Skip to main content

Exercise equipment that requires a subscription to work is the opposite of smart

The closures of gyms and concerns over community spread of COVID-19 in the past two years has resulted in a meteoric rise in smart home gym equipment. Much of this technology is innovative, award-winning, and holds promise for the future. That’s a very good thing.

But much of this technology is basic machinery that has been around for years. What’s worse is that its functionality is locked behind arbitrary subscription services that make the equipment nothing more than a heavy, expensive paperweight if you don’t subscribe.

And that’s nothing short of stupid.

A workout using The Mirror.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The rise of the pay-to-be-fit culture

Exercise equipment is expensive. It always has been; in fact, many words have been written on the frugality of purchasing exercise equipment secondhand to reduce its cost. A quick search shows an incredibly basic treadmill available for just over $160, but if you want a machine that allows you to train hard for a marathon, you’ll likely need to spend upwards of $300 or more. After all, you don’t want it to shatter after a few footfalls.

People who buy exercise equipment aren’t afraid of spending money on the equipment, but they do so with the expectation that they can use the device. Smart home gym equipment has changed the paradigm. Instead of paying once for a machine you can use whenever you want, you now pay once for the machine — and again, and again, and again for the monthly subscription. And without that subscription, the machine doesn’t work.

What part of that sounds smart?

The model makes sense for certain devices like the Mirror. Its purpose is to connect the user with guided classes that help improve form and technique. That’s not easy to do without a subscription, especially since one-on-one training is a possibility.

When it comes to something like an exercise bike, locking its functionality down behind a subscription is ridiculous. I tried out several, and each one would track distance, heart rate, and other health metrics during a class — but outside of a class, I could pedal all day long and it would record no information.

At that point, it felt smarter just to strap on a fitness watch (or even just use an iPhone with the Strava app) and hop on an actual bicycle than spend $1,500 or more on a piece of equipment that still charged on a recurring basis.

NordicTrack Studio Cycle in Home
Image used with permission by copyright holder

If you want to keep track of your health and fitness scores, you have to pay for it. In a world where physical health is under scrutiny more than ever before, that seems counterintuitive.

I’ll pay for a class, but metrics should be free

Guided classes and connected gym equipment are great, especially if your friends also use them. It adds a competitive element that helps keep you motivated and striving for better and better scores, and it certainly has a place in the world of smart gym equipment.

But it just feels greedy to not provide metric tracking for free. Standard, not-smart equipment can tell your heart rate, distance traveled, and estimate calories burned for half the cost of a smart exercise bike. A piece of smart exercise equipment that costs more than $1,500 should give you the option to cancel subscriptions without essentially bricking the entire machine.

Another aspect of the problem lies in what content is available. Sometimes, I want to jump on an exercise bike and put in a few miles without watching a class or trying to cycle to the beat of the music. Sometimes I want to throw on Netflix on my phone and watch a show while getting in a bit of light cardio. In some instances, even that isn’t an option.

If a machine offers guided classes and workouts, it should also offer unguided workouts. Every machine should have a free roam feature that tracks my heart rate. I don’t need a specialized background or a virtual tour of some far-off land to guide me as I cycle. Just give me a black background with all of the relevant metrics. It’s a simple ask.

Between apps like MyFitnessPal, the dozens of different exercise-specific tracking apps available on both the App Store and Google Play, and smart fitness wearables, the rest of the world seems dead-set on making it easy to keep up with your fitness. Why do exercise machines, even the smart ones, still feel so far behind?

Editors' Recommendations

Patrick Hearn
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Patrick Hearn writes about smart home technology like Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, smart light bulbs, and more. If it's a…
Capti smart bike ditches indoor biking boredom with games and realistic terrain
capti smart bike uses gaming enhance your workout heart rate training

With the colder months just around the corner, the last thing you want to do is go on a long bike ride -- especially if you don't have proper gear. For many people, riding a bike is their preferred form of cardio. The Capti Smart Bike lets you ride indoors, without having to brave the elements, but also without having to sacrifice the experience of varying terrain. Thanks to its Smart Ride technology, which features with dynamic steering and adaptive resistance, the Capti Smart Bike shifts between the feel of a road bike to a locked studio bike.

Capti monitors the ride and reacts 50 times per second, creating one of the most immersive riding experiences of any smart bike yet. It also features a large display that helps capture the feeling of being out on the road, even if you're in the comfort of your home. Think of it like one of those roller coaster simulators found at arcades: Not exactly the real thing, but pretty close.

Read more
The unfortunate part about connected fitness equipment for the home
best home gym equipment cycle 3 970x647 c  1

At-home fitness is booming as people look for ways to work out at home instead of the gym. Connected fitness equipment offers a way to replicate the gym experience by providing access to live online classes and training programs led by professional trainers. This smart home gym equipment is great as long as you continue paying the monthly subscription and maintain a robust internet connection. Once you stop paying the monthly fee or go offline, however, your smart gym suddenly becomes dumb. In some cases, you can't even use it anymore.

When a person is shopping for new connected fitness equipment, they often are wowed by the training software and the features that come with it. Customers are lured in by the slick interface and enthusiastic trainers that promise to whip them into shape.  People visualize themselves exercising along with an online class or a professional trainer. It's a powerful motivator. So powerful, many people get caught up in the hype and spend thousands on a piece of connected fitness gear without considering some of the drawbacks.
Subscriptions are a must
When users first start working out with their new equipment, the extra cost of a subscription is not a big deal. They spent a couple thousand -- what's a few dollars more each month. Owners also are excited to get started and will do whatever it takes to exercise and improve their fitness. They often push off that monthly charge to a credit card and forget about it.

Read more
Meet the exercise bike that wants you to play video games while working out
playpulse one has you play video games while workout youngprofessionals

Although games like Dance Dance Revolution and Beat Saber might make you work up a sweat, they technically aren't exercise games. For gamers who want to get in shape by pulling off dungeon-delving moves just like Lara Croft, there's another solution: The Playpulse One, a smart exercise bike that combines workout machine, game console, and entertainment center into one.

The Playpulse One uses high-precision sensors in the pedals and handlebars to make pedaling part of gameplay. It monitors your heart rate through the handlebars to provide you with measurable, accurate workout results. You'll know how hard you worked out and the number of calories you burn after every play session.

Read more