Tiny streaming sticks are striking it big, but should you really go small?

set top boxes vs streaming sticks which is right for you chromecast amazon fire tv stick roku
Next year, 25 percent of households will have some sort of streaming device in their home, according to analysts. With Apple, Roku, Google, and Amazon all making dedicated streaming devices, consumers have plenty of competitive devices to choose from. But before you settle on a brand, the bigger question might be form factor: streaming stick or set-top box?

Inexpensive, compact and dead simple, streaming sticks like the Google Chromecast, Roku Streaming Stick and now Amazon Fire TV offer a compelling argument for “smaller is better.” And consumers agree. Google sold 3.8 million Chromcasts in its first year alone, the same number of set-top boxes Roku sold in 2013.

But what do you sacrifice when you go small? To help you navigate, we compiled a list of pros and cons to the streaming HDMI stick in an effort to help you decide whether the new hotness in home theater is right for you, or if a traditional set-top box better fits the bill.

Pros

Tiny size, light weight

Streaming sticks are about the size and weight of a big pack of gum. With such a negligible footprint, they easily fit in your pocket, and go unnoticed in a backpack or suitcase. As such, you can take one anywhere, anytime,  whether it’s to a buddy’s place, the office, or a hotel. Sure you can haul around a set-top box, but then you’ll have to bring its power supply and a bulky HDMI cable, too.

Out of sight

There’s a lot to be said for a device you don’t have to look at. Not only does your TV’s transformation seem just a but more magical with a streaming stick, but its out-of-sight location behind your TV is far more discreet and convenient, too. With a streaming stick, you don’t have to be concerned with another black box taking up space on your already crowded equipment rack.

Easier installation

Since streaming sticks plug directly into a one of a TV’s HDMI ports, you’ll never have to worry about running another HDMI cable up to a TV, or deal with the hassle of snaking another power cord through your entertainment stand’s already rat-nested bundle of cords and cable. Streaming sticks get their power via USB, and since most TVs produced in the past few years have USB ports on them, there’s often no need to run any cables anywhere.

Price

The Chromecast, Fire TV Stick, and Roku Streaming stick cost $35, $39, and $50, respectively. By comparison, each devices set-top counterpart, the Nexus Player, Fire TV box, and Roku 3, cost $99. That means the least you save by going with a streaming stick is 50 percent, which also means you can hook up at least twice as many TVs.

Same interface

It would be fair to assume that, because streaming sticks are so small and inexpensive, that they might offer a watered-down experience, but that would be incorrect. Both the Fire TV Stick and the present version of the Roku Streaming stick offer the same user interface with access to the same apps and many of the same features.

Cons

Slower

Simply put, streaming sticks can’t house as much horsepower, due in part to their smaller size. Though the Amazon Fire TV Stick raises the bar for HDMI dongle hardware, it’s still half the hotrod the Fire TV set-top box is. As such, The Fire TV Stick, like the Roku Streaming stick, will be a little slower to navigate and load videos compared to its full-fledged set-top counterpart.

No Ethernet connection

Both the Roku 3 and Amazon Fire TV feature Ethernet connections, which provide a more stable and reliable streaming video experience. Wi-Fi is prone to interference and congestion in a way that Ethernet hard lines are not. For those houses where multiple video streams via Wi-Fi are common, or Wi-Fi dead spots are a problem, Ethernet is the best possible solution, but, sadly, not an option for streaming sticks.

Fewer connection options

With a streaming stick, you’ve got one connection possibility — HDMI to one port — and that’s it. Roku and Amazon both outfit their best set-top boxes with Toslink optical audio output ports, which can diversify connection options and, for many, dramatically improve sound quality. Sure, HDMI can handle all the latest audio signals, which can’t be said for Toslink, but if that HDMI stick is connected directly to a TV, that TV is going to downmix and crush the living daylights out of the audio signal before it passes it out through its own Toslink optical digital audio port. Unless you are using an A/V receiver for all of your audio and video switching needs, a set-top box is almost always going to be a better choice for those that care about sound quality.

No on-board decoding potential

Fair enough, set-top boxes don’t currently decode video files on their own, but they at least have the potential to. Just looking at Amazon’s Fire TV hardware, and it’s clear it is up to the task of taking videos straight off a storage drive and decoding them on its own, without the need for media software (like PLEX) and a computer to run it. This is something we could see in a future firmware update (yes, we’re optimistic!). On the other hand, streaming sticks have virtually zero chance of pulling off this function anytime within the next decade. And this isn’t the only hardware-based con.

