Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

Court orders Apple to pay buyer for missing iPhone charger

A regional court in Brazil has ordered Apple to compensate an iPhone buyer following a complaint about not getting a charger in the retail box. As per the court’s ruling, Apple will have to pay a sum of 5,000 Brazilian real, which translates to approximately $1,080 based on the current conversion rates, to the affected iPhone buyer.

The company will also add a 1% fee for each month since the court summons began, and a fine of approximately $21 for each day’s worth of delay in following the orders. And yeah, Apple will also provide a charger to the customer.

The court order classifies the charging adapter as a necessary item for operating a phone. More importantly, the judge labeled Apple’s no-charger policy as “abusive” to consumer rights. The court also lambasted Apple’s logic of skipping the inbox charger because it harms the environment.

Judge Vanderlei Caires Pinheiro, of the Goiânia 6th Special Civil Court, also noted that Apple’s environmental concerns are unfounded. And that’s because the company continues to make charging adapters and sells them separately. In fact, Apple now hawks two kinds of chargers — the traditional USB-C brick and the MagSafe puck.

Black iPhone 11 plugged into charger.
Andreas Haslinger / Unsplash

Not the first legal tussle over the charging brick

This is not the first time that Apple’s no charger policy has attracted scrutiny or punitive action in Brazil. Sao Paolo-based consumer protection regulator Procon-SP levied a fine of roughly $2 million on Apple for not including a charger in the iPhone 12’s retail package in March of last year.

A few months later,in October, the agency slapped Apple with another fine of around $2 million for repeating the offense with the iPhone 13 series phones. Procon-SP also asked Apple to ship iPhone 12 units with chargers in the state of Sao Paolo.

Apple’s latest legal tussle brings up the Consumer Protection Code, with the court’s order making it clear that forcing consumers to fork out extra money for buying a charger is unreasonable when the same can be supplied as a bundled accessory, of which there is a long history and an industrywide norm.

On the other hand, Apple has reaped healthy financial benefits by ditching the in-box charger. The company has reportedly saved over $6 billion by not including chargers and earphones in the retail package. Aside from the reduced cost, the smaller size of the box also saved Apple extra money on shipping and logistics-related expenses.

Fortunately,for Apple, the company will get away with paying just over a thousand dollars in its latest legal skirmish, because it was a single buyer knocking at the court’s door with a complaint. Had the case been granted class-action status, the company would have been forced to compensate all affected buyers participating in the legal proceedings.

In October of last year, five students hailing from the Beijing University of Chemical Technology and Donghua University filed a lawsuit against Apple over its no-charger policy, with the goal of elevating it to class-action status. Of course, Apple will spend every resource in its kitty to avoid such a scenario over its controversial charger policy, especially with the company’s lobbying expenses reaching a record high in 2022 over antitrust concerns.

Editors' Recommendations

Nadeem Sarwar
Nadeem is a tech journalist who started reading about cool smartphone tech out of curiosity and soon started writing…
After 3 days, I love these 4 things about the iPhone 15
A green iPhone 15 on a green bench.

Apple’s new iPhone 15 has hit the streets, and boy, it’s a pretty great upgrade from its predecessor. You now have the Dynamic Island, USB-C, an A16 Bionic processor, and a mighty 48MP main camera that can do up to 2x optical zoom. To top it off, the standard iPhone 15 models have a new matte finish back glass with color infused throughout the material.

I’ve only had the iPhone 15 for a few days now and will be working on the full review for Digital Trends in the coming days. But after just spending a couple of days with it, I’m already thoroughly impressed with the iPhone 15, even though I typically go for the Pro models myself.
The new matte back is absolutely lovely

Read more
Does the iPhone 15 have an overheating problem? Here’s what we know
Someone holding the Natural Titanium iPhone 15 Pro Max.

The Apple iPhone 15 and iPhone 15 series have been launched with much fanfare, but it seems that not all users are completely satisfied with the new handsets. Despite the many improvements and new features that come with these phones, users of both the iPhone 15 Pro and iPhone 15 have taken to social media to complain about overheating issues.

While this may not be a cause for immediate alarm, it is certainly something that Apple and its team of engineers will need to monitor closely, assuming there is a system-wide problem, which there might not be. The last thing anyone wants is for the new phones to become a safety hazard or for users to suffer damage to their devices.

Read more
4 things Android phones still do better than the iPhone 15
Clockwise from top: natural titanium iPhone 15 Pro, Nothing Phone 2, green iPhone 15, and Obsidian Black Google Pixel Fold.

The Apple iPhone 15 lineup is here, which includes the iPhone 15, iPhone 15 Plus, iPhone 15 Pro, and iPhone 15 Pro Max. The Dynamic Island and USB-C are now available across the lineup, the standard models get a big camera boost to 48MP, the Pros get the new Action button, and the Pro Max even has a fancy new tetraprism telephoto lens for 5x optical zoom.

While all of this sounds impressive, Apple’s iPhone lineup is still behind the competition. Android phones have had some of these features for a while now — and even do some things a lot better.
Faster USB-C charging

Read more