Skip to main content

Why mobile devices spell certain death for the universal remote control

Universal Remote ClusterIf ever there was a piece of technology that promised so much, yet failed so miserably, it is the universal remote. Year after year we were introduced to newer, more advanced remotes, each touted as the device that would end the angst we had endured for ages. Instead, these devices inevitably presented a new set of problems, along with further confirmation that it wasn’t the equipment, but the approach that was flawed.

Unfortunately (animal lovers skip ahead a sentence), we all spent a lot of time beating a dead horse, but now that we’re well into the 21st century, can we please embrace some new ideas and leverage the kind of contemporary technology that has already proven it can make our lives easier? We’ll answer our own question: Yes. In fact, it has already started to happen. 

In a 2007 article penned for The Independent, Techno-Guru and Neul Ltd CTO William Webb opined that by 2025, your phone will have become a “remote control for your life,” and we couldn’t agree more. In the future, we see all remote controls being consolidated into one option. Starters for cars, openers for garage doors, and adjusters for thermostats have already been digitized and miniaturized; and more devices will soon follow. Companies like Logitech will likely lose business, while the mobile industry will pick up the slack, and dedicated devices everywhere will struggle to justify their existence. All the while more and more power will be funneled into the palms of your hands, into your precious, into the one remote to rule them all.

But before we start staring deeply into our crystal ball, let’s take a look back at how the universal remote as we have known it has failed us and subsequently dug its own grave. Any device this influential deserves a proper obituary, right?

The Da Vinci Codes

The programmable universal remote was born in 1987, the brainchild of Ch 9, a startup founded by Steve Wozniak. With electronic devices and the remotes associated with them starting to pile up in people’s homes, it was designed to be a streamlined solution to control and, though it was a solution, streamlined is a strong word.

Universal remotes are preparing to ship out to the island of misfit toys, leaving coffee tables empty, save a few cute books and maybe some actual cups of joe.

Whether you were a layman or a regular Robert Langdon, setting up a universal remote tested everyone’s patience. Some failed and threw the damn thing against the wall, some passed but fantasized about doing so, and some gave up and curled into the fetal position. That’s because programming these devices is  accomplished by sifting through a manual of access codes and inputting one for each piece of equipment you want to control. On its face, that doesn’t sound all that daunting, but the process is tedious at best and can quickly become maddening. Typically, the little red button on the remote blinks in various patterns to confirm different stages of the setup, but the convoluted operation almost never goes off without a hitch and is inelegant to say the least.

Still, while it’s tough to deny that these remotes have been infuriating, they’re also of some convenience once the hand-wringing and curse-muttering is concluded.  Because of that fact, the nuts and bolts of this original concept has persisted for over a decade. But then the Internet stepped in and delivered a whole new set of woes.

A (slightly) more harmonious alternative

Created in 2001, Logitech’s Harmony remote was one of the first devices of its kind to offer online set up and syncing. By interfacing with the Internet, Harmony made setup a  bit easier, and as the technology advanced, owners could update its configuration, upgrade its firmware, save IR commands to its memory systems , create macros and use it all via touchscreen. Since it only made you want to tear half of your hair out, Harmony soon became the preeminent universal remote, and the product proved to be a windfall for Logitech.

Logitech Harmony
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The device was a step in the direction, but it still felt like a distinctly 20th century solution. To this day we hear people complaining about how frustrating their universal remote is, or that their friends won’t use their equipment when they visit because they’re afraid to screw it up. Perhaps that’s part of the reason that 2013 marked the end of the industry’s seminal universal remote. After a devastating Q3 of 2012, in which Logitech saw its remote sales decrease by 24 percent year-on-year, the company divested itself of the division, a sign that the entire product category’s days may be numbered.

Obsolescence

These days, universal remotes are preparing to ship out to the island of misfit toys, leaving coffee tables empty, save a few cute books and maybe some actual cups of joe. In the years ahead, their purpose will be better served by another class of device, one that most Americans carry in their pockets and one that is extending its tentacles in thousands of different directions, wreaking havoc on specialists everywhere.

Anything you can do …

In the modern world, apps have supplanted dedicated devices. Why own five products with five different purposes when you could own one product with five million purposes? Connected mobile devices with app functionality have forced plenty of competitors into obsolescence and the universal remote will soon lie somewhere on that laundry list.

Since a quarter of American adults now own a tablet, and nearly half (45 percent) have a Smartphone in their pockets, smart devices are fast becoming the most convenient option for most electronic tasks. It used to be that controlling all of your home theater equipment via phone or tablet required peripherals and plug ins; products like Pee, Harmony Link, and the L5 remote paired an app with IR-emitting hardware and were – for a time – the best options for consumers. Then the industry had an idea: What if we put the IR blaster IN the mobile device? Boom.