No storage expansion potential

It’s amazing technology has come to a point where the Amazon Fire TV Stick can tout 8GB of storage space — blowing the Roku Streaming Stick away — but that 8GB is all you’ll ever get. As apps and games get more advanced, they’ll get bigger, and a set-top box will be able to accommodate them, a streaming stick never will.

At this point, you should have a gist for what makes streaming sticks and set-top boxes different. For casual users who want a quick and inexpensive fix, streaming sticks are great. And, frankly, they’re cheap enough to have one sitting around just in case. But if you consider yourself more of an enthusiast — a power user, even? — then the set-top box offers the sort of hardware and expansion potential that should help feed your tech-y need.

Available here:

Chromecast: Amazon, Walmart, BestBuy, Staples

Roku Streaming Stick: AmazonBestBuy, Office Depot, Walmart

Amazon Fire TV Stick: Amazon

Nexus Player: Google Play

Roku 3: Amazon, Walmart, Best Buy

Amazon Fire TV: Amazon

Product Review

Cut cable and keep quality with TiVo's 4K-friendly Bolt OTA DVR

Free over-the-air programming isn’t available in 4K, so why would you want a 4K OTA DVR? We’ll discuss what makes the new TiVo Bolt OTA a viable choice for cord-cutters with 4K UHD TVs who want to get ahead of the game.
Home Theater

Google Chromecast and Chromecast Ultra: Everything you need to know

Google's Chromecast plugs into your TV's HDMI port, allowing you to stream content from your tablet, laptop, or smartphone directly to your TV. Here's what you need to know about all iterations, including the 4K-ready Chromecast Ultra.
Home Theater

From the Roku Ultra to the Fire TV Cube, these are the best streaming devices

There are more options for media streamers than ever, so it’s more difficult to pick the best option. But that’s why we're here. Our curated list of the best streaming devices will get you online in no time.
Home Theater

What is MHL, exactly, and how does it work with your TV?

There are more ways to mirror your smartphone or tablet to your TV than you might think. Check out our rundown of MHL for everything you need to know about the wired protocol and its myriad uses.
Home Theater

Put your home theater to the test with these spectacular Blu-ray releases

What's the point of having all of that awesome home theater gear if you can't breed a little jealousy in your friends and family? We've put together this list of fantastic Blu-rays that have the goods to drop a few jaws.
Home Theater

Learn how to calibrate your home theater speakers for sheer audio bliss

Make your home theater rumble just right with our manual speaker setup guide, a simple, step-by-step walkthrough to getting the most from your audio equipment without needing to rely on imperfect automatic calibration.
Product Review

These AirPod look-alikes are better in every way but one

With silicone eartips, water resistance, and a more palatable price tag, Mobvoi’s Ticpods Free are impressive AirPod doppelgangers. But for all the great things they have going for them, there’s one flaw holding them back.
Home Theater

How to make your TV squeaky clean for not much green

Not sure how to clean the LCD, OLED, or plasma display that's the cornerstone of your living room? You don't need to buy expensive cleaning solutions to clean your TV -- we'll teach you how to do it with simple household items.
Home Theater

If you've got questions about Ultra HD Blu-ray, we've got answers

Ultra HD Blu-ray discs and players are a killer way to beef up your home theater. Here's everything you need to know about one of the most significant advances to hit home entertainment in years.
Deals

All the Best Target Black Friday deals for 2018

The mega-retailer opens its doors to the most competitive shoppers at 6 p.m. on Thursday, November 22, and signs indicate that the retailer means business this year. We've sifted through all of the deals, from consumer electronics to small…
Deals

The Best Black Friday Deals from Best Buy in 2018

We've been hard at work assembling all the best Black Friday deals Best Buy offers in 2018 and putting them in one place to save you time and money this holiday season. From laptops to TVs, game consoles to smart speakers and much more…
Home Theater

From game consoles to 4K UHD spinners, these are the best Blu-ray players

Streaming may be popular, but the disc isn't dead yet. To get the very best picture and sound quality from your system, you need to be watching Blu-ray or 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray discs, and these are the best Blu-ray players you can buy.
Home Theater

What’s new on Amazon Prime Video (December 2018)

Amazon Prime Video adds new titles each month that are available for free to all Prime members. Check out our list to find all the content hitting Amazon Prime Video in November and December 2018, from new original series to classic films.
Product Review

Hisense’s new H8E 4K TV serves up a pretty picture at a very nice price

Budget TVs continue to get more attractive and that includes the latest from Chinese TV maker Hisense. The company’s new H8E, which offers 4K resolution, HDR, and a slick design for well under $500.