PlayStation. Even so, I know that my Switch will continue to be my closest console companion, despite the flash and pizzazz of other options.

Editors' Recommendations

Emily Morrow
Emily Morrow is a games journalist and narrative designer who has written for a variety of online publications. If she’s…
This console generation isn’t about games or hardware. It’s about services
A character stands below a ship in Starfield.

It’s been over two years since the start of the current console generation, which launched with a rocky start at the end of 2020. You'd think it's been more than long enough to understand what it's all about, but for many, there's still confusion. That might be changing this year. As Tomas Franzese wrote earlier this month, 2023 could be the year where we finally see what games define this generation’s consoles, at least in terms of exclusives. He also noted that games could stop being cross-platform, launching on just current-gen consoles instead of simultaneously on last-gen ones.

While that'll finally give us some memorable games, it doesn't bring us closer to defining the hardware itself. Besides a few extra teraflops and new ultra-fast SSDs, there isn’t much that helps the PS5 and Xbox Series X and S stand out from their predecessors. Sure, the PS5 looks like a giant spaceship, and the Xbox Series X is built like a fridge, but we didn’t know what these devices could offer that the PS4 and Xbox One couldn’t besides some pretty lighting effects and virtually non-existent loading times.

Read more
PS5 and Xbox Series X need to show us what they’re capable of in 2023
Miles Morales and Peter Parker stand together in Spider-Man 2.

True current-gen console exclusives have been few and far between this generation. Over two years in, even great games like Halo Infinite and God of War: Ragnarök are still shackled to the consoles that came before the PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X and S. While they still look fantastic and benefit from better load times and DualSense gimmicks, there haven’t been enough exclusives to give this new console generation a true identity just yet.
That's going to be one of the most important tasks for Microsoft and Sony in 2023. This year, we'll see a much larger number of PS5 and Xbox Series X/S exclusives, especially from first-party studios. Games like Forspoken, Marvel’s Spider-Man 2, Forza Motorsport, and Starfield will be just some of the games this year that will demonstrate what exactly a ninth-generation console game feels and looks like. That means that the stakes are high for this year's biggest releases, as they need to prove that the games industry hasn't plateaued. 
A slow but steady start
It’s hard to believe we’re already over two years into this new console generation, considering that we're still seeing high-profile games launching on old platforms. That looks like it will change this year, though, as more games will release exclusively for PS5 and Xbox Series X/S to give those consoles more of an identity. Still, that’s taken more time than it did for the eighth generation of game consoles: the PS4 and Xbox One.
Even the Xbox One, for all its faults at release, had games like Dead Rising 3, Forza Motorsport 5, and Ryse: Son of Rome early on to show what Microsoft wanted that new generation of games to look like. They did so through both impressive visuals for their time and via Xbox One gimmicks like SmartGlass and Kinect. We haven’t seen that as much with the Xbox Series X/S because early-generation games like Halo Infinite and Forza Horizon 5 were intentionally cross-gen, and its more ambitious exclusives have suffered delays.
On the PlayStation front, the PS4 admittedly took a few years to get going on the exclusives front. Games like Infamous Second Son, Driveclub, and Bloodborne eventually impressed, though, and fantastic exclusives were consistently launching throughout each year by 2017. The PS5 is following a similar cadence, as Astro’s Playroom remains an outstanding PS5 and DualSense showcase, while Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart, Returnal, and The Last of Us Part 1 show what the system is capable of.

Still, last year’s two biggest PlayStation Studios releases, Horizon Forbidden West and God of War: Ragnarök, came out on PS4 and still felt "last-gen" as a result. One can’t help but think what both games could have done had they launched solely on PS5. That's a question I hope to see answered more firmly over the next 12 months.
The importance of 2023 console exclusives 
As we enter the PS5’s third year, its upcoming exclusives will be some of the most pivotal on the system. Forspoken could demonstrate some impressive visual effects early on, but Marvel’s Spider-Man 2 is in an even more crucial position. It will be the first sequel to a PS4-era hit that isn’t tied to the PS4. The PS5’s high frame rate and adaptive triggers already enhance Marvel’s Spider-Man: Miles Morales and Spider-Man: Remastered when played on PS5.
I’m intrigued to see how Insomniac Games can push the visuals further, make more parts of New York City explorable, and take swinging around as the Spider-Men even further on PS5. Hopefully, any other PS5 exclusives launching this year will do similar things.

Read more
The best live service games of 2022: 10 ongoing games we couldn’t stop playing
A Sea of Thieves skeleton sits in front of text that says 2022 Best Live Service Games.

Some games are meant to be played once, savored, and then shelved for the next one -- not unlike a book or a movie. But many other games are meant to be played and replayed over a long period of time, offering wildly different experiences each time you sit down and boot them up. There were many ongoing games to pick from in 2022, a lot of which include live service elements like online multiplayer, microtransactions, and regular content updates -- though not all are worth investing your time into.

Even though there are plenty of stinkers out there to avoid, there were also several ongoing games that kept our attention in 2022, ranging across several genres. From globe-trotting online roleplaying games to far simpler games you can play at a café bench, here are 10 games that set the bar for live service in 2022.

Read more