Today, tablets like the Sony Tablet S and the Galaxy Tab 7.0 Plus, and phones like the HTC One and the Sony Xperia ZL don’t Galaxy S4 imageneed any expensive add-ons – just download an app and voila: instant remote. Even consoles are getting in on the fun. Nintendo Wii U’s new tablet controller offers app-based control of your home media, and Xbox’s next gen system is set to follow suit with a similar device. Best of all, however, is the new Galaxy S4‘s approach. The phone comes equipped with IR-emitters like many other products, but also includes an app. As soon as you pop open the box this baby is ready to boss your electronics around.

Though the market hasn’t had much time to respond yet, it’s pretty clear to us that phones, tablets, and other mobile devices are bound to become the standard for media control. They are cheaper (since we own them already) and more convenient than the dedicated alternative, plus they support additional functionality. These devices put social media, reviews, trailers, stills, fun facts, interactive program guides AND a remote in your hand. Your average universal remote just can’t compete with that kind of power, and as consumers are provided with more and more IR-equipped hardware, its days will finally be numbered. 

Editors' Recommendations

Adam Poltrack
Adam is an A/V News Writer for Digital Trends, and is responsible for bringing you the latest advances in A/V…
Tidal vs. Qobuz: Which hi-res music streaming service is for you?
Tidal app showing on iPhone 15 Pro.

Spotify and Apple Music may be the most popular music streaming services in the world, but services like Tidal and Qobuz offer plenty of great features and a higher level of listening to anyone making a switch. Each offers hi-res audio and is available on desktop and mobile devices. Thanks to a recent switch in Tidal subscriptions, the prices between the two services are now very comparable, although one is slightly cheaper.

Below, we compare Tidal and Qobuz based on price, sound quality, and supported devices to determine which platform is better.
Price
For many years, Tidal has stood out for its hi-res music offerings, a feature long shared with Qobuz. However, the landscape has changed, and now other services like Apple Music and Amazon Music (and soon Spotify, hopefully) have also ventured into the hi-res music space.

Read more
OTC hearing aid sale discounts 15 models, from just $80
Bose SoundControl Hearing Aids

If you need a hearing aid, you’re going to love the OTC hearing aid sale going on at Crutchfield right now. Currently, you can buy a pair for as little as just $80 with up to $500 to be saved on select models. With 15 models in the sale, we recommend you click the button below to see what’s on sale for yourself. But you can also read on while we highlight some of our favorite hearing aid deals. Don’t delay as the deals are unlikely to stick around for long.

What to shop for in the Crutchfield hearing aid sale
With some of the best OTC hearing aids including models from Lexie, go straight for the . It’s currently $799 instead of $849. It has a slim, visually discreet profile with a behind-the-ear fit style. A built-in feedback management system helps reduce high-pitched feedback while there’s a noise reduction circuit which decreases the volume of constant background sounds such as vacuum cleaners or A/C units. It also has level-dependent gain and compression which keeps loud noises from becoming too loud during conversations. The app also provides bass and treble controls along with left/right balance adjustments, and directional focus modes. It’s a really well-rounded hearing aid.

Read more
GoldenEar subwoofers are up to $755 off for a limited time
The GoldenEar SuperSub XXL subwoofer in the living room.

Upgrading your home theater setup's sound output is easily achieved by buying from soundbar deals, but if you want extra bass, you'll want to purchase a subwoofer. If you're thinking about it, you may want to checkout Crutchfield's sale on GoldenEar subwoofers with prices that start at $595. These premium subwoofers will give you all the bass that you need for watching streaming shows, epic movies, sports programs, and any other form of content, but you'll have to hurry with your decision on what to buy because these discounts are only available for a limited time.

What to buy in Crutchfield's GoldenEar subwoofers sale
The cheapest option in Crutchfield's GoldenEar subwoofers sale is still pretty powerful -- the GoldenEar ForceField 3, which is an 8-inch subwoofer with digital signal processing and a built-in 500-watt RMS digital amplifier. You'll also get a front-firing 8-inch long-throw woofer and a 9-inch by 11-inch down-firing passive radiator for , for savings of $55 on its original price of $650. You can also take a step up with the GoldenEar ForceField 30, which offers most of the same features but with an updated design with a curved top and metal grills, for instead of $900 following a $155 discount, or the GoldenEar ForceField 40 with a front-firing 10-inch long-throw woofer and an 11-inch by 13-inch down-firing passive radiator for a , down by $205 from $1,200 originally.

Read more