Skip to main content

Wii U holds promise, but will developers deliver?

Image used with permission by copyright holder

I was in the audience yesterday as Nintendo unveiled its next home console, oddly monikered (but not as odd as “Project Cafe” and some other Internet speculation) “Wii U.” As it turns out, the rumor mill gave us a number of spot-on guesses as to the controller’s form and function, but I care more about what Nintendo plans to do with this new platform—what sorts of software I can expect.

The prevailing desire amongst the hardest of the “hardcore” was this concept that one could migrate their TV-game-in-progress to the Wii U’s controller and play it there. Nintendo led off with this concept with a presumed-sequel to New Super Mario Bros. Wii, showing a player happily relinquishing the TV to a family member and continuing to stomp Goombas on his own private screen. But it didn’t stop there; many other concepts were shown, including painting with a stylus, using the controller as a viewfinder to aim at the TV, providing a second view on the action, and several other things. Wii U provides a lot of options… so many that I wonder how well developers will be able to deliver on its promise.

Nintendo Wii U controller angle with stylis
Image used with permission by copyright holder

I think we can count on Nintendo to deliver games built around each of the concepts they’ve shown today, and others we haven’t thought about yet. But I’m afraid that the wealth of options and the different kind of development culture fostered in third party developers will result in games that don’t really take advantage of the Wii U, instead using its features as tack-on fodder. It’s a story that’s played out before, throughout the DS’ and Wii’s respective histories, and it makes for games that don’t live up to their potential because they aren’t designed with the Wii U in mind from day one.

Whether this actually proves to be a problem is up for debate. I can point to many games of both stripes–those that embrace the platform and those that ignoring or only slightly pay respect to it–that have been successful both critically and financially on Wii and DS, and I’ve certainly enjoyed titles of both stripes.

I’m also a little concerned about a design choice that we heard about during the presentation: the choice to apparently stream video to the controller in lieu of delivering it actual software, which seems to me, in conjunction with the lack of video clips illustrating more than one Wii U controller in use, to potentially limit the possibilities of Wii U—you may not be able to create a Four Swords Adventures on Wii U.

I’m cautiously optimistic about what Wii U will deliver here. It’s has some apparent limitations, both technological and—for lack of a better word—political, that may stymie its development. But I still think the idea is a great one, and I really look forward to what Nintendo—and hopefully others—may eventually deliver. I’m looking forward to heading to the show floor to try it out for myself; I’m hoping that using it—much like in 2006 when I played Wii Tennis on the show floor—will convince me that Wii U’s potential is not to be missed when it launches next year.

Matt Behrens
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Matt Behrens is a software developer based in Michigan, working on networked software on Unix and Linux. He was a longtime…
Nintendo confirms that it won’t be part of E3 2023
Pikmin and Bulborb in Pikmin 4.

Nintendo has confirmed reports that it won't be participating in E3 2023, meaning the gaming trade show will be missing one of its key vendors when it returns in-person this June.
"We approach our involvement in any event on a case-by-case basis and are always considering various ways to engage with our fans," a Nintendo spokesperson said in a statement to The Verge. "Since this year’s E3 show didn’t fit into our plans, we have made the decision to not participate. However, we have been and continue to be a strong supporter of the ESA [Entertainment Software Association] and E3."
After taking 2020 and 2022 off and being digital-only in 2021, this year was supposed to mark the grand return of E3, which was once a dominant game industry trade show that attracted every big video game company. Although Sony hasn't participated since 2019, it still came as a shock in January when IGN reported that both Nintendo and Microsoft would not be attending E3 this year as well. It appears that the report is true, as Microsoft has not confirmed any E3-related events outside of its independently run Xbox & Bethesda Games Showcase.
Nintendo skipping E3 2023 not only takes away a vendor that dominated the show floor in previous years, but also raises questions about whether or not the company will hold an exciting Nintendo Direct around then. While Nintendo typically holds a big showcase with lots of first-party game announcements around June every year, in 2022 it only held a third-party driven Partner Showcase in June. Now that we know it won't be at E3 2023, we're left to wonder when exactly then next big Nintendo Direct will be. 
E3 2023 will take place between June 13 and June 16, but don't expect Nintendo, Sony, or Microsoft to have a big presence there.

Read more
Here’s what E3 2023 could look like without Sony, Nintendo, and Microsoft
Playstation character wall at E3 2018

Let's start with the good news: E3 2023 will be held in its in-person format once again after three long years of digital events necessitated by the COVID-19 pandemic, this time with ReedPop at the helm. The bad news is that Sony, Xbox, and Nintendo -- gaming's "Big 3" -- may not show up at the industry’s biggest convention this summer.

This is according to a report from IGN citing multiple sources, who claimed the companies won’t be a part of the show or make appearances on the floor at the Los Angeles Convention Center in any way. Their absence from this year’s E3, especially Nintendo’s, may come as a shock to the gaming community, but it's not such a surprise when looking at the past few iterations of E3. Even before the pandemic locked everyone down in 2020, Sony and Xbox had been hosting their own E3-style livestreams, so it was more likely they would do it again this year anyway. Nintendo, on the other hand, managed to show off its upcoming games via Nintendo Direct streams and at its booth, console kiosks and all.

Read more
Nintendo’s Wii Shop Channel and DSi shops are back online
Nintendo 3DS close-up.

After months of service outages, Nintendo's Wii Shop Channel and DSi Shop are back online.

Nintendo's two virtual marketplace services went down in March of this year. In a statement to Kotaku on the outage, Nintendo acknowledged the downtime but had nothing to report other than that the shops were undergoing maintenance and that it would provide updates on them at a later date. It seems it completely skipped the update and simply put both back online instead.

Read more