Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

Sony killed Linux on the PlayStation 3, and now it has to pay the price

sony settles over install other os ps3
Image used with permission by copyright holder
A settlement appears to be on the horizon thanks to a deal that was reached on Friday between Sony and lawyers representing millions of PlayStation 3 owners (PDF here, via Ars Technica). The agreement was made before Judge Yvonne Gonzalez in California’s Oakland courthouse, but still needs to be approved by a federal judge before Sony can hand out money to each PlayStation 3 owner. The proposed settlement will be viewed next month.

So what is Sony’s settlement all about? Glad you asked.

A long, long time ago in what now seems like an alternate universe, the Sony PlayStation 3 allowed the installation of a secondary operating system based on Linux or Unix. This function was listed as “Install Other OS” on the console’s XMB interface, and was ripped out with the introduction of the newer PS3 Slim model and firmware version 3.21. Many PlayStation 3 owners, both old and new customers alike, were not happy with the change, given that one of Sony’s major PlayStation 3 selling points became a defunct option.

The reason Sony provided for removing secondary OS support was due to “security reasons.” When the v3.21 firmware update went live, Patrick Seybold, senior director of corporate communications and social media, merely indicated that the feature was removed to make the PlayStation 3 platform more secure. Customers of the older system had a choice of not updating to the v3.21 firmware, but they would not have access to the PlayStation Network. They also wouldn’t be able to run software or play videos that required the latest firmware.

Sony saw a number of class-action lawsuits filed against the company over the “Other OS” issue starting in April 2010. These lawsuits were dismissed one after another by the beginning of December, 2011, because they failed to show how Sony would be liable. However, the last dismissal was reversed in January 2014 in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, and that particular lawsuit was returned to the district court.

And now here we are, years later, with a settlement finally on the way.

“Approximately 10 million units were sold in the United States and ranged in price from approximately $400 to $600,” the legal agreement states. ‘Throughout the pendency of the case, Defendant has vigorously denied liability. Among other things, Defendant has argued that it had the right to remove the Other OS pursuant to its terms of service and other purported agreements, and that the Other OS was not a functionality that was material to the vast majority of purchasers.”

However, according to the agreement, millions of North American customers will soon be eligible to submit a Claim Form to receive a $55 settlement, or a smaller $9 settlement. In order to get the larger sum, customers must show proof that they actually ran another operating system on the PlayStation 3. Otherwise, consumers will get $9 if they show in a valid claim that the console lost its value when Sony removed the Other OS function.

“There is no limit on the number of valid claims that Defendant is required to pay,” the document adds. “The Parties believe the terms of the Agreement are fair, reasonable and adequate, and that the Court should grant preliminary approval. Accordingly, Plaintiffs respectfully request that the Court grant this motion.”

A “notice program” will be launched to send out two rounds of emails to customers who are potential recipients of a settlement. Banner ads and search-related advertising related to the settlement will also be flashed on the likes of CNET, IGN, GameSpot, and other related sites. There will even be a “settlement website” that will play host to the settlement notice and “key documents.”

Finally, the agreement shows that Sony will shell out $3,500 for each plaintiff as recognition for their continued efforts to reach a settlement. These individuals paid to retain council, provided their PlayStation 3 consoles as evidence, and so on. Attorney’s fees and expense reimbursement will be an additional $2,250,000, which Sony will be required to pay.

The final approval hearing is scheduled to take place on November 8, 2016, the document shows.

Editors' Recommendations

Kevin Parrish
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Kevin started taking PCs apart in the 90s when Quake was on the way and his PC lacked the required components. Since then…
PlayStation Plus has lost 2 million subscribers since its revamp
PlayStation Plus logo.

PlayStation Plus has lost 2 million subscribers since Sony relaunched the game streaming service with a total makeover in June. According to the latest earnings report Sony released on Tuesday, the number of people subscribed to PS Plus fell from 47.3 million to 45.4 million in Q2 ending September 30, 2022.

Earlier this year, Sony rolled out a new version of PS Plus, which brought the online service more in line with Xbox Game Pass. It features a large library of games for users to access, including retro titles. The revamp has yet to see gains for Sony, though the company says the service now has the lowest number of monthly active users (MAUs) for PlayStation Network since 2020 at 102 million. That's a steady decrease from 104 million users last year and 103 million in the first quarter.

Read more
Sony forms PlayStation Mobile Division alongside Savage Game Studios acquisition
Savage game studios splash screen.

Sony is expanding into mobile gaming by acquiring mobile developer Savage Game Studios. As part of the move, Sony announced that it has established the PlayStation Mobile Division.

Sony has been slowly dipping its toes outside its normal comfort zone of console exclusives in recent years, primarily by porting its first-party titles to PC. The success of these titles has been such that the company even acquired a dedicated PC port studio, Nixxes Software, to push this initiative. While there have been a select few Sony games on mobile, such as the oft-forgotten Uncharted: Fortune Hunter, the company has otherwise been absent on the platform.

Read more
Sony has shipped over 117M PlayStation 4 systems, per final tally
playstation 4 final shipment numbers ps4

The final total of PlayStation 4 console shipments worldwide is now at about 117.2 million as of March this year.

Since then, Sony has stopped reporting the number of PS4 console shipments. Shipment numbers are different than the number of consoles actually sold, so there may be a discrepancy between the two.

Read